Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!
Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.
Race 1 Claiming 1100Y Dirt
Win: Ilikethat (7) – 67% confidence
Place: Elliot The Dragon (2) – 33% confidence
Show: Into Gold (1) – 33% confidence
Alternative: Lust For Life (4) – 17% confidence
Analysts largely agree that the top-end speed rests with the seven horse, though the one horse provides a credible threat if the pace collapses early. The lack of depth in the middle of the field suggests a top-heavy result is likely.
Race 2 Maiden Claiming 1320Y Dirt
Win: Justtakethecannoli (1) – 83% confidence
Place: Ruby River (3) – 67% confidence
Show: Hero Queen (6) – 50% confidence
Alternative: Jaganna (2) – 17% confidence
The consensus here is overwhelmingly in favor of the rail horse, who boasts the most consistent recent speed figures. Most analysts see a clear path for the three horse to follow into the exacta, creating a potentially low-payout but high-probability sequence.
Race 3 Claiming 8F Dirt
Win: Oaks Honey (3) – 50% confidence
Place: Raven Moon (4) – 33% confidence
Show: Hite (2) – 33% confidence
Alternative: Orville B (5) – 33% confidence
Opinion is split between several contenders in this mile test. While some analysts favor the recent form of the three horse, others believe the four horse is better suited for the distance. Expect a contested early pace.
Race 4 Claiming 1320Y Dirt
Win: Siofra (2) – 83% confidence
Place: Credit Check (8) – 50% confidence
Show: Rollin Freedom (6) – 33% confidence
Alternative: S’mor Crafty (4) – 17% confidence
The two horse is the clear choice across nearly all platforms, dropping in class to find a more manageable group. Analysts suggest the outside eight horse is the only runner with the tactical speed to challenge late.
Race 5 Claiming 1320Y Dirt
Win: J J Valentin (6) – 67% confidence
Place: Quarantino (11) – 67% confidence
Show: Ghostagain (3) – 33% confidence
Alternative: Parade Of Fears (5) – 17% confidence
A strong consensus has formed around a two-horse battle between the six and the eleven. The eleven horse is respected for consistency, but analysts slightly favor the six due to a more favorable pace setup.
Race 6 Claiming 1320Y Dirt
Win: She’s So Sexy (2) – 67% confidence
Place: Our Lady Peace (8) – 33% confidence
Show: Fiveminutsofpasion (7) – 50% confidence
Alternative: Lil Sweezey (4) – 17% confidence
The two horse is the most popular pick, but there is significant noise around the seven and eight horses. Analysts note that the two horse needs to overcome a poor last-out performance to justify this level of backing.
Race 7 Claiming 1320Y Dirt
Win: Silent Drill (3) – 50% confidence
Place: Stormed Out (1) – 67% confidence
Show: C V Jersey Bee (5) – 50% confidence
Alternative: A Van On The Run (8) – 17% confidence
This race presents a horizontal distribution of talent. While the one horse has the most high-placing mentions, analysts are split on whether the three horse can maintain its form. The five horse remains a dangerous alternative for the win spot.
Race 8 Starter Optional Claiming 8F Dirt
Win: Patriarchal (2) – 33% confidence
Place: Fivefive Six Champ (8) – 33% confidence
Show: Strava (7) – 33% confidence
Alternative: Afraidofthebunny (1) – 33% confidence
Opinion is completely fragmented in this optional claiming event. No single runner holds more than a third of the win or place support, suggesting a high-variance outcome where any of the top four could realistically take the prize.
Race 9 Allowance 8F Dirt
Win: Handsome Pants (1) – 50% confidence
Place: The Chalk (5) – 50% confidence
Show: Springhawk (2) – 33% confidence
Alternative: Jus Too Fly (4) – 33% confidence
The top two horses command most of the attention here. Analysts highlight the class drop for the one horse as a primary driver for its support, though the five horse remains a strong contender based on local track history.
Race 10 Allowance 8F Dirt
Win: Lucky’s Prize (7) – 67% confidence
Place: Duo (2) – 33% confidence
Show: Glory Reigns (9) – 33% confidence
Alternative: Jacobi (6) – 17% confidence
The card concludes with a relatively strong lean toward the seven horse. Most analysts believe the seven has a significant class edge over this field, though the two and nine horses are viewed as solid exotic inclusions.
Recommended Exotic Plays by Race
Race 1: Analysts suggest an Exacta Box featuring Ilikethat (7) and Elliot The Dragon (2). For larger budgets, a Trifecta using Ilikethat (7) on top of Elliot The Dragon (2), Into Gold (1), and Lust For Life (4) is recommended.
Race 2: Given the high confidence in Justtakethecannoli (1), analysts recommend a straight Exacta 1-3. A Superfecta 1 over 3 over 6 over 2 is also presented as a low-cost high-probability play.
Race 3: Analysts lean toward a 3-4-2 Exacta Box to cover the split in opinions. A Trifecta Box 2-3-4-5 is suggested for those looking to capture the value of the five horse.
Race 4: This is viewed as a “Key” race for Siofra (2). Analysts recommend an Exacta Part-Wheel 2 over 3, 6, 8. A Superfecta 2 over 8 over 6 over 3 is also noted.
Race 5: A 6-11 Exacta Box is the primary recommendation. For a more aggressive play, analysts suggest a Trifecta Part-Wheel 6, 11 over 6, 11 over 3, 5.
Race 6: With the wide distribution of picks, a 2-7-8 Trifecta Box is favored. Analysts also mention a 2-7 Exacta as a high-conviction play.
Race 7: Analysts recommend an Exacta Box 1-3-5. To capture the upset potential of the eight horse, a Trifecta 1, 3 over 1, 3, 5 over 5, 8 is suggested.
Race 8: Because of the fragmented opinion, analysts recommend a “spread” approach. A 1-2-7-8 Exacta Box or a 2-7-8 Trifecta Box is advised to account for the lack of a clear favorite.
Race 9: Analysts favor a 1-5 Exacta Box. A Trifecta 1, 5 over 1, 5 over 2, 4 is also highlighted as a likely finish order.
Race 10: Lucky’s Prize (7) is a strong single candidate. Analysts recommend an Exacta Part-Wheel 7 over 1, 2, 9. A Superfecta 7 over 2 over 9 over 1 is the suggested exotic construction.
Value Play Observations
In Race 1, Zakaria (5) appears as a significant overlay given the isolated win backing from some analysts while others omit the runner entirely. If the morning line remains high, this horse represents the best value to disrupt the chalky top two.
Race 3 sees Orville B (5) as a potential value play. While consensus is tepid, the individual backing for a win suggests the horse has a higher ceiling than the aggregate percentage indicates.
Race 4 offers S’mor Crafty (4) as an interesting alternative. With the field focused on the two and eight, the four horse could provide a massive boost to exotic payouts if it manages to hit the board at double-digit odds.
Race 6 features Fiveminutsofpasion (7) as a value-rich selection. Despite only moderate win support, its frequent appearance in show and alternative slots suggests it is a high-probability board hitter that may be overlooked in win-heavy pools.
In Race 8, the entire field is essentially a value proposition due to the lack of consensus. However, Sunset Town (6) is particularly notable as an under-the-radar selection that could reward bettors if the more popular Patriarchal (2) falters.
Overall Wagering Strategy
The racing card at Mahoning Valley presents a distinct bifurcated structure with several heavy favorites balanced against deep, contentious allowance fields. The strongest consensus of the day centers on Race 2 and Race 4, where the top selections command over 80 percent confidence from the analyst pool. These races serve as the logical anchors for multi-race wagers such as Pick 4 or Pick 5 sequences. In these instances, bettors should prioritize reliability and consider using these favorites as singles to minimize ticket costs while maximizing coverage in more volatile segments of the card.
Split-opinion races, particularly Race 3 and Race 7, demand a more nuanced approach. In these events, the analysts are divided between two or three primary contenders, each with legitimate claims to the win spot. This analytical tension suggests that the winner will likely be determined by trip and racing luck rather than a significant class advantage. For these races, horizontal strategies such as boxing the top three consensus picks or utilizing small exacta wheels are preferred over a single-horse focus.
Multi-race sequences are particularly attractive starting from Race 1 through Race 5, where consensus alignment remains relatively stable. The transition from the high-confidence claimers in the early card to the more unpredictable starter and allowance races in the late card creates a natural escalation of risk. Bettors should look to build equity in the early chalk-heavy races to fund more aggressive, wide-spread exotic combinations in the final three races of the day.
Exotic value opportunities are most prevalent in Race 6 and Race 8. These races feature high analytical variance, meaning the difference between the most favored and least favored horses is marginal. This environment is ideal for employing superfecta wheels or four-horse trifecta combinations to capture high-odds upsets. When the consensus is this fragmented, the pricing inefficiency typically rewards those who bet against the “soft” favorite in favor of consistent board-hitters with lower win frequencies.
Environmental factors, specifically the 10-degree temperature and dirt surface, likely favor horses with proven local form and those that can maintain heat during the warm-up. Track bias at Mahoning Valley often leans toward speed in shorter sprints, reinforcing the heavy support for the rail-drawn favorites in the early claiming races.
Key takeaways for this card include the necessity of using the one horse in Race 2 and the two horse in Race 4 as the foundation of any multi-race strategy. Secondly, bettors should remain cautious in Race 8, treating it as a wide-open event where no single horse can be safely excluded. Finally, the allowance races in the late card provide the best opportunity for value, as the consensus leans toward established class but allows room for developing horses to offer superior pricing.
