Pick Pony Picks – Consensus Expert Picks for Keeneland Race Course, April 9, 2026.


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Consensus Expert Picks

Consensus rankings based on 12 experts. Scoring: 1st pick = 4 pts, 2nd = 3 pts, 3rd = 2 pts, 4th = 1 pt. Agreement % = share of experts that included each horse.

Race 1

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Skara Brae (5)1-19/1090.0%32 pts
2Ruiva (8)3-16/1060.0%18 pts
3Uncle With Money (4)12-14/1040.0%14 pts
4Crossfire (2)4-16/1060.0%11 pts
5Gates Of Eden (3)20-11/1010.0%4 pts
6Baytown Nora (1)15-11/1010.0%2 pts

Race 2

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Click (11)4-16/1250.0%16 pts
2Hylla (9)8-15/1241.7%16 pts
3Lexico (14)6-14/1233.3%11 pts
4Bugs Malone (7)12-15/1241.7%9 pts
5Safe Space (2)6-14/1233.3%9 pts
6Gus's Gal (15)4-13/1225.0%7 pts
7Queen Mckinzie (16)4-13/1225.0%6 pts
8Sea Zest (3)4-13/1225.0%5 pts
9Denise Says No (12)20-13/1225.0%4 pts
10Sharing Wisdom (5)3-13/1225.0%3 pts
11Voluntold (6)30-13/1225.0%2 pts
12Dodecahedron (13)12-12/1216.7%2 pts
13Crown Of Violence (4)15-13/1225.0%1 pts
14Mariposa Moon (10)15-12/1216.7%0 pts
15Rotisserie (1)20-12/1216.7%0 pts
16Little Empress (8)15-12/1216.7%0 pts

Race 3

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Ma Rae's Girl (1)4-18/1172.7%26 pts
2Sweet Scorecard (8)2-18/1172.7%23 pts
3Flame Dancer (7)2-17/1163.6%22 pts
4Mom's Cheesecake (3)6-15/1145.5%12 pts
5Danzig's Dora (6)8-14/1136.4%6 pts
6Fourfiftyseven (2)30-13/1127.3%1 pts
7Ashkenazi (4)30-12/1118.2%0 pts
8Viral Plane Lady (9)20-12/1118.2%0 pts
9Yume (5)15-12/1118.2%0 pts

Race 4

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Tideoftime (4)5-17/1258.3%22 pts
2Amberglen (3)4-15/1241.7%18 pts
3Luster (9)8-16/1250.0%13 pts
4Trust Account (5)3-15/1241.7%12 pts
5Callmeyourmajesty (1)10-15/1241.7%10 pts
6White Smoke (8)6-13/1225.0%5 pts
7Backgammon (2)8-13/1225.0%4 pts
8Huck's Agenda (10)10-13/1225.0%3 pts
9South Philly Slide (6)20-12/1216.7%3 pts
10Mother Green (7)12-12/1216.7%0 pts

Race 5

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Royal Crescent (8)3-19/1275.0%30 pts
2Mr. Miracle (6)2-17/1258.3%22 pts
3Spartacus (4)6-16/1250.0%15 pts
4Maginnesontap (1)8-15/1241.7%10 pts
5Hickman Creek (5)4-15/1241.7%10 pts
6Fourth Dimension (2)4-15/1241.7%8 pts
7Stakeholder (7)15-13/1225.0%4 pts
8Bearister (3)20-12/1216.7%0 pts

Race 6

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Kokomotion (7)1-18/1266.7%27 pts
2May Gray (1)4-16/1250.0%15 pts
3Petronella (3)8-16/1250.0%15 pts
4Soloist (10)6-15/1241.7%14 pts
5Just A Minute (9)20-15/1241.7%9 pts
6East Jabip (4)6-13/1225.0%4 pts
7Rhythm Lady (5)10-12/1216.7%3 pts
8Bold Time (2)10-13/1225.0%2 pts
9Three To G (6)5-12/1216.7%2 pts
10Red Beretta (8)30-12/1216.7%0 pts

Race 7

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Majestical (3)2-110/1283.3%36 pts
2Market Chill (2)4-110/1283.3%25 pts
3Go To Girl (5)2-17/1258.3%21 pts
4Call Me Precious (1)4-15/1241.7%12 pts
5Queenstown (6)6-14/1233.3%5 pts
6Honor Azteca (4)10-12/1216.7%0 pts

Race 8

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Clever Again (5)8-16/1250.0%18 pts
2Mcravin (9)4-15/1241.7%18 pts
3Risk Tolerance (2)3-13/1225.0%11 pts
4Reagan's Wit (6)6-14/1233.3%10 pts
5Pineland (7)20-14/1233.3%6 pts
6Smokey Smokey (1)15-13/1225.0%4 pts
7Mountain Bear (8)8-13/1225.0%4 pts
8Simulate (3)12-13/1225.0%4 pts
9Joejoe Go (14)12-13/1225.0%3 pts
10Fond Farewell (4)10-12/1216.7%0 pts
11Ejtimaa (12)12-12/1216.7%0 pts
12Tough Little Nut (13)15-12/1216.7%0 pts
13Esmark (10)15-12/1216.7%0 pts
14Cairo Caper (11)20-12/1216.7%0 pts
15End Of Romance (16)20-12/1216.7%0 pts
16Special Caliber (15)20-12/1216.7%0 pts

Race 9

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Merry Madison (12)2-110/1283.3%35 pts
2Formaggio (1)15-16/1250.0%16 pts
3Onmywaytosavthday (2)4-15/1241.7%12 pts
4But Seriously (11)10-16/1250.0%11 pts
5Rhaenys (6)15-16/1250.0%10 pts
6Haleakala (9)4-14/1233.3%10 pts
7Mustang Lady (5)8-13/1225.0%5 pts
8Authentic Angel (15)6-12/1216.7%0 pts
9Red Royalty (14)8-12/1216.7%0 pts
10Brave Samantha (13)10-12/1216.7%0 pts
11Mamarsha (3)20-12/1216.7%0 pts
12Carol's Melody (10)20-12/1216.7%0 pts
13Ride The Broom (4)12-12/1216.7%0 pts
14Zafyre (7)30-12/1216.7%0 pts
15Star Watch (8)50-12/1216.7%0 pts

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback