Pick Pony Mini Tip Sheet for Horseshoe Indianapolis – Racing News and Analysis for May 20, 2026


Get the full Handicapper Report, AI picks, expert analysis, and more with a Pick Pony subscription!

 

Pick Pony Handicapper Report — Horseshoe Indianapolis | May 20, 2026

Mild mid-60s temperatures with increasing shower chances through the back half of the card; turf course firm to good early but monitor for Race 7 and beyond. The dirt main track favors early position and inside posts in sprints; turf routes reward closers and rail draws. BUN races in the back half attract sharper horses and deeper wagering pools.

Race 1 — 1760f | Dirt | Maiden Special Weight

Julee Forever (3) is the top selection as a tactical type from a trainer with a strong maiden record at this circuit. Jogger (5) is the likely pace-setter and primary threat, with Abra Abra (4) worth including in exotics as one of two Richardville entries at matching 4-1 odds. Box Abra Abra (4) and Crazy Sexy Cool (7) in the exacta if you believe the barn has split its best effort evenly.

Race 2 — 1320f | Dirt | Claiming $12,500

I'm A Cookie Lover (2) gets the call on the strength of a top jockey booking and an inside post in a six-horse sprint. Pickle Shoes (6) at the same 2-1 price with a productive trainer-rider partnership is the co-equal danger, and Zoomaha (1) at 4-1 from the rail is the best exacta underneath option. With two co-favorites possibly dueling early, the pace sets up for the closers to sneak in.

Race 3 — 1210f | Dirt | Maiden Claiming $12,500

Earl's Lady (5) is the top selection at 2-1 from a favorable middle post in this seven-horse sprint, with Muscle Mommy (7) at co-2-1 the main rival despite the wide draw. Baby Hello (2) at 4-1 from post two is the best secondary choice for trifecta coverage, and Vaedra (1) at 4-1 with a productive meet rider adds rail-post value. Structure the trifecta with both favorites on top and Baby Hello (2) and Vaedra (1) in third.

Race 4 — 1320f | Dirt | Maiden Special Weight (Oklahoma-Bred)

Deyemond (3) is the standout of the first half of the card as the lone Brad Cox shipper in a maiden special weight for Oklahoma-breds. Rose Of San Antone (4) at 3-1 is the primary danger with a leading turf jockey aboard, and Lets Shance It (5) at 4-1 offers the best win value if the favorite stumbles. Key Deyemond (3) on top in exactas over Rose Of San Antone (4) and Lets Shance It (5).

Race 5 — 1760f | Turf | Optional Claiming $20,000

Dream On Stormy (2) at 3-1 is the single best win bet on the card, powered by a nationally respected turf jockey booking that gives this horse a meaningful edge in an optional claimer on grass. Bijou Baby (6) at 2-1 is the morning line favorite from a double-entry barn that is clearly confident in both runners, with Polka Polenta (1) at 4-1 from the coveted rail draw on turf offering strong place value. Razzle Red (8) at 5-1 as the second Grubbs entry deserves exotic inclusion.

Race 6 — 1210f | Dirt | Allowance $41,000 (BUN)

Unbridled Intent (8) at 2-1 is the class of this nine-horse allowance sprint despite the wide draw, with Silver Syon (6) at 3-1 the best value alternative from a more favorable post. Imminent Forecast (1) at 5-1 from the rail is the top secondary choice and the recommended show bet, while Luna Diva (2) at 6-1 and Our Jalapeno (4) at 8-1 round out trifecta coverage.

Race 7 — 1760f | Turf | Claiming $25,000 (BUN, 15 runners)

Vulcan's Boots (1) is the top selection in this 15-horse turf route on the strength of the coveted rail draw at a workable 4-1 price, with Hyperbolize (7) and Candy Cane Crain (3) as the co-equal co-favorites rounding out the top three. Kick A Buck (6) at 6-1 and Papiamento (9) at 10-1 are the best secondary choices for trifecta and exotic coverage in this wide-open large field. Concentrate wagering in exotic structures rather than straight win bets given the three-way co-favorite situation.

Race 8 — 1210f | Dirt | Allowance $41,000 (BUN)

Silver Sterling (3) at 2-1 is the top Cunningham stable selection in this nine-horse allowance sprint, but the best value play on the entire card is barn-mate Unattainable Love (6) at 4-1 in the same race. Fools Jester (1) at 4-1 from the rail with an aggressive front-running jockey is the recommended trifecta anchor underneath both Cunningham horses. Box Silver Sterling (3) and Unattainable Love (6) in the exacta for the primary wager.

Race 9 — 330f | Dirt | Quarter-Horse Allowance (BUN)

Rock Hard Love (3) at 2-1 is the top selection in this 330-furlong quarter-horse dash, backed by the card's dominant trainer and a favorable center-field draw in a straight sprint where gate speed is everything. Kelli Girl (6) at co-2-1 from a specialized quarter-horse barn is the equal danger, and Flyin Cowgirl (4) at 5-1 from the ideal center post offers the best win value among the non-favorites. Note the Cunningham double entry — Sauce C (2) at 8-1 is worth adding to exacta boxes given the barn's firepower on this card.

Before wagering, check the Latest Race Scratches, Changes, and Conditions post for any last-minute scratches or race changes.


Unlock the full Handicapper Report and enjoy all Pick Pony membership perks!

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback