Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.

Race 1 Maiden Claiming 1100 Yards Dirt

Win: Go Go Jelly Roll (8) – 60% confidence

Place: Halfway Joking (7) – 60% confidence

Show: The Exodus Twist (6) – 60% confidence

Alternative: Redeposit (9) – 40% confidence

There is a significant divide among analysts in the opener. While a majority prefer Go Go Jelly Roll (8) for the top spot, the support for Halfway Joking (7) and The Exodus Twist (6) across the board suggests this is a wide-open maiden event. One analyst notes that Go Go Jelly Roll (8) has significant room for improvement after a debut effort, making them a logical selection despite the Split field.

Race 2 Maiden Claiming 8 Furlongs Dirt

Win: Lady Faye (2) – 80% confidence

Place: Frosty For Ever (4) – 60% confidence

Show: Gio Linh (5) – 60% confidence

Alternative: Bowling Blue (3) – 40% confidence

Lady Faye (2) is one of the strongest consensus picks on the card. Analysts point to her consistency in recent starts and the drop in relative field quality as major factors. One analyst suggests that Frosty For Ever (4) is the primary challenger coming off a narrow second-place finish, but the overall sentiment heavily favors the favorite to break through here.

Race 3 Claiming 1430 Yards Dirt

Win: Mcilroy (4) – 60% confidence

Place: Papiamento (1) – 80% confidence

Show: Guardian (7) – 40% confidence

Alternative: Glacial Power (2) – 20% confidence

Mcilroy (4) and Papiamento (1) are the clear standouts for analysts. Most prefer Mcilroy (4) on top given a strong third-place effort recently, though Papiamento (1) is the most frequently mentioned horse for the place position. Analysts suggest that these two should Dominate the exotic wagers, with Guardian (7) viewed as the most likely candidate to fill out the minor awards.

Race 4 Claiming 8 Furlongs Dirt

Win: Count Of Amazonia (8) – 40% confidence

Place: Some R Blessed (9) – 60% confidence

Show: Company You Keep (3) – 40% confidence

Alternative: Del Mo (4) – 40% confidence

This race features a highly fragmented consensus. While Count Of Amazonia (8) gets the edge for the win from several sources, Some R Blessed (9) actually appears in more total selections across the win and place spots. Analysts are wary of the class jump for Some R Blessed (9), which may explain Why the win confidence is capped. The variety of alternative picks suggests a high-variance outcome is possible.

Race 5 Maiden Claiming 1430 Yards Dirt

Win: Ryan's Shadow (1) – 40% confidence

Place: Love In Lights (7) – 40% confidence

Show: Shallus (8) – 40% confidence

Alternative: Todo Men (3) – 40% confidence

This is one of the most difficult races to handicap according to the analysts. No single horse commands more than a 40% confidence level for any specific position. Ryan's Shadow (1) gets the nod for the win based on an ideal draw, but Love In Lights (7) has strong momentum from recent placed efforts. This race appears to be a prime candidate for using multiple horses in vertical exotics.

Race 6 Maiden Special Weight 8 Furlongs Dirt

Win: Celtic Flame (3) – 80% confidence

Place: Supercharger (6) – 40% confidence

Show: Brave Force (10) – 40% confidence

Alternative: Just Munny (8) – 20% confidence

Celtic Flame (3) is a Powerful consensus choice. Analysts are Nearly unanimous in their belief that this horse will build on a promising runner-up effort at this track. While the secondary positions are less certain, Supercharger (6) and Brave Force (10) are the names most frequently mentioned as having the best chance to challenge. The depth of the field behind the favorite is noted, but the win selection remains firm.

Race 7 Allowance Optional Claiming 1320 Yards Dirt

Win: Mom's Cheesecake (2) – 60% confidence

Place: Lost And Found (4) – 60% confidence

Show: Hue (9) – 40% confidence

Alternative: Salty Senorita (3) – 20% confidence

Analysts are Split between Mom's Cheesecake (2) and Lost And Found (4). Mom's Cheesecake (2) is favored by those who prioritize course-and-distance form, while Lost And Found (4) is the choice for those looking at overall class. One analyst notes that Salty Senorita (3) is a dangerous wildcard returning from a long layoff, adding some uncertainty to the exotic landscape.

Race 8 Wintergreen Stakes 8 Furlongs Dirt

Win: Literate (4) – 80% confidence

Place: Devassa (1) – 60% confidence

Show: Wrigleyville (2) – 40% confidence

Alternative: Stylish Sue (5) – 20% confidence

The feature race has a very clear consensus hierarchy. Literate (4) is the overwhelming choice to repeat a recent winning performance. Analysts see the race primarily as a rematch between Literate (4) and Devassa (1), with the former having the clear upper hand. Wrigleyville (2) is respected as a recent winner at Tampa Bay but is viewed as a minor award candidate in this tougher environment.

Race 9 Claiming 1320 Yards Dirt

Win: Atlantic Passage (1) – 100% confidence

Place: Bend My Ear (4) – 60% confidence

Show: Catalyzed (11) – 40% confidence

Alternative: Hard To Get (8) – 20% confidence

Atlantic Passage (1) is the lone unanimous win selection on the card. Analysts are in total agreement that this horse is perfectly placed to secure a victory. The battle for the minor awards is where the analysts differ, though Bend My Ear (4) has the most support for the runner-up spot. This race is viewed as the most predictable event on the Turfway card.

Race 10 Maiden Claiming 1100 Yards Dirt

Win: Sailor Sam (2) – 80% confidence

Place: Count The Green (3) – 80% confidence

Show: Numbers Game (10) – 40% confidence

Alternative: I Forgot To Ask (5) – 40% confidence

The finale features strong consensus on a pair of first-time starters. Sailor Sam (2) is the preferred win choice, largely due to the reputation of the training stable. Count The Green (3) is almost equally supported, usually as the primary alternative. Analysts suggest that the newcomers have a significant edge over the experienced runners in this field, making them a solid 1-2 punch for the end of the day.

Recommended Exotic Plays by Race

Analysts suggest that the Turfway card offers several distinct opportunities for exotic wagering based on the consensus levels. In Race 2, analysts recommend a focused Exacta using Lady Faye (2) on top of Frosty For Ever (4) and Gio Linh (5). Given the 80% confidence in the favorite, this is seen as a high-Probability, lower-payout structure.

For the more wide-open Race 5, analysts lean toward a Trifecta Box including Ryan's Shadow (1), Love In Lights (7), Todo Men (3), and Shallus (8). With no clear Standout, analysts believe covering multiple combinations is the best way to capture value in a race where a longshot could easily sneak into the top three.

In the stakes race (Race 8), analysts propose a cold Exacta Literate (4) over Devassa (1), but suggest adding Wrigleyville (2) into a Trifecta with the top two to increase potential returns.

The strongest recommendation from analysts comes in Race 9. With Atlantic Passage (1) holding 100% win confidence, analysts suggest using this horse as a “key” in Superfecta wheels. By placing Atlantic Passage (1) in the win spot and rotating Bend My Ear (4), Catalyzed (11), and Hard To Get (8) in the remaining positions, bettors can capitalize on the favorite’s High Probability while hunting for a larger payout in the minor slots.

Value Play Observations

Analysts have identified several horses that represent potential value relative to their likely odds. In Race 4, Some R Blessed (9) has a high appearance frequency in analyst picks (60%) compared to their 5/2 morning line. Analysts believe this horse has a higher win Probability than the odds suggest, making them a primary value target.

Conversely, Count Of Amazonia (8) in Race 4 is viewed with more skepticism. Despite being a top pick for some, the Split opinion and 3-1 odds make this horse look like an “underlay” compared to the more consistent support for the runner-up.

In Race 7, Salty Senorita (3) at 10-1 is identified as a potential “overlay.” While only 20% of analysts selected her for a top-three spot, those who did noted her previous class and strong training camp. Analysts suggest that at double-digit odds, she provides significant upside for bettors looking to beat the favorites Mom's Cheesecake (2) and Lost And Found (4).

Finally, in Race 10, analysts note that Numbers Game (10) is frequently picked for the show spot (40%) despite potentially high odds. Analysts believe this runner is being overlooked in favor of the flashy newcomers, creating a value opportunity for the bottom of Trifecta and Superfecta tickets.

Overall Wagering Strategy

The Turfway Park card for February 28 presents a clear barbell strategy for bettors, with a mix of high-certainty anchors and high-Volatility puzzles. The strongest consensus races occur in the middle and late portions of the program. Race 6 with Celtic Flame (3), Race 8 with Literate (4), and especially Race 9 with Atlantic Passage (1) serve as the foundation for the day. Atlantic Passage (1) is the definitive Standout, earning unanimous support from all surveyed analysts, while Celtic Flame (3) and Literate (4) both maintain a robust 80% win confidence. These horses are ideal candidates to use as “singles” in multi-race wagers or as heavy favorites in vertical exotics.

The primary challenge for bettors lies in the Split-opinion races, specifically Race 4 and Race 5. In Race 4, analysts are deeply divided between Count Of Amazonia (8) and Some R Blessed (9), creating a situation where a small field of three or four horses could realistically win. Race 5 is even more fractured, with four different horses receiving equal 40% confidence marks. The analytical tension in these races suggests that bettors should avoid heavy investment in a single runner and instead use “all” or deep spreads to survive these legs of a Pick 3 or Pick 4.

For multi-race sequences, a natural Pick 3 opportunity exists spanning Races 8, 9, and 10. The high consensus on Literate (4) in the eighth and Atlantic Passage (1) in the ninth allows bettors to concentrate their budget on the tenth race. Since the tenth race is dominated by two first-time starters, Sailor Sam (2) and Count The Green (3), a small ticket using the two favorites in the final leg could yield a high hit rate. This sequence is particularly attractive due to the reduced field Volatility in the two preceding stakes and claiming races.

Exotic value opportunities are most prevalent in the maiden events, specifically Race 1 and Race 6. The unpredictability of young horses often creates pricing inefficiencies. Analysts recommend using structural approaches like Superfecta wheels in Race 9 to capture upside, but in the maidens, a four-horse Trifecta box is the preferred method to account for analytical variance. Environmental factors appear stable, with consistent dirt surfaces and clear weather expected, which should favor horses with established form at Turfway Park.

Key takeaways for this card include prioritizing Atlantic Passage (1) as the day’s Best Bet and focusing on Lady Faye (2) in Race 2 as a reliable early anchor. Bettors should be prepared for Volatility in Race 5 and use that race as a separator to increase payouts on Pick 4 or Pick 5 tickets. By leveraging the strong consensus in the feature races while spreading in the maiden and low-level claiming ranks, experienced bettors can maximize their edge on this card.