Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Charles Town, October 17, 2025.

Race #1 Expert Picks

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: The Commish (#4)

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: The Commish (#4)

Racenet:

  • Win: The Commish (#4)
  • Place: Go Long (#1)
  • Show: Cedar’s Estate (#5)

FanDuel:

  • Win: Cedar’s Estate (#5)
  • Place: The Commish (#4), Gallant Creek (#6)

Betting News:

  • Win: The Commish (#4)
  • Place: Go Long (#1)
  • Show: Gallant Creek (#6)

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: The Commish (#4)
  • Place: Gallant Creek (#6)
  • Show: Go Long (#1)

At The Races:

  • Win: The Commish (#4)
  • Place: Gallant Creek (#6)

Race #2 Expert Picks

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: Candy Man Can (#5)

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: Candy Man Can (#5)

Racenet:

  • Win: Jack’s Aloha (#1)
  • Place: Roark (#3)
  • Show: Denizetti (#4)

FanDuel:

  • Win: Candy Man Can (#5)
  • Place: Denizetti (#4)
  • Show: Roark (#3)​

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: Tap The Arches (#6)
  • Place: Jack’s Aloha (#1)
  • Show: Candy Man Can (#5)

At The Races:

  • Win: Candy Man Can (#5)
  • Place: Jack’s Aloha (#1)

Race #3 Expert Picks

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: Innocent Nyght (#5)

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: Fashion Victim (#1)

Racenet:

  • Win: Fashion Victim (#1)
  • Place: Double Spirit (#3)
  • Show: Suzies Pride (#4)

FanDuel:

  • Win: Double Spirit (#3)
  • Place: Fashion Victim (#1)
  • Show: Innocent Nyght (#5)

Betting News:

  • Win: Fashion Victim (#1)
  • Place: Double Spirit (#3)
  • Show: Innocent Nyght (#5)

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: Innocent Nyght (#5)
  • Place: Fashion Victim (#1)
  • Show: Fifth Of June (#6)

At The Races:

  • Win: Fashion Victim (#1)
  • Place: Double Spirit (#3)​

Race #4 Expert Picks

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: Cherokee Castle (#3)

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: Lady Serenity (#7)

Racenet:

  • Win: Lady Serenity (#7)
  • Place: Peggy’s Way (#4)
  • Show: Cherokee Castle (#3)

FanDuel:

  • Win: Lady Serenity (#7)
  • Place: Cherokee Castle (#3), Peggy’s Way (#4)

Betting News:

  • Win: Cherokee Castle (#3)
  • Place: Peggy’s Way (#4)
  • Show: Lady Serenity (#7)

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: Forgotten Gift (#1)
  • Place: Peggy’s Way (#4)
  • Show: Lady Serenity (#7)

At The Races:

  • Win: Lady Serenity (#7)
  • Place: Cherokee Castle (#3)​

Race #5 Expert Picks

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: Eyesonthecandy (#3)

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: Runaway Gold (#5)

Racenet:

  • Win: Eyesonthecandy (#3)
  • Place: Fancy Conchita (#4)
  • Show: Stolen Secrets (#6)

FanDuel:

  • Win: Eyesonthecandy (#3), Stolen Secrets (#6)
  • Place: Runaway Gold (#5)

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: Runaway Gold (#5)
  • Place: Eyesonthecandy (#3)
  • Show: Fancy Conchita (#4)

At The Races:

  • Win: Eyesonthecandy (#3)
  • Place: Stolen Secrets (#6)​

Race #6 Expert Picks

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: Cuddler (#5)

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: Cuddler (#5)

Racenet:

  • Win: Cuddler (#5)
  • Place: Sonde Tails (#1)
  • Show: Hey Nigh Teen (#6)

FanDuel:

  • Win: Cuddler (#5)
  • Place: Sonde Tails (#1), Hey Nigh Teen (#6)

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: Cuddler (#5)
  • Place: Breadman’shoneybun (#2)
  • Show: Sonde Tails (#1)

At The Races:

  • Win: Cuddler (#5)
  • Place: Sonde Tails (#1)​

Race #7 Expert Picks

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: Dreamy Sonde (#1)

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: Caribbean Comedy (#6)

Racenet:

  • Win: Caribbean Comedy (#6)
  • Place: Dreamy Sonde (#1)
  • Show: Ran The Red (#5)

FanDuel:

  • Win: Miss Menetes (#2)
  • Place: Dreamy Sonde (#1), Caribbean Comedy (#6)

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: Champagne Please (#4)
  • Place: Amalfi Sunset (#7)
  • Show: Dreamy Sonde (#1)

At The Races:

  • Win: Caribbean Comedy (#6)
  • Place: Dreamy Sonde (#1)​

Race #8 Expert Picks

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: Tesoro Rossa (#2)

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: Melancia (#3)

Racenet:

  • Win: Can I Get Awitness (#1)
  • Place: Melancia (#3)
  • Show: Tesoro Rossa (#2)

FanDuel:

  • Win: Melancia (#3), Frosty Maya (#5)
  • Place: Chase By The Moon (#8)

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: Melancia (#3)
  • Place: Chase By The Moon (#8)
  • Show: Let’s Go Mo (#9)

At The Races:

  • Win: Melancia (#3)
  • Place: Tesoro Rossa (#2)​

Consensus Picks

Race #1 Consensus

  • Win: The Commish (#4) – 86% confidence
  • Place: Gallant Creek (#6) – 57% confidence
  • Show: Go Long (#1) – 43% confidence

Race #2 Consensus

  • Win: Candy Man Can (#5) – 67% confidence
  • Place: Jack’s Aloha (#1) – 50% confidence
  • Show: Roark (#3) – 33% confidence

Race #3 Consensus

  • Win: Fashion Victim (#1) – 67% confidence
  • Place: Double Spirit (#3) – 67% confidence
  • Show: Innocent Nyght (#5) – 50% confidence

Race #4 Consensus

  • Win: Lady Serenity (#7) – 57% confidence
  • Place: Peggy’s Way (#4) – 67% confidence
  • Show: Cherokee Castle (#3) – 50% confidence

Race #5 Consensus

  • Win: Eyesonthecandy (#3) – 60% confidence
  • Place: Runaway Gold (#5) – 40% confidence
  • Show: Stolen Secrets (#6) – 40% confidence

Race #6 Consensus

  • Win: Cuddler (#5) – 100% confidence
  • Place: Sonde Tails (#1) – 75% confidence
  • Show: Hey Nigh Teen (#6) – 33% confidence

Race #7 Consensus

  • Win: Caribbean Comedy (#6) – 50% confidence
  • Place: Dreamy Sonde (#1) – 75% confidence
  • Show: Ran The Red (#5) – 20% confidence

Race #8 Consensus

  • Win: Melancia (#3) – 67% confidence
  • Place: Tesoro Rossa (#2) – 33% confidence
  • Show: Chase By The Moon (#8) – 33% confidence​

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback