Get more in-depth analysis for all races and enjoy many other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!
The Thoroughbred racing circuit returns to Thistledown for an eight-race card featuring a mix of claiming, allowance, and maiden special weight contests. With post time beginning at 12:50 PM for the opening race, bettors can expect competitive fields and solid wagering opportunities throughout the afternoon.
Track Conditions and Weather
Current conditions at North Randall show clear skies with temperatures around 61°F and winds from the east at 9 mph. The track is expected to be fast with humidity levels at 60% and no precipitation in the forecast. Racing surface conditions should remain ideal throughout the afternoon program.
Race-by-Race Analysis
Race 1 – $21,900 Claiming (6F Dirt, 12:50 PM)
Key Contenders: John Fitzgerald (#9) emerges as the top selection at 9-2 odds with jockey Alexander Chavez aboard for trainer Craig Sweeting. This 3-year-old gelding carries blinkers and has recent form that suggests improvement potential.
Secondary Choices: Color Bearer (#1) with Ricardo Mejias riding brings consistency to the field, while Marquitos M (#3) under Fernando Salazar Becerra offers value at longer odds.
Pace Analysis: The race sets up as a moderate pace scenario with several horses showing early speed tendencies. Look for tactical positioning to be crucial in the stretch run.
Wagering Angles: John Fitzgerald represents the consensus choice among handicappers and offers solid value at current odds.
Race 2 – $28,000 Allowance (5½F Dirt, 1:20 PM)
Key Contenders: Mr. Penny Pincher (#4) stands out as the morning line favorite at 2-1 with Ricardo Feliciano riding for trainer Anthony F. Rini. However, this horse appears on the scratch list due to veterinarian concerns.
Secondary Choices: With the probable scratch of the favorite, attention shifts to Win Herbie Win (#1) and Zippin Gigi (#2) as legitimate contenders in this allowance field.
Longshot Consideration: Coastertothemoon (#6) with Deshawn L. Parker aboard could provide exotic value if the race develops favorably.
Key Angles: The scratch of Mr. Penny Pincher opens up the race significantly, creating better value opportunities throughout the field.
Race 3 – $33,900 Maiden Special Weight (6F Dirt, 1:50 PM)
Key Contenders: Affair to Remember (#1) is the handicappers’ choice at 8-5 with Noel Vigil riding for trainer Richard L. Genovese. This 4-year-old gelding has shown consistency in recent efforts.
Secondary Choices: Skiptheguilttrip (#2) with Victor R. Fernandez offers solid credentials, while Crypto Chris (#3) brings youth and potential upside to the contest.
Pace Analysis: This appears to be a moderate pace setup with several horses possessing tactical speed, making positioning critical in the final furlong.
Wagering Strategy: Affair to Remember offers solid win probability, while using Skiptheguilttrip and Crypto Chris in exacta and trifecta combinations provides betting value.
Race 4 – $17,900 Claiming (5½F Dirt, 2:20 PM)
Key Contenders: Blessednotlucky (#4) emerges as the consensus pick at 2-1 odds with Walter Cullum aboard for trainer Sherry L. Jackson. This 3-year-old colt shows recent improvement patterns.
Secondary Choices: Hidden Ransom (#3) appears on the scratch list due to veterinary issues, while Harsh Truth (#5) and Smoocher (#6) provide alternative options.
Longshot Play: Gretchens Mane Man (#1) at longer odds could provide surprise value if the pace develops favorably for closers.
Wagering Angles: Focus on Blessednotlucky for win betting while incorporating secondary choices in exotic wagers.
Race 5 – $14,400 Claiming (6F Dirt, 2:50 PM)
Key Contenders: Logico (#4) stands as the morning line choice at 2-1 with Christian P. Pilares riding for Richard L. Genovese. This 6-year-old horse brings experience and recent good form.
Secondary Choices: Fatih (#1) and Star Weaver (#2) provide solid alternatives, while Bourbon On Fire (#5) could factor at longer odds.
Pace Analysis: The race appears to set up with moderate early pace, allowing for tactical positioning to determine the outcome.
Value Play: Logico represents solid value at current odds while offering win potential in this competitive claiming field.
Race 6 – $18,300 Claiming Fillies/Mares (6F Dirt, 3:20 PM)
Key Contenders: Instigation (#4) is the handicappers’ selection at 8-5 odds with Jose A. Bracho aboard for trainer Justin Radosevich. Beautiful Charade (#1) appears on the scratch list due to veterinary concerns.
Secondary Choices: With Beautiful Charade likely scratched, Rosetta (#2) and Ruby Layne (#3) become more prominent in the wagering.
Pace Analysis: The scratch of Beautiful Charade alters the early pace dynamics, potentially benefiting horses with tactical speed.
Betting Strategy: Instigation offers solid win potential while the scratched favorite creates better exotic wagering opportunities.
Race 7 – $28,000 Allowance Fillies/Mares (6F Dirt, 3:50 PM)
The seventh race at Thistledown presents a competitive allowance contest for fillies and mares three years old and upward that have never won a race other than maiden, claiming, starter, optional or Ohio bred events. With two scratches reducing the field to five runners, this creates enhanced betting value and clearer handicapping angles.
Field Analysis With Scratches
Scratched Horses: Officially Yours (#1) was scratched by trainer decision, while The Devil’s Dream (#6) was scratched due to gate issues. These scratches significantly alter the race dynamics and betting patterns.
Remaining Field:
- #2 Nublada (4F, 121 lbs) – Erik Barbaran / Robert M. Gorham
- #3 Tattered Heart (5M, 119 lbs) – Jose A. Bracho / Rey Juarez-Mendoza
- #4 Derby Day Kiss (4F, 123 lbs) – Victor R. Fernandez / Robert C. Cline
- #5 Whiskey Diamond (5M, 123 lbs) – John McKee / George S. Bush
- #7 Cali Cruiser (4F, 119 lbs) – David J. Haldar / Ivan Calderon
Key Contenders
Whiskey Diamond (#5) emerges as the morning line favorite at 2-1 odds with veteran jockey John McKee aboard for trainer George S. Bush. This 5-year-old mare shows consistent recent form and carries 123 pounds as a non-winner of a race since September 10, making her well-placed in this allowance field. Her tactical speed and proven ability at the Thistledown 6-furlong distance make her the logical choice.
Nublada (#2) represents significant value at 3-1 morning line odds with Erik Barbaran riding for Robert M. Gorham. The handicapping analysis notes she “won impressively last time out and could follow up,” indicating strong recent form that suggests she can compete with the favorite. At 121 pounds, she receives a slight weight advantage over the top contenders.
Secondary Choices
Derby Day Kiss (#4) brings solid credentials at 6-1 odds with Victor R. Fernandez aboard for Robert C. Cline. The expert analysis indicates she “won well recently and could complete the trio,” suggesting legitimate place potential. Her recent victory demonstrates current form, and the Fernandez/Cline combination brings tactical expertise to this allowance level.
Cali Cruiser (#7) also carries 6-1 morning line odds with David J. Haldar riding for Ivan Calderon. Her previous victory at Thistledown in August 2024 demonstrates course familiarity, though her recent form suggests she may need improvement to compete with the top choices.
Longshot Analysis
Tattered Heart (#3) represents the longest price at 20-1 odds despite carrying only 119 pounds with Jose A. Bracho aboard. While the odds suggest limited chances, the 5-year-old mare’s light weight and Bracho’s tactical skills could produce surprise value if pace dynamics develop favorably.
Pace Analysis
With the scratches reducing early speed, the pace setup becomes more tactical. Whiskey Diamond’s proven tactical speed positions her well to control the early fractions, while Nublada’s closing ability could prove effective if the pace develops moderately. The 6-furlong distance at Thistledown typically favors horses with tactical positioning rather than pure closers.
Track Considerations
Current fast track conditions favor horses with proven form over the Thistledown surface. Whiskey Diamond and Cali Cruiser both show previous success at the track, providing advantages in surface familiarity. The reduced field size creates cleaner trips and fewer traffic concerns, potentially benefiting all runners.
Jockey and Trainer Angles
John McKee brings extensive experience aboard Whiskey Diamond and has shown strong performance at the current meet. Erik Barbaran pairs with the well-regarded Gorham stable on Nublada, creating a formidable combination. Victor R. Fernandez continues his productive association with trainer Robert C. Cline on Derby Day Kiss.
Trainer George S. Bush maintains solid statistics with allowance-level horses, while Robert M. Gorham shows consistency in preparing horses for competitive spots. The double entry from Gorham suggests stable confidence in both Nublada’s current form and race placement.
Wagering Strategies
Win Betting: Whiskey Diamond represents the logical win choice at 2-1 odds, offering reasonable value given the reduced field and proven credentials.
Value Plays: Nublada at 3-1 morning line odds provides excellent exacta value, particularly in combination with Whiskey Diamond. The scratch of two horses enhances the probability for the remaining contenders.
Exotic Wagering: Consider exacta combinations using Whiskey Diamond and Nublada in both directions, with Derby Day Kiss offering trifecta value underneath. The small field creates manageable exotic costs while maintaining solid coverage.
Final Selection
Win: Whiskey Diamond (#5)
Place: Nublada (#2)
Show: Derby Day Kiss (#4)
Exacta: 5-2, 2-5
Trifecta: 5/2,4/2,4,7
The race sets up favorably for Whiskey Diamond to control the pace and maintain her advantage, while Nublada’s recent impressive victory creates legitimate upset potential at attractive odds.
Race 8 – $32,000 Claiming Fillies/Mares (6F Dirt, 4:20 PM)
The finale at Thistledown presents a competitive $50,000 claiming contest for Ohio-bred fillies and mares three years old and upward which have never won three races. With Hot Princess scratched due to veterinary concerns, the field reduces to six runners, creating enhanced betting opportunities and clearer handicapping angles.
Field Analysis With Scratches
Scratched Horse: Hot Princess (#4) was withdrawn due to veterinary concerns, removing a potential contender from the original seven-horse field. This scratch significantly impacts the betting dynamics and improves value opportunities for the remaining runners.
Remaining Field:
- #1 Vertisalute (4F, 119 lbs) – Luis Alberto Batista / Richard J. Rettele
- #2 Biondettisnitemare (3F, 115 lbs) – Roberto A. Perez / Rodney C. Faulkner
- #3 I Belong First (3F, 119 lbs) – David J. Haldar / Megan Fadlovich
- #5 Queen Kitty (3F, 117 lbs) – Fernando Salazar Becerra / Richard J. Rettele
- #6 Brief Encounter (4F, 119 lbs) – Laureano Sosa / Timothy E. Hamm
- #7 Nancyfromtheblock (4F, 119 lbs) – Miguel L. Martinez / Richard L. Genovese
Key Contenders
I Belong First (#3) emerges as the consensus morning line favorite at 9-5 odds with David J. Haldar aboard for trainer Megan Fadlovich. The handicapping analysis notes she “looks well-placed to continue her winning form after an impressive victory last time out” and “can’t knock the form winning two in a row at Thistledown”. Her recent form shows consistent improvement, and she has proven course experience with multiple wins at the track.
Vertisalute (#5) represents the primary challenge at 5-2 morning line odds with Luis Alberto Batista riding for Richard J. Rettele. The expert analysis indicates she “has been consistent in this class and could chase home” the favorite. Her form suggests she can compete effectively at this claiming level and provides legitimate win potential.
Secondary Choices
Queen Kitty (#5) offers solid value at 4-1 morning line odds with Fernando Salazar Becerra aboard for Richard J. Rettele. The analysis notes she “steps up but has shown ability,” indicating potential despite the class increase. The Rettele stable’s double entry suggests confidence in both horses’ current form and race placement.
Brief Encounter (#6) brings competitive credentials at 5-1 odds with Laureano Sosa riding for Timothy E. Hamm. Her recent form indicates she can factor in this competitive claiming field, making her a legitimate contender for exotic wagering.
Longshot Analysis
Biondettisnitemare (#2) represents the longest price at 8-1 odds despite carrying only 115 pounds with Roberto A. Perez aboard. Her light weight advantage could prove beneficial if pace dynamics develop favorably, though her longer odds suggest limited win chances.
Nancyfromtheblock (#7) completes the field at 15-1 odds with Miguel L. Martinez riding for Richard L. Genovese. While her odds indicate minimal expectations, the Genovese stable brings proven expertise at this claiming level.
Pace Analysis
The scratch of Hot Princess alters the early pace dynamics, potentially creating a more tactical setup. I Belong First’s proven tactical speed positions her well to control the early fractions, while her recent winning form suggests she can sustain her advantage. The 6-furlong distance at Thistledown typically favors horses with proven speed and course familiarity, both attributes that I Belong First possesses.
Track and Class Considerations
Current fast track conditions favor horses with proven form over the Thistledown surface. I Belong First’s multiple course victories provide significant advantages in surface familiarity and proven ability at the distance. The $50,000 claiming level represents competitive company, but her recent form suggests she has found her optimal class level.
Jockey and Trainer Angles
David J. Haldar brings tactical expertise aboard I Belong First and has shown strong performance during the current meet. Luis Alberto Batista pairs with the experienced Rettele stable on Vertisalute, creating a formidable combination. Fernando Salazar Becerra continues his productive association with trainer Richard J. Rettele on Queen Kitty.
Trainer Megan Fadlovich shows solid statistics with claiming-level horses and appears to have I Belong First peaking at the right time. Richard J. Rettele maintains consistency in preparing horses for competitive claiming spots, with two entries suggesting stable confidence in both runners’ current form.
Recent Form Analysis
I Belong First’s recent winning streak at Thistledown demonstrates her current class and course suitability. Her form pattern shows improvement through the claiming ranks, and she appears to have found her optimal level. Vertisalute’s consistent performance at this claiming level provides legitimate challenge potential, while Queen Kitty’s ability despite the class step-up creates value opportunities.
Wagering Strategies
Win Betting: I Belong First represents the logical win choice at 9-5 odds, offering reasonable value given her proven recent form and course advantages.
Value Plays: Vertisalute at 5-2 morning line odds provides solid exacta value, particularly in combination with I Belong First. Queen Kitty at 4-1 offers attractive trifecta possibilities underneath the top two choices.
Exotic Wagering: Consider exacta combinations using I Belong First and Vertisalute in both directions, with Queen Kitty and Brief Encounter offering trifecta depth. The reduced field creates manageable exotic costs while maintaining comprehensive coverage.
Final Selections
Win: I Belong First (#3)
Place: Vertisalute (#1)
Show: Queen Kitty (#5)
Exacta: 3-1, 1-3
Trifecta: 3/1,5/1,5,6
The race sets up favorably for I Belong First to continue her winning form at Thistledown, while Vertisalute provides the primary challenge with legitimate upset potential at attractive odds.
Jockey Notes and Insights
Alexander Chavez continues his strong form at the current meet and rides John Fitzgerald in Race 1, representing solid pilot expertise. Ricardo Feliciano maintains consistent performance levels and handles Mr. Penny Pincher in Race 2 if the horse is cleared to run. Noel Vigil’s aggressive riding style suits Affair to Remember in the maiden special weight contest.
Jose A. Bracho brings tactical awareness to his mount Instigation in Race 6, while John McKee’s experience benefits Whiskey Diamond in the allowance feature. David J. Haldar’s patient approach should serve I Belong First well in the finale.
Trainer Notes and Insights
Craig Sweeting’s barn shows recent improvement with John Fitzgerald representing solid form. Richard L. Genovese conditions both Affair to Remember and Logico, bringing consistent training patterns to multiple races. Sherry L. Jackson’s preparation of Blessednotlucky suggests improvement potential.
George S. Bush’s handling of Whiskey Diamond indicates strong recent form, while Megan Fadlovich’s conditioning of I Belong First represents solid preparation for the finale.
Best Wagering Strategies
Win Betting: Focus on John Fitzgerald (Race 1), Affair to Remember (Race 3), Blessednotlucky (Race 4), Logico (Race 5), Instigation (Race 6), Whiskey Diamond (Race 7), and I Belong First (Race 8).
Value Plays: Several scratches throughout the card create enhanced value opportunities in exacta and trifecta wagering. The scratched favorites in multiple races open up betting possibilities for alert handicappers.
Multi-Race Wagers: Consider Pick 3 combinations using the strongest selections while incorporating secondary choices for coverage. Daily double opportunities exist connecting strong win contenders across consecutive races.
Previous Day Highlights – October 9, 2025
Yesterday’s racing at Thistledown saw competitive fields throughout the card. The fifth race claimed featuring Ovid at 13/8 odds delivered solid value for win bettors. Streets Of War captured the finale at 7/4 odds, providing consistent returns for handicappers who identified the logical choice. Track conditions remained fast throughout the program.
