Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!
Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.
Race 1 Claiming 1320 Yards 11:15am
Win: SUPREME SONG (7) – 20% confidence
Place: EXCHANGE DAY (4) – 40% confidence
Show: STAR SHOPPING (1) – 40% confidence
Alternative: MAKING ME CRAZY (9) – 20% confidence
Analysts have divergent views on the win candidate for the opener, likely due to a group of class droppers with varying recent form. The high percentage for the place and show positions suggests these horses are reliable exotic fillers even if they fail to secure the win.
Race 2 Allowance 1210 Yards 11:43am
Win: GETAWAY BAY (1) – 80% confidence
Place: TRICKY TIGER (4) – 40% confidence
Show: EL MUCHACHO ALEGRE (3) – 40% confidence
Alternative: DEFENDING ALBERT (5) – 20% confidence
Strong consensus aligns on the top selection here, indicating a significant talent gap between the favorite and the rest of the field. This race provides a potential anchor for early multi-race sequences given the overwhelming analyst support.
Race 3 Claiming 1320 Yards 12:11pm
Win: CREDIT CHECK (2) – 100% confidence
Place: OLYMPIC WINGS (7) – 60% confidence
Show: COUSIN MINNIE (3) – 60% confidence
Alternative: EXTRA CRAFTY (1) – 20% confidence
A rare unanimous consensus on the winner highlights a standout performer in this claiming event. The secondary positions are also well-supported, suggesting a chalky finish is likely for the trifecta.
Race 4 Claiming 8 Furlongs 12:39pm
Win: SHE’S CRAFTY (6) – 40% confidence
Place: KINGDOM TRAILS (1) – 40% confidence
Show: CHANEL SPIRIT (4) – 40% confidence
Alternative: MOBIL CHIC (5) – 20% confidence
Analysts are split between several viable options, creating a competitive wagering landscape. This lack of a dominant favorite indicates potential value if the public overbets one of the co-contenders.
Race 5 Allowance 1320 Yards 01:07pm
Win: FIRST KISS EVER (4) – 100% confidence
Place: SPECIAL COLLETTE (1) – 20% confidence
Show: IT’S BROWNS TIME (6) – 40% confidence
Alternative: CAT’S CRADLE (7) – 40% confidence
The field faces another formidable favorite with unanimous analyst backing. While the win spot seems secure, the battle for the minor awards is wide open with several analysts looking at different horses to fill the exotics.
Race 6 Claiming 8 Furlongs 01:35pm
Win: PANTHERA’S FATE (4) – 60% confidence
Place: THIRD CITY (2) – 40% confidence
Show: KADESH (3) – 40% confidence
Alternative: MORE THAN FIVE (1) – 20% confidence
Solid majority support for the top pick suggests a horse in peak form. Analysts seem to agree on the top three runners, pointing toward a concentrated wagering strategy on the main contenders.
Race 7 Allowance 8 Furlongs 02:03pm
Win: COWGIRLTAKEMEAWAY (6) – 40% confidence
Place: MOBIL DREAM STAR (3) – 40% confidence
Show: LIL SHARPIE (4) – 40% confidence
Alternative: EBONY’S SECRET (1) – 20% confidence
This race presents a tiered opinion where three horses share the bulk of the support. The tension between the consistent place-hitters and the recent winners creates an interesting dynamic for exacta wagering.
Race 8 Maiden Special Weight 1320 Yards 02:31pm
Win: MAXIMUM AGENDA (8) – 40% confidence
Place: RUN BOBBY RUN (3) – 40% confidence
Show: UNBRIDLED O’BRIEN (9) – 40% confidence
Alternative: ROLLIN FOR REAL (5) – 20% confidence
The finale is a standard maiden puzzle where analysts have identified the main trio of contenders but disagree on the exact order of finish. This provides a good opportunity for a boxed exotic play to cover the various permutations.
Recommended Exotic Plays by Race
Race 1: Exacta box using EXCHANGE DAY (4) and SUPREME SONG (7). A defensive Trifecta adding STAR SHOPPING (1) and MAKING ME CRAZY (9) in the third spot is advised given the spread of opinions.
Race 2: Cold Exacta 1-4. For deeper exotics, play a Trifecta of GETAWAY BAY (1) over TRICKY TIGER (4) and DEFENDING ALBERT (5) / EL MUCHACHO ALEGRE (3).
Race 3: Strategic anchor race. Exacta 2 over 7 and 3. Trifecta 2 / 7, 3 / 7, 3, 1 to capture the high-confidence selections.
Race 4: Exacta box 1 and 6. Superfecta enthusiasts should consider a 1, 6 / 1, 6, 4 / 1, 4, 5, 6 / ALL wheel to handle the analytical variance in this field.
Race 5: Exacta 4 over 1 and 6. Use CAT’S CRADLE (7) in the show spot of a Trifecta for potential value.
Race 6: Exacta 4 over 2 and 3. Analysts suggest a tight finish among the top three, making a Trifecta box of 4, 2, 3 a viable play.
Race 7: Exacta box 6 and 3. For more coverage, include LIL SHARPIE (4) in a three-horse Exacta box.
Race 8: Trifecta box 8, 3, and 9. This covers the main consensus contenders in what analysts view as a competitive maiden closer.
Value Play Observations
In Race 1, SUPREME SONG (7) and MAKING ME CRAZY (9) both show up as win candidates for single analysts while being ignored by others. This creates an overlay opportunity if their odds drift higher than the more commonly cited EXCHANGE DAY (4).
In Race 4, CHANEL SPIRIT (4) is a notable value play. While some analysts view the horse as a win threat, others have it in the show spot or omitted entirely. If the morning line is high, this horse represents a significant pricing inefficiency compared to its assessed probability of winning.
In Race 8, MAXIMUM AGENDA (8) attracts support from several analysts but may be overlooked by the betting public in favor of more established form lines. Analysts suggest this newcomer or less-exposed runner could offer a better return than the favorites.
Conversely, GETAWAY BAY (1) in Race 2 and CREDIT CHECK (2) in Race 3 are likely to be heavy underlays. With nearly unanimous analyst support, their win odds will likely be hammered, making them poor value for win bets but necessary components for multi-race structures.
Overall Wagering Strategy
The racing card at Mahoning Valley is dominated by several high-confidence anchors that should dictate the structure of most wagering portfolios. Analyst consensus reaches its peak in Race 3 and Race 5, where both top selections command unanimous support. These races should be utilized as the foundations for Pick 3 and Pick 4 sequences. In Race 2 and Race 6, the consensus remains strong at 80% and 60% respectively, further reinforcing a strategy that prioritizes narrow, heavy-hitting tickets in the middle of the card.
Races 1, 4, and 7 represent the primary areas of analytical tension. In these events, analysts are divided among multiple contenders with no single horse capturing a majority of the win votes. In Race 4 specifically, the 40/40 split between the top two choices suggests that bettors should use both horses in horizontal wagers to avoid being knocked out by a legitimate co-favorite. These “spread” races are where the value will be found, particularly if a secondary analyst choice can upset a narrowly preferred public favorite.
For multi-race sequences, a Pick 4 starting in Race 2 appears particularly attractive given the strength of the anchors in the first and third legs. The sequence 1 / 2 / 1, 6 / 4 provides a high-probability path through the middle of the card with minimal investment. For the later Pick 3 starting in Race 6, analysts suggest a slightly wider approach in the final two legs to account for the split opinions in the allowance and maiden races.
Bettors should focus on two primary takeaways for this card. First, the high-confidence winners in the claiming and allowance ranks provide an excellent opportunity for aggressive multi-race plays. Second, the variance in the maiden and opening claiming races requires a structural approach to exotics, such as boxes or wheels, to capitalize on the lack of a clear dominant runner. By balancing these “sure things” with calculated coverage in the more volatile races, bettors can maximize their potential return while managing risk across the entire program.
