Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Consensus Expert Picks for Will Rogers Downs, February 23, 2026.


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.

RACE 1 CLAIMING 1320Y DIRT

Win: EVERYONE NOS WENDY (6) – 57% confidence

Place: SANGRIA SUNSET (4) – 43% confidence

Show: FROM THE TOP ROPE (3) – 43% confidence

Alternative: GOSPEL FABULOUS (5) – 14% confidence

Race Notes: The consensus indicates a two-horse race at the top. While one analyst favors a class drop for a challenger, the majority of analysts prefer the recent form of the top selection. Significant show support for the three-horse suggests it is a reliable part of the frame.


RACE 2 CLAIMING 1210Y DIRT

Win: BLAME DA STOOPS (4) – 100% confidence

Place: NORWAY BEACH (6) – 57% confidence

Show: DEN’S DYNASTY (3) – 57% confidence

Alternative: LEVIATHAN AXE (1) – 29% confidence

Race Notes: This represents the strongest consensus on the card. Every analyst agrees on the win selection, viewing the horse as a standout in this claiming group. The underneath positions are also remarkably stable among analyst opinions.


RACE 3 CLAIMING 8F DIRT

Win: GRAND PRAIRIE GAL (5) – 50% confidence

Place: GRACE GIVEN (4) – 38% confidence

Show: PURE CONNECTION (1) – 38% confidence

Alternative: LOOKIN LUCKY AGAIN (2) – 13% confidence

Race Notes: Analysts are divided in this mile event. Some analysts emphasize the weight of recent wins, while others focus on class drops. The five-horse holds a slight edge in win-purpose selections, but the four and one are closely bunched.


RACE 4 CLAIMING 1320Y DIRT

Win: DEVIOUS LOVER (9) – 100% confidence

Place: MCMUSIC (1) – 50% confidence

Show: FASTENED (7) – 33% confidence

Alternative: STUNNING BRUNO (2) – 33% confidence

Race Notes: Another unanimous win selection from the analyst pool. Most analysts agree the top choice has a tactical advantage coming off a recent placed effort. The minor placings show some variance, particularly regarding the ability of the seven-horse.


RACE 5 CLAIMING 1210Y DIRT

Win: DEVIOUS DIVA (2) – 83% confidence

Place: SUPRISING CODE (1) – 50% confidence

Show: RAINBOW SMILES (6) – 50% confidence

Alternative: CALLITFATELUCKARMA (5) – 17% confidence

Race Notes: Analysts view the two-horse as a high-probability winner despite a layoff. There is a strong secondary consensus for the one-horse to occupy the exacta spot, though analysts note the consistent hitting of the six-horse in this distance.


RACE 6 MAIDEN SPECIAL WEIGHT 1210Y DIRT

Win: BAILEY SIOUX (4) – 100% confidence

Place: BRIELLE (2) – 50% confidence

Show: GOSPEL SHARE (3) – 33% confidence

Alternative: CHITOZ STORM CAT (1) – 33% confidence

Race Notes: The analyst community is in total agreement regarding the four-horse breaking through today. Opinions on the place position are slightly more split, with a subset of analysts highlighting the two-horse as the primary threat.


RACE 7 CLAIMING 1320Y DIRT

Win: FLASH HUMOR (1) – 50% confidence

Place: FINE TUNED (4) – 50% confidence

Show: KNOCKEM OUT JERRY (3) – 50% confidence

Alternative: SMACKDOWN (6) – 33% confidence

Race Notes: This is a highly contentious race where analysts are essentially split into three camps. One group of analysts backs the tactical speed of the one, while another prefers the consistency of the four. The three-horse is also considered a win-capable contender.


RACE 8 ALLOWANCE 8F DIRT

Win: GUAPO (3) – 83% confidence

Place: VESTES (2) – 33% confidence

Show: BOURBON LIFE (1) – 33% confidence

Alternative: MISSING CODE (4) – 17% confidence

Race Notes: A dominant consensus exists for the three-horse based on superior recent speed figures. Analysts suggest the battle for the minor awards is much more wide-open, with the two and one horses drawing equal support for the underneath slots.


RACE 9 CLAIMING 8F DIRT

Win: ABSAROKA (2) – 83% confidence

Place: PRINCE RAMA (3) – 50% confidence

Show: OUTLIER (6) – 50% confidence

Alternative: HAMAZING WISDOM (7) – 33% confidence

Race Notes: Analysts conclude the card with high confidence in the two-horse, citing its track specialty. The place and show positions are a toss-up between the three and six, with analysts noting the distance increase for the latter.


RECOMMENDED EXOTIC PLAYS BY RACE

Race 1: Analysts recommend an Exacta Box using EVERYONE NOS WENDY (6) and SANGRIA SUNSET (4). For Trifecta players, include FROM THE TOP ROPE (3) and GOSPEL FABULOUS (5) in the third slot to cover potential pace meltdowns.

Race 2: Given the unanimous selection of BLAME DA STOOPS (4), analysts suggest a Straight Trifecta 4 over 6 over 3. For a more conservative play, a Cold Exacta 4-6 is recommended.

Race 3: This race presents a “spread” opportunity. Analysts suggest a Trifecta Box featuring GRAND PRAIRIE GAL (5), GRACE GIVEN (4), and PURE CONNECTION (1), as no single horse has established dominance in the analyst projections.

Race 4: Analysts propose using DEVIOUS LOVER (9) as a “key” in Superfecta plays. A recommended structure is 9 with 1, 7 with 1, 7, 2, 5 with 1, 7, 2, 5 to capture value in the lower rungs of the exotic.

Race 5: An Exacta Key is suggested here. Analysts recommend playing DEVIOUS DIVA (2) on top of SUPRISING CODE (1) and RAINBOW SMILES (6).

Race 6: Analysts favor a Trifecta Key with BAILEY SIOUX (4) over BRIELLE (2), GOSPEL SHARE (3), and CHITOZ STORM CAT (1). The high confidence in the winner allows for a concentrated exotic spend.

Race 7: Due to the split opinion, analysts recommend a three-horse Exacta Box involving FLASH HUMOR (1), FINE TUNED (4), and KNOCKEM OUT JERRY (3). This covers the most likely combinations in a volatile race.

Race 8: Analysts suggest a Daily Double starting here, using GUAPO (3) to link into the final race. For the individual race, a Trifecta 3 with 2, 1 with 2, 1, 4, 5 is recommended.

Race 9: Analysts propose an Exacta Box with ABSAROKA (2) and PRINCE RAMA (3). For those looking for a bigger payout, include HAMAZING WISDOM (7) in a 2, 3, 6, 7 Superfecta box.


VALUE PLAY OBSERVATIONS

In Race 1, SANGRIA SUNSET (4) offers value if the public over-bets EVERYONE NOS WENDY (6). While several analysts picked the six to win, the four received nearly equal top-line billing from a significant subset of the panel.

Race 7 features FLASH HUMOR (1) at 4-1 morning line odds, which analysts believe is an overlay. With 50% of the analyst pool selecting this horse to win, the mathematical probability assigned by analysts is higher than the implied probability of the odds.

In Race 8, BOURBON LIFE (1) is listed as a potential value play. Despite some analysts slotting the horse in the alternative or show position, its consistent ability to hit the board suggests it may be overlooked by the betting public in favor of more obvious speed.

HAMAZING WISDOM (7) in Race 9 is identified as a live longshot. One analyst has this horse on top, suggesting that if the heavy favorites falter in the nightcap, this runner is the most likely to provide a significant price.


OVERALL WAGERING STRATEGY

The card at Will Rogers Downs on February 23 features several races with high-conviction favorites, balanced by a few critical sequences where opinion is deeply divided. The strongest consensus races are found in Race 2, Race 4, and Race 6, where analyst confidence in the top selection reaches 100%. In these instances, Blame Da Stoops (4), Devious Lover (9), and Bailey Sioux (4) are viewed as nearly essential foundations for any multi-race ticket. These horses command consensus backing due to a combination of class relief, superior recent speed figures, and tactical versatility in their respective fields.

Split-opinion races occur primarily in Race 3 and Race 7. In Race 3, the tension lies between the recent winning form of Grace Given (4) and the perceived class edge of Grand Prairie Gal (5). Race 7 is even more fractured, with analysts equally split between Flash Humor (1), Fine Tuned (4), and Knockem Out Jerry (3). This analytical tension suggests that these races are the primary “chaos” points of the card where spread strategies are required to survive multi-race sequences.

Strategic construction for multi-race sequences should focus on a Pick 4 beginning in Race 6 and ending in Race 9. This sequence benefits from two “anchor” horses: Bailey Sioux (4) in the first leg and Absaroka (2) in the final leg. By keying these two high-confidence selections, bettors can afford to spread deeper in Race 7 and Race 8. This approach maximizes the potential to catch a mid-priced winner in the middle legs while keeping the overall ticket cost manageable.

Exotic value opportunities are most prevalent in the claiming sprints, specifically Race 1 and Race 5. In these categories, the unpredictability of older claiming horses often leads to pricing inefficiencies. Analysts recommend using superfecta wheels in Race 4 and Race 5, as the heavy favorites are likely to win, but the secondary and tertiary positions are often filled by overlays that the public ignores. Capturing these upset pieces in the bottom of the trifecta or superfecta is the most efficient way to generate a high ROI on this specific card.

Environmental factors remain standard for the dirt surface, though analysts note the shorter distances in the middle of the card may favor early speed if the track develops a rail bias. Bettors should monitor the first two races for any indication that front-runners are holding an unfair advantage. Key takeaways for the day include prioritizing the three “unanimous” analyst picks as singles, spreading in the seventh race to avoid a sequence-ending upset, and looking for value in the place/show pools where analyst consensus is less rigid.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback