Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!
Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.
Race 1 – Starter Optional Claiming – 1320Y – Dirt
Win: FORGIVING SPIRIT (1) – 29% confidence
Place: RAVIN’S RANSOM (7) – 40% confidence
Show: RAVIN’S RANSOM (7) – 40% confidence
Alternative: TWENTY FOUR MAMBA (4) – 25% confidence
Race 1 presents a fragmented opinion among analysts. While FORGIVING SPIRIT (1) captures a slight lead for the win, RAVIN’S RANSOM (7) appears on almost every ticket, splitting time between Win, Place, and Show, suggesting high reliability for exotics but uncertainty for the top spot. The presence of TWENTY FOUR MAMBA (4) as a top choice for some analysts indicates potential for an upset or a value play against the morning line favorite.
Race 2 – Maiden Claiming – 8F – Dirt
Win: YOLO (3) – 57% confidence
Place: A. P. SLINGSHOT (7) – 60% confidence
Show: ROGUE JUSTICE (1) – 40% confidence
Alternative: KAT STORMY (4) – 50% confidence
There is strong agreement here on YOLO (3) as the horse to beat, securing the majority of win selections. A. P. SLINGSHOT (7) is the clear consensus choice for second, creating a very defined exacta structure. ROGUE JUSTICE (1) and KAT STORMY (4) consistently fill out the lower rungs of the trifecta and superfecta, making this a race with a very stable, predictable hierarchy according to the experts.
Race 3 – Allowance Optional Claiming – 1540Y – Dirt
Win: HEDGE RATIO (1) – 57% confidence
Place: IGNITER (4) – 40% confidence
Show: HONG KONG PHOOEY (5) – 60% confidence
Alternative: TARTABULL (2) – 25% confidence
HEDGE RATIO (1) commands the field with significant support for the win, while IGNITER (4) is the primary challenger, often picked to win or place. The most striking consensus is for HONG KONG PHOOEY (5) in the Show position; analysts consistently peg this horse to hit the board without winning. This creates a solid “key” opportunity for trifecta structures using 1 and 4 on top of 5.
Race 4 – Allowance Optional Claiming – 8F – Dirt
Win: THREE B’S (6) – 43% confidence
Place: SHADOW DRAGON (4) – 40% confidence
Show: SHADOW DRAGON (4) – 40% confidence
Alternative: WILLINTORISKITALL (3) – 25% confidence
This race features a competitive duel between THREE B’S (6) and HAGRID’S FLAME (1), though THREE B’S edges out the consensus for the top spot. SHADOW DRAGON (4) is a polarized horse, appearing frequently in Place and Show spots but rarely as the winner, suggesting it is a defensive use in exotics. The Alternative slot is wide open, indicating the superfecta may pay well if a longshot crashes the party.
Race 5 – Maiden Claiming – 1430Y – Dirt
Win: ANYWAY (1) – 43% confidence
Place: B PROVOCATEUR (5) – 40% confidence
Show: MACH SCHNELL (3) – 60% confidence
Alternative: B PROVOCATEUR (5) – 25% confidence
ANYWAY (1) is the tepid favorite in a chaotic race where opinions vary widely. While ANYWAY leads the win count, spread picks like TAMPA STORM (8) and B PROVOCATEUR (5) suggest vulnerability. MACH SCHNELL (3) is the standout “board hitter,” with high confidence for the Show spot. The lack of a dominant win consensus warns bettors to tread carefully or spread their tickets.
Race 6 – Claiming – 8F – Dirt
Win: JACKSON HEIGHTS (6) – 43% confidence
Place: MARKET MAVEN (1) – 40% confidence
Show: MARKET MAVEN (1) – 40% confidence
Alternative: FRIZZANTE (8) – 25% confidence
A fascinating split occurs here: while FRIZZANTE (8) and JACKSON HEIGHTS (6) battle for the win preference, the analysts are united in their uncertainty, with win votes scattered across four different horses. MARKET MAVEN (1) is the “glue” horse, appearing on nearly every ticket in the Place/Show slots. This race looks prime for a box bet rather than a straight win wager given the conflicting top opinions.
Race 7 – Maiden Special Weight – 1430Y – Dirt
Win: PRETTY BOY MIAH (4) – 43% confidence
Place: FELONIOUS (3) – 20% confidence
Show: PRETTY BOY MIAH (4) – 20% confidence
Alternative: MARBLE HALL (6) – 50% confidence
PRETTY BOY MIAH (4) emerges as the narrow favorite in a scramble of a race. Opinions on the minor awards are incredibly fragmented, with almost no agreement on who runs second or third. However, MARBLE HALL (6) has strong backing as a superfecta filler (Alternative), suggesting it may lack winning speed but has the stamina to plod into fourth.
Race 8 – Allowance Optional Claiming – 8F – Dirt
Win: WAVELESS (3) – 29% confidence
Place: SOUNDBITE (7) – 40% confidence
Show: WAVELESS (3) – 20% confidence
Alternative: SAILAWAY (5) – 25% confidence
This is one of the most open races on the card. Win votes are split nearly evenly between WAVELESS (3), KHALI MAGIC (8), and SOUNDBITE (7). SOUNDBITE (7) is the safest play, appearing most frequently in the top two slots combined. The lack of a clear favorite and the presence of live longshots like SAILAWAY (5) make this an excellent betting race for value seekers.
Race 9 – Maiden Claiming – 1540Y – Dirt
Win: TINSELTOWN (11) – 43% confidence
Place: KID RICH (8) – 40% confidence
Show: INTROUBLEAGAIN (6) – 20% confidence
Alternative: ALWAYS PACKEN (9) – 25% confidence
TINSELTOWN (11) holds a shaky consensus lead over KID RICH (8). The outer post for Tinseltown likely contributes to the hesitation among some analysts. The bottom of the ticket is murky, with very low confidence for Show and Alternative spots. This suggests a “top-heavy” approach, keying the 11 and 8, while hitting the “All” button for the third and fourth spots in exotics.
Recommended Exotic Plays by Race
Race 1
Exacta Box: 1, 7, 4 Trifecta Key: 1 over 2, 4, 7 over 2, 4, 7 Analysis: With Forgiving Spirit (1) and Ravin’s Ransom (7) anchoring most tickets, a small box captures the volatility of the win while covering the likely outcomes.
Race 2
Cold Exacta: 3 over 7 Trifecta Straight: 3 / 7 / 1, 4 Analysis: The data suggests a very predictable finish. Yolo (3) over A.P. Slingshot (7) is the strongest 1-2 punch on the card. Minimizing combinations here maximizes value.
Race 3
Trifecta Key: 1 over 4, 5 over 2, 4, 5 Pick 3 Starter: 1, 4 Analysis: Hedge Ratio (1) is a trusty anchor, but Igniter (4) is a must-use saver. The 5 horse is a “lock” for the bottom of the ticket, making trifectas structured as 1/4/5 very appealing.
Race 4
Superfecta Part-Wheel: 1, 6 with 1, 4, 6 with 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 with 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 Analysis: Three B’s (6) and Hagrid’s Flame (1) are the class. Using them to top a ticket while spreading deeper for 3rd and 4th allows you to catch a price like Willintoriskitall (3) underneath.
Race 5
Pick 5 Spread: 1, 3, 5, 8 Exacta Box: 1, 3, 5 Analysis: This is a “spread” race. No single horse commands enough authority to single. Covering the 1, 3, 5, and 8 ensures survival in multi-race sequences.
Race 6
Trifecta Box: 1, 6, 8, 9 Analysis: With four different horses receiving win votes, a box is the safest play. Market Maven (1) is a reliable board hitter who boosts the payout if he sneaks into second.
Race 7
Exacta Key Box: 4 with 1, 3, 6, 8 Analysis: Pretty Boy Miah (4) is the most likely winner, but the field behind him is messy. Keying him in the exacta with a spread of contenders covers the confusion for second place.
Race 8
Win/Place: 7 (Soundbite) Exacta Box: 3, 7, 8 Analysis: Soundbite (7) offers the best balance of probability and price. Boxing him with the other two main contenders (3, 8) covers the likely winning combinations.
Race 9
Double: 3, 7, 8 (from Race 8) with 8, 11 Superfecta: 8, 11 over 8, 11 over 5, 6, 9 over All Analysis: End the day by narrowing the focus to Kid Rich (8) and Tinseltown (11). They stand well above the rest. Getting a longshot into 3rd or 4th is the key to a payoff here.
Value Play Observations
Race 1: TWENTY FOUR MAMBA (4) While Forgiving Spirit is the morning line favorite, multiple sharp analysts (Serling, Racing Dudes) have tipped Twenty Four Mamba for the win. If he floats above 5-1, he represents significant overlay value compared to his analyst backing.
Race 3: HONG KONG PHOOEY (5) This horse is a “Show” pony specialist in the consensus. With a Morning Line of 8-1, he is an excellent candidate for vertical wagers (underneath in exactas/trifectas). The market may ignore him for the win, inflating his exotic payouts.
Race 5: TAMPA STORM (8) Listed at 8-1 on the Morning Line, Tampa Storm is the top pick for Marketwise and a Place pick for Serling. The general public may overlook him in favor of the Pletcher trainee (Anyway), creating an overlay opportunity.
Race 6: MARKET MAVEN (1) Despite being a 5-1 shot, this horse appears on almost every expert’s ticket. He is statistically undervalued by the line relative to his probability of hitting the board. He is a prime “key” horse for exotics.
Race 8: SAILAWAY (5) At 8-1 ML, Sailaway is a “sneaky chance” mentioned by multiple sources and consistently hits the bottom of tickets. In a race with split win opinions, a horse like this often picks up the pieces for a big Place or Show payout.
Overall Wagering Strategy
Strongest Consensus Races
The clearest path to profitability today lies in Race 2 and Race 3. In Race 2, YOLO (3) commands 57% of the win vote and is supported by a robust consensus for the runner-up, providing a rigid, predictable structure for exactas. Similarly, HEDGE RATIO (1) in Race 3 is a standout single, with 57% confidence. These two races act as the “free squares” in horizontal sequences (Pick 3/4/5), allowing bettors to allocate budget elsewhere.
Split-Opinion Races
Race 6 and Race 8 represent the analytical bottlenecks of the card. In Race 6, the divide between FRIZZANTE (8) and JACKSON HEIGHTS (6) is stark, with MARKET MAVEN (1) acting as a spoiler. In Race 8, the win vote is fractured three ways. Wagering strategy here demands coverage; attempting to “get skinny” or single a horse in these legs is a high-risk proposition. These are the races where Pick N tickets often die; treat them with respect and spread your capital.
Multi-Race Sequences
The Early Pick 4 (Races 2-5) offers the highest probability of success. You have a potential single in Race 2 (Yolo) and Race 3 (Hedge Ratio). This allows for deep coverage in Race 4 (a two-horse duel) and Race 5 (a chaotic spread race). By leveraging the conviction in legs 1 and 2, you can afford to buy the “All” button or spread widely in the difficult Race 5 without breaking the bank.
Exotic Value Opportunities
Race 5 is the prime target for high-yield exotic payouts. The favorite (Anyway) has a low confidence score (43%), and opinions on the placings are widely divergent. This structural instability often leads to “blowout” prices in the trifecta and superfecta. Utilizing a “Key Box” strategy—using a mid-priced horse like MACH SCHNELL (3) or TAMPA STORM (8) with the field—capitalizes on the confusion.
Environmental/Track Factors
The forecast calls for 36°F temperatures, which will keep the dirt track tight. Cold weather at Aqueduct often favors speed on the inner track, but pay attention to the early races (1 and 2). If the rail is dead (horses winning from the outside), downgrade rail-drawn horses like ROGUE JUSTICE (1) in Race 2. Conversely, if inside speed is holding, upgrade HEDGE RATIO (1) in Race 3 significantly.
Key Takeaways
- Anchor the Early Pick 5: Use Yolo (R2) and Hedge Ratio (R3) as your foundational pillars. Their consensus backing is the strongest on the card.
- Attack Race 5 for Price: Do not settle for the favorite in Race 5. The data indicates this race is ripe for an upset; spread your bets to include 8-1 and 12-1 shots.
- Defensive Betting in Race 6 & 8: These are high-variance races. Avoid Win bets and focus on Exacta Boxes or Trifectas that pay out regardless of which of the top three contenders crosses the line first.
