Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Fair Grounds, December 12, 2025. 63% WIN RATE + 2 EXACTAS


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.

Race 1 Maiden Claiming – 1 Mile 70 Yards – Dirt – $15,000 WIN + EXACTA

Win: 1 Prince Day (100% confidence)🥇

Place: 4 Gold Gunner (40% confidence)🥈

Show: 2 Max S (40% confidence)

Alternative: 6 Tonka Trouble (25% confidence)

Prince Day demonstrates overwhelming consensus support across all sources, having finished a neck back from the leader last start at Fair Grounds. The top three selections appear to separate from the remainder of the field based on recent form and trainer/jockey combinations. Gold Gunner and Max S compete closely for place consideration while Tonka Trouble represents a capable alternative for deeper exotic wagering. Early pace management and track bias will likely determine whether favorites maintain their form advantage.


Race 2 Claiming – 1 Mile 70 Yards – Dirt – $15,000 WIN

Win: 1 Gypsan (80% confidence)🥇

Place: 5 Midnight Blaze (75% confidence)🥉

Show: 2 Roll Gypsy Roll (75% confidence)

Alternative: 3 Dreamy Deal (20% confidence)

Gypsan brings standout consistency and commands most analyst support despite Dreamy Deal representing an intriguing contrarian angle from one source. Midnight Blaze’s recent turf run may have freshened the runner for a return to dirt where the horse has demonstrated progressive form. Roll Gypsy Roll provides reliable place utility. The race shapes as a competitive claiming event where form reversals and track bias could shift the predicted order. Dreamy Deal at longer odds offers potential value if the race develops differently than expected.


Race 3 Claiming – 1 Mile – Turf – $20,000

Win: 7 Same Play (25% confidence)🥉

Place: 2 Doolgaroux (50% confidence)

Show: 3 A Passive Nobody (50% confidence)

Alternative: 9 Southscape (25% confidence)

Race 3 presents the most competitive win picture on the entire card with no single selection commanding majority support. Same Play finished four lengths behind the winner last start at Delta Downs and demonstrates the most compelling credentials. Doolgaroux ranks among the most consistent place finishers in the group. The turf mile setup demands tactical speed and closing ability, factors that may advantage different runners than expected. A Passive Nobody’s two recent placings position the runner as a legitimate show candidate, while Southscape cannot be ruled out based on trainer/jockey form. Exotic wagering opportunities abound given the competitive nature of win selection.


Race 4 Maiden Claiming – 6 Furlongs – Dirt – $17,000 WIN + EXACTA

Win: 4 Our Standard (75% confidence)🥇

Place: 1 Campanario (33% confidence)

Show: 2 Azteca Storm (33% confidence)

Alternative: 5 Heavenly Beliefs (33% confidence)🥈

Our Standard dominates win selection among debuting newcomers in this maiden claiming event. Early positioning becomes crucial at six furlongs on dirt, a distance where speed advantage often translates to success. Campanario draws attention from one source as a strategic play despite lower consensus weight. Heavenly Beliefs shows first-time blinkers equipment and trainer form that could produce a significant effort in place or show wagering. The six-furlong distance suits speed-oriented runners, which may favor Our Standard while creating opportunity for well-positioned runners in the secondary positions.


Race 5 Claiming – 5 Furlongs – Turf – 8:45 PM – $24,000

Win: 4 Spinning Glory (40% confidence) / 2 Baby Kristen (40% confidence)🥉

Place: 1 Bayou Bertie (75% confidence)🥈

Show: 5 Call’em All (50% confidence)

Race 5 presents a competitive win scenario with two horses commanding equal support from the analyst consensus. Spinning Glory demonstrates consistency over this trip while Baby Kristen brings strong recent form including a five-furlong turf win. Bayou Bertie’s dominant place support reflects recent impressive victory and progressive form trajectory. The five-furlong turf distance favors runners capable of early positioning and closing aggressively, characteristics present in multiple contenders. Call’em All provides reliable show utility. The competitive nature of win selection creates excellent exacta value opportunities when pairing the split win candidates with Bayou Bertie.


Race 6 Magic City Classic Stakes – 1 Mile – Dirt – $85,000

Win: 3 Liken It (33% confidence) 🥉/ 8 Jovie G (33% confidence)

Place: 8 Jovie G (25% confidence) / 3 Liken It (25% confidence) / 4 Wabash (25% confidence)

Show: 7 Dromas (25% confidence) / 8 Jovie G (25% confidence) / 3 Liken It (25% confidence) / 4 Wabash (25% confidence)

The Magic City Classic Stakes features evenly distributed support among multiple contenders, indicating a highly competitive stakes field. Liken It represents recent course and distance success with impressive form trailing slightly behind Jovie G in some analyst views. Jovie G demonstrates strong recent form and draws attention from multiple sources. The stakes-level competition and mile distance demand horses capable of tactical flexibility and strong closing acceleration. Wabash cannot be dismissed based on recent training performance and proven course credentials. The race likely produces value opportunities in exacta and trifecta wagering given the split consensus.


Race 7 Claiming – 1 Mile – Turf – $22,000 WIN ($15.00)

Win: 6 Contemplation (50% confidence) 🥇/ 4 Brit’s Wit (25% confidence)

Place: 11 Skipper’s Pride (33% confidence) / 1 Deccan Prince (33% confidence) / 2 Pico D’oro (33% confidence)

Show: 7 Gorilla Trek (33% confidence) 🥉/ 14 Bizzee Channel (33% confidence) / 4 Brit’s Wit (33% confidence)

Contemplation emerges as the primary selection with recent course success and strong form credentials across multiple analyst sources. Brit’s Wit draws attention as a contrarian angle, particularly from sources emphasizing class improvement potential. Gorilla Trek demonstrates consistent turf form and represents a capable place and show candidate. The one-mile turf trip rewards horses capable of tactical speed and coordinated closing efforts. Deccan Prince’s course and distance record warrants consideration in place wagering despite lower overall consensus weight. Parrot Head represents a potential value angle for win wagering at longer odds should the primary selections encounter interference or racing luck issues.


Race 8 Claiming – 1 Mile – Dirt – 10:15 PM – $14,000 WIN ($5.00)

Win: 2 Island Cabana (40% confidence) / 1 Duvee (40% confidence)🥇

Place: 1 Duvee (33% confidence) / 7 Regatta Bay (33% confidence) / 4 My Dad’s Guitar (33% confidence)

Show: 2 Island Cabana (33% confidence) / 8 Midnight Halo (33% confidence) / 3 Contraband Early (33% confidence)

Island Cabana and Duvee command split analyst support for the win, reflecting competitive strength between the primary selections. Island Cabana’s recent form at Fair Grounds and consistency in finishing positions support the selection. Duvee returns from a lengthy layoff with desirable post position and trainer form credentials. Midnight Halo’s consistent recent performances position the runner as a reliable show utility. Regatta Bay provides additional place option based on recent competitive form. The claiming level competition and mile distance on dirt typically favor runners with proven class credentials and tactical positioning ability. Value opportunities exist in exacta and trifecta wagering given the split consensus between Island Cabana and Duvee.


Value Plays and Recommended Exotic Wagers

Race 1 Exacta: Box 1-2-4 with 1-6 – Prince Day commands overwhelming support, but pairing the favorite with Max S and Gold Gunner for place creates strong exacta value.

Race 2 Win Bet: 1 Gypsan – Commands 80% consensus support as a reliable single play with positive expected value.

Race 2 Exacta: 1-5 (Gypsan/Midnight Blaze) – The two primary selections earn 80% and 75% consensus support respectively, providing the strongest two-horse exacta pairing on the card.

Race 3 Trifecta: Play all three-horse combinations featuring Same Play, Doolgaroux, and A Passive Nobody – The competitive nature of win selection with Doolgaroux and A Passive Nobody showing consistent place and show support creates excellent value in trifecta wagering.

Race 5 Win Bet: Box 2-4 (Baby Kristen/Spinning Glory) – Equal 40% consensus support for both selections creates value when backing both as primary win selections.

Race 6 Win Bet: Box 3-8 (Liken It/Jovie G) – Split analyst support between these two legitimate contenders provides maximum value for horseplayers confident in the Magic City Classic field composition.

Race 7 Win Bet: 6 Contemplation – Commands 50% consensus support while Brit’s Wit attracts contrarian interest, making Contemplation the more reliable single play.

Race 8 Exacta: Box 1-2 (Duvee/Island Cabana) – Equal 40% win support makes the two-horse exacta box an efficient wager capturing both primary selections across finish combinations.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback