Pick Pony AI Picks and Predictions Tip Sheet – Horseshoe Indianapolis, May 19, 2026


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

 

Pick Pony's AI picks work best when used with our Past Performance reports to enhance your handicapping and are especially effective for identifying potential longshot selections. You can purchase custom Past Performance reports through one of our subscription options. Learn more about Pick Pony's Past Performance reports here. We also provide handpicked Expert Picks from Pick Pony's analysts.

Remember: Our AI models trend towards value. When deciding whether to bet a horse to win, place, or show, always look for value in the odds (read our article on betting and odds for more information).

Algo Picks – Algo 1
 
Race 1
Win:1 – Magnus Gold (3/1)
Place:7 – Pro Fever (2/1)
Show:2 – Silent Tone (7/2)
Other contenders:6 – Red So O Lo (9/2), 5 – Unresponsive (10/1)
Rest of field:4 – Johnny Ringo (12/1), 3 – Rich Lover (15/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 2-7-1-6-5-4
🎯 Longshots: 7-4-6-1-3-5-2
 
Race 2
Win:2 – Swift Bee (5/2)
Place:3 – Lotta Latte (3/1)
Show:5 – Fifth Wheel (9/2)
Other contenders:6 – Happy Match (4/1), 1 – Mitole's Secret (6/1)
Rest of field:4 – Daddys Dreamin (5/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 5-3-6-2-4-1
🎯 Longshots: 3-2-5-4-6-1
 
Race 3
Win:4 – Tarzana (8/5)
Place:3 – Quality View (9/5)
Show:2 – Really Fancy River (4/1)
Other contenders:6 – Rhapsody In Blue (10/1), 5 – My Secret Dreams (8/1)
Rest of field:1 – Stevie Rae (12/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 4-3-2-6-1-5
🎯 Longshots: 4-3-2-5-1-6
 
Race 4
Win:5 – Texas Cyclone (5/2)
Place:4 – Midnight Vengeance (9/5)
Show:3 – Great Sword (4/1)
Other contenders:2 – Purdy Darn Good (7/2), 7 – Veneno Futuro (8/1)
Rest of field:6 – Only Frank Knows (20/1), 1 – Howard's Grit (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 5-3-2-7-6-1
🎯 Longshots: 4-5-2-3-7-6-1
 
Race 5
Win:10 – Boitano (8/5)
Place:6 – Takeitandrun (4/1)
Show:2 – Shankar (10/1)
Other contenders:7 – Frosty The Soldier (15/1), 4 – Woodcock Flight (9/2), 1 – Streamsong (20/1)
Rest of field:8 – Revs Medal (20/1), 3 – On Palm Sunday (12/1), 9 – Zach (12/1), 5 – Havegunswilltravel (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 9-10-3-2-7-1
🎯 Longshots: 10-6-2-4-1-7-3-9-8-5
 
Race 6
Win:8 – Hickman Creek (9/5)
Place:1 – Hyperlink (7/2)
Show:7 – Bhatia (6/1)
Other contenders:6 – Mr. All In (8/1), 5 – Payton's Hammer (5/1), 4 – Akkadian (10/1)
Rest of field:2 – Senor Valentine (15/1), 3 – El Tio (10/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 8-7-1-6-5-2
🎯 Longshots: 8-1-4-6-3-5-7-2
 
Race 7
Win:9 – Eltinge (3/1)
Place:10 – Turbo Lady (7/2)
Show:6 – Sweet Jannaelise (15/1)
Other contenders:12 – Goody Two Socks (10/1), 8 – Prettyontheprarie (15/1), 11 – Estrella Brillante (8/1), 2 – That'smydaughter (10/1)
Rest of field:5 – Echo Dreamer (5/1), 13 – J's Naughty Kitten (15/1), 1 – Tamarac Square (20/1), 3 – Over And Above (30/1), 4 – Total Luna Eclipse (20/1), 7 – Band Band (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 8-12-9-10-5-6
🎯 Longshots: 9-12-11-10-8-5-2-6-13-4-1-3-7
 
Race 8
Win:9 – Bullet Journal (7/2)
Place:10 – Long Live (5/2)
Show:11 – Ability (6/1)
Other contenders:3 – Ronilla (10/1), 7 – Miso Speedy (8/1), 4 – Live Life (12/1), 8 – Lazy Y Legacy (10/1)
Rest of field:2 – Click Here (8/1), 6 – Minstrelly (15/1), 5 – Senora D'oro (20/1), 1 – Evie's Eyebrows (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 1-8-6-4-9-11
🎯 Longshots: 7-9-10-2-4-11-8-3-5-6-1
 
Race 9
Win:5 – Disko Lady (3/1)
Place:4 – Keenies Final Gift (9/2)
Show:7 – Last Game Lady (2/1)
Other contenders:3 – Mg Kangura (12/1), 6 – Jess Knew (10/1), 10 – Beach Chickz (20/1)
Rest of field:2 – One Apollitical Dash (10/1), 1 – Super Shiny (15/1), 9 – Dna Zoomers Cyber (20/1), 8 – Gold Kings Mawnee (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 4-5-7-2-6-10
🎯 Longshots: 5-4-7-3-2-1-6-9-10-8
 
AI Weight Settings
Speed: 20, FPS: 15, FPS Midpoint: 10, FPS Late: 10, Pace Last 3: 10, Pace Last Race: 15, Early Pace: 10, Mid Pace: 10, Late Pace: 20, Post Position: 10, PPPP Rating: 15, Average Finish: 10, Days Since Last Race: 10, Jockey: 14, Trainer: 14, Track Bias: 15, Morning Line: 14, Pedigree: 51, Works: 5, Weight: 15, Medications: 20, Weather: 10, Race Trouble: 50, Last Race: 10, Last Three Races: 15, All Races: 10, Best Race: 5, Proprietary AI: 5,
Algo Picks – Algo 2
 
Race 1
Win:1 – Magnus Gold (3/1)
Place:7 – Pro Fever (2/1)
Show:2 – Silent Tone (7/2)
Other contenders:6 – Red So O Lo (9/2), 5 – Unresponsive (10/1)
Rest of field:4 – Johnny Ringo (12/1), 3 – Rich Lover (15/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 2-7-1-6-5-4
🎯 Longshots: 7-4-6-1-3-5-2
 
Race 2
Win:2 – Swift Bee (5/2)
Place:3 – Lotta Latte (3/1)
Show:6 – Happy Match (4/1)
Other contenders:5 – Fifth Wheel (9/2), 1 – Mitole's Secret (6/1)
Rest of field:4 – Daddys Dreamin (5/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 3-2-5-6-1-4
🎯 Longshots: 3-2-5-4-6-1
 
Race 3
Win:4 – Tarzana (8/5)
Place:3 – Quality View (9/5)
Show:2 – Really Fancy River (4/1)
Other contenders:5 – My Secret Dreams (8/1), 6 – Rhapsody In Blue (10/1)
Rest of field:1 – Stevie Rae (12/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 4-3-2-5-6-1
🎯 Longshots: 4-3-2-5-1-6
 
Race 4
Win:4 – Midnight Vengeance (9/5)
Place:5 – Texas Cyclone (5/2)
Show:2 – Purdy Darn Good (7/2)
Other contenders:3 – Great Sword (4/1), 7 – Veneno Futuro (8/1)
Rest of field:6 – Only Frank Knows (20/1), 1 – Howard's Grit (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 5-2-3-7-4-6
🎯 Longshots: 4-5-2-3-7-6-1
 
Race 5
Win:10 – Boitano (8/5)
Place:6 – Takeitandrun (4/1)
Show:4 – Woodcock Flight (9/2)
Other contenders:2 – Shankar (10/1), 7 – Frosty The Soldier (15/1), 1 – Streamsong (20/1)
Rest of field:8 – Revs Medal (20/1), 3 – On Palm Sunday (12/1), 9 – Zach (12/1), 5 – Havegunswilltravel (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 9-10-3-2-1-7
🎯 Longshots: 10-6-2-4-1-7-3-9-8-5
 
Race 6
Win:8 – Hickman Creek (9/5)
Place:1 – Hyperlink (7/2)
Show:5 – Payton's Hammer (5/1)
Other contenders:7 – Bhatia (6/1), 6 – Mr. All In (8/1), 4 – Akkadian (10/1)
Rest of field:3 – El Tio (10/1), 2 – Senor Valentine (15/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 8-7-1-5-6-2
🎯 Longshots: 8-1-4-6-3-5-7-2
 
Race 7
Win:9 – Eltinge (3/1)
Place:10 – Turbo Lady (7/2)
Show:5 – Echo Dreamer (5/1)
Other contenders:2 – That'smydaughter (10/1), 11 – Estrella Brillante (8/1), 12 – Goody Two Socks (10/1), 13 – J's Naughty Kitten (15/1)
Rest of field:8 – Prettyontheprarie (15/1), 1 – Tamarac Square (20/1), 6 – Sweet Jannaelise (15/1), 4 – Total Luna Eclipse (20/1), 3 – Over And Above (30/1), 7 – Band Band (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 8-12-9-10-5-13
🎯 Longshots: 9-12-11-10-8-5-2-6-13-4-1-3-7
 
Race 8
Win:9 – Bullet Journal (7/2)
Place:10 – Long Live (5/2)
Show:2 – Click Here (8/1)
Other contenders:7 – Miso Speedy (8/1), 4 – Live Life (12/1), 11 – Ability (6/1), 8 – Lazy Y Legacy (10/1)
Rest of field:3 – Ronilla (10/1), 6 – Minstrelly (15/1), 5 – Senora D'oro (20/1), 1 – Evie's Eyebrows (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 1-8-6-9-4-10
🎯 Longshots: 7-9-10-2-4-11-8-3-5-6-1
 
Race 9
Win:5 – Disko Lady (3/1)
Place:7 – Last Game Lady (2/1)
Show:4 – Keenies Final Gift (9/2)
Other contenders:6 – Jess Knew (10/1), 2 – One Apollitical Dash (10/1), 3 – Mg Kangura (12/1)
Rest of field:1 – Super Shiny (15/1), 9 – Dna Zoomers Cyber (20/1), 10 – Beach Chickz (20/1), 8 – Gold Kings Mawnee (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 5-7-4-2-6-3
🎯 Longshots: 5-4-7-3-2-1-6-9-10-8
 
AI Weight Settings
Speed: 2, FPS: 21, FPS Midpoint: 3, FPS Late: 1, Pace Last 3: 1, Pace Last Race: 1, Early Pace: 65, Mid Pace: 59, Late Pace: 57, Post Position: 41, PPPP Rating: 21, Average Finish: 1, Days Since Last Race: 1, Jockey: 1, Trainer: 10, Track Bias: 31, Morning Line: 1, Pedigree: 1, Works: 1, Weight: 19, Medications: 26, Weather: 84, Race Trouble: 68, Last Race: 1, Last Three Races: 16, All Races: 92, Best Race: 1, Proprietary AI: 1,
Algo Picks – Algo 3
 
Race 1
Win:7 – Pro Fever (2/1)
Place:1 – Magnus Gold (3/1)
Show:2 – Silent Tone (7/2)
Other contenders:6 – Red So O Lo (9/2), 5 – Unresponsive (10/1)
Rest of field:4 – Johnny Ringo (12/1), 3 – Rich Lover (15/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 2-7-1-6-5-4
🎯 Longshots: 7-4-6-1-3-5-2
 
Race 2
Win:2 – Swift Bee (5/2)
Place:3 – Lotta Latte (3/1)
Show:5 – Fifth Wheel (9/2)
Other contenders:6 – Happy Match (4/1), 1 – Mitole's Secret (6/1)
Rest of field:4 – Daddys Dreamin (5/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 5-3-2-6-1-4
🎯 Longshots: 3-2-5-4-6-1
 
Race 3
Win:4 – Tarzana (8/5)
Place:3 – Quality View (9/5)
Show:2 – Really Fancy River (4/1)
Other contenders:5 – My Secret Dreams (8/1), 6 – Rhapsody In Blue (10/1)
Rest of field:1 – Stevie Rae (12/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 4-3-2-5-6-1
🎯 Longshots: 4-3-2-5-1-6
 
Race 4
Win:5 – Texas Cyclone (5/2)
Place:4 – Midnight Vengeance (9/5)
Show:2 – Purdy Darn Good (7/2)
Other contenders:3 – Great Sword (4/1), 7 – Veneno Futuro (8/1)
Rest of field:6 – Only Frank Knows (20/1), 1 – Howard's Grit (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 5-2-3-7-6-4
🎯 Longshots: 4-5-2-3-7-6-1
 
Race 5
Win:10 – Boitano (8/5)
Place:6 – Takeitandrun (4/1)
Show:4 – Woodcock Flight (9/2)
Other contenders:2 – Shankar (10/1), 7 – Frosty The Soldier (15/1), 9 – Zach (12/1)
Rest of field:8 – Revs Medal (20/1), 3 – On Palm Sunday (12/1), 1 – Streamsong (20/1), 5 – Havegunswilltravel (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 9-10-3-7-2-1
🎯 Longshots: 10-6-2-4-1-7-3-9-8-5
 
Race 6
Win:8 – Hickman Creek (9/5)
Place:1 – Hyperlink (7/2)
Show:5 – Payton's Hammer (5/1)
Other contenders:6 – Mr. All In (8/1), 7 – Bhatia (6/1), 2 – Senor Valentine (15/1)
Rest of field:3 – El Tio (10/1), 4 – Akkadian (10/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 8-1-7-5-2-6
🎯 Longshots: 8-1-4-6-3-5-7-2
 
Race 7
Win:9 – Eltinge (3/1)
Place:10 – Turbo Lady (7/2)
Show:11 – Estrella Brillante (8/1)
Other contenders:5 – Echo Dreamer (5/1), 2 – That'smydaughter (10/1), 12 – Goody Two Socks (10/1), 8 – Prettyontheprarie (15/1)
Rest of field:1 – Tamarac Square (20/1), 13 – J's Naughty Kitten (15/1), 6 – Sweet Jannaelise (15/1), 4 – Total Luna Eclipse (20/1), 3 – Over And Above (30/1), 7 – Band Band (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 8-12-9-10-5-13
🎯 Longshots: 9-12-11-10-8-5-2-6-13-4-1-3-7
 
Race 8
Win:9 – Bullet Journal (7/2)
Place:10 – Long Live (5/2)
Show:7 – Miso Speedy (8/1)
Other contenders:4 – Live Life (12/1), 8 – Lazy Y Legacy (10/1), 11 – Ability (6/1), 2 – Click Here (8/1)
Rest of field:3 – Ronilla (10/1), 5 – Senora D'oro (20/1), 6 – Minstrelly (15/1), 1 – Evie's Eyebrows (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 1-8-9-4-6-10
🎯 Longshots: 7-9-10-2-4-11-8-3-5-6-1
 
Race 9
Win:5 – Disko Lady (3/1)
Place:4 – Keenies Final Gift (9/2)
Show:7 – Last Game Lady (2/1)
Other contenders:6 – Jess Knew (10/1), 3 – Mg Kangura (12/1), 9 – Dna Zoomers Cyber (20/1)
Rest of field:2 – One Apollitical Dash (10/1), 1 – Super Shiny (15/1), 10 – Beach Chickz (20/1), 8 – Gold Kings Mawnee (30/1)
🌧️ Off-track: 4-5-7-6-2-9
🎯 Longshots: 5-4-7-3-2-1-6-9-10-8
 
AI Weight Settings
Speed: 1, FPS: 1, FPS Midpoint: 8, FPS Late: 1, Pace Last 3: 1, Pace Last Race: 26, Early Pace: 38, Mid Pace: 14, Late Pace: 67, Post Position: 1, PPPP Rating: 76, Average Finish: 1, Days Since Last Race: 1, Jockey: 1, Trainer: 1, Track Bias: 26, Morning Line: 1, Pedigree: 1, Works: 26, Weight: 91, Medications: 4, Weather: 13, Race Trouble: 66, Last Race: 51, Last Three Races: 1, All Races: 26, Best Race: 1, Proprietary AI: 1,
Kelly Edge Plays
Kelly Edge Plays   (longshots with positive calibrated edge — calibrator: multidim)
RaceHorseMLP(win)Edge¼ Kelly$ on $200
91 – Super Shiny15/110.7%+71.5%1.19%$2.38
92 – One Apollitical Dash10/115.3%+68.4%1.71%$3.42
88 – Lazy Y Legacy10/114.9%+63.6%1.59%$3.18
57 – Frosty The Soldier15/110.1%+61.9%1.03%$2.06
52 – Shankar10/114.2%+56.7%1.42%$2.84
72 – That'Smydaughter10/113.9%+52.7%1.32%$2.63
83 – Ronilla10/113.8%+52.2%1.31%$2.61
31 – Stevie Rae12/111.7%+52.2%1.09%$2.17
93 – Mg Kangura12/111.2%+45.2%0.94%$1.88
62 – Senor Valentine15/18.9%+41.6%0.69%$1.39
53 – On Palm Sunday12/110.6%+37.3%0.78%$1.56
712 – Goody Two Socks10/112.3%+35.2%0.88%$1.76
76 – Sweet Jannaelise15/18.2%+30.8%0.51%$1.03
13 – Rich Lover15/18.0%+27.2%0.45%$0.91
59 – Zach12/19.7%+26.4%0.55%$1.10
86 – Minstrelly15/17.4%+19.2%0.32%$0.64
84 – Live Life12/18.9%+15.5%0.32%$0.65
713 – J'S Naughty Kitten15/16.6%+5.7%0.09%$0.19
Edge = P(win) × decimal odds − 1. ¼ Kelly stake is the recommended fraction of bankroll, capped at 5%. Dollar column scales to a $200 example bankroll — scale linearly for your own.
Index – Horses Running In This Card
ABILITYAKKADIANBAND BANDBEACH CHICKZBHATIA
BULLET JOURNALCLICK HEREDADDYS DREAMINDISKO LADYDNA ZOOMERS CYBER
EL TIOELTINGEESTRELLA BRILLANTEEVIE'S EYEBROWSFIFTH WHEEL
GOLD KINGS MAWNEEGOODY TWO SOCKSGREAT SWORDHAPPY MATCHHAVEGUNSWILLTRAVEL
HOWARD'S GRITHYPERLINKJ'S NAUGHTY KITTENJESS KNEWJOHNNY RINGO
LAST GAME LADYLAZY Y LEGACYLIVE LIFELONG LIVELOTTA LATTE
MG KANGURAMIDNIGHT VENGEANCEMINSTRELLYMISO SPEEDYMITOLE'S SECRET
MY SECRET DREAMSON PALM SUNDAYONE APOLLITICAL DASHONLY FRANK KNOWSOVER AND ABOVE
PRETTYONTHEPRARIEPRO FEVERPURDY DARN GOODQUALITY VIEWREALLY FANCY RIVER
REVS MEDALRHAPSODY IN BLUERICH LOVERRONILLASENOR VALENTINE
SHANKARSILENT TONESTEVIE RAESTREAMSONGSUPER SHINY
SWIFT BEETAKEITANDRUNTAMARAC SQUARETARZANATEXAS CYCLONE
TOTAL LUNA ECLIPSETURBO LADYUNRESPONSIVEVENENO FUTUROWOODCOCK FLIGHT

 


Get more in-depth analysis for all races and enjoy many other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback