Posted inAnalysis

Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Consensus Expert Picks for Sunland Park, March 9, 2026.

No CommentsPosted inAnalysis


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Race 1 – Claiming – 1210Y Dirt – Purse not listed

Win: George Who (5) – 40% confidence🥈
Place: Peekay (1) – 30% confidence
Show: Our Valentino (2) – 20% confidence🥉
Alternative: Ghostly Chance (4) – 10% confidence🥇

Race notes: Multiple analysts land on George Who (5) and Peekay (1) while still respecting Our Valentino (2), suggesting a fairly formful opening event with modest upset risk focused on Ghostly Chance (4). Other runners include: Wrecking Storm (6), Juana Rumble (3).

Race 2 – Claiming – 1210Y Dirt – Purse not listed

Win: Whiskey Rye (3) – 30% confidence
Place: Running Bear (6) – 30% confidence
Show: Hank Hill (7) – 20% confidence🥈
Alternative: I'mnotforeveryone (4) – 20% confidence🥇

Race notes: Opinions split between Whiskey Rye (3) as a rebound candidate and the fitter Running Bear (6) and Hank Hill (7), with I'mnotforeveryone (4) receiving steady support underneath. Other runners include: Snow Boots (1), Taz Marking (2).

Race 3 – Claiming – 1430Y Dirt – Purse not listed

Win: Fifth Street (5) – 55% confidence🥈
Place: Crossrighthands (1) – 25% confidence
Show: Diablo Rosso (6) – 15% confidence
Alternative: Corie's Boy (2) – 5% confidence🥇

Race notes: Fifth Street (5) is the clearest single on the card off broad top‑pick support, with Crossrighthands (1) the main danger and Diablo Rosso (6) a common underneath inclusion; Corie's Boy (2) is the fringe upset type. Other runners include: Tiger By The Tail (4), Spend Again (8), Using Nitro (7), Copper State (3).

Race 4 – Claiming – 990Y Dirt – Purse not listed WIN

Win: Royal Lineage (6) – 60% confidence🥇
Place: Hennessy Looker Rf (2) – 20% confidence
Show: Ronchetti (4) – 15% confidence
Alternative: Attila's Boy (7) – 5% confidence🥈

Race notes: Analysts are strongly aligned on Royal Lineage (6) as the most likely winner, with Hennessy Looker Rf (2) the key alternative and Ronchetti (4) repeatedly showing in underneath slots; Attila's Boy (7) offers a minor pace‑driven upset angle. Other runners include: I'm A Dreamer Too (1), Nobody's Perfect (3), Sapello Sicario (5), Bonnie Mae's Mark (8).

Race 5 – Maiden Special Weight – 1320Y Dirt – Purse not listed

Win: Gimme A Who (8) – 45% confidence
Place: Made American (6) – 30% confidence
Show: American Century (9) – 10% confidence
Alternative: Onwithit (4) – 15% confidence

Race notes: The maiden event centers on Gimme A Who (8) and Made American (6), with American Century (9) and Onwithit (4) offering upside given lighter public awareness and improving profiles. Other runners include: D C Call Me George (1), Storm Cannon (2), Tap The Prize (3), I'm Just Playing (5), Shiny Shores (7).

Race 6 – Maiden Claiming – 990Y Dirt – Purse not listed

Win: Nogal (7) – 70% confidence
Place: Dashing American (1) – 15% confidence
Show: Low Rollin (6) – 10% confidence
Alternative: Mighty Money (5) – 5% confidence

Race notes: This is one of the strongest consensus spots as analysts repeatedly anchor on Nogal (7), with Dashing American (1) and Low Rollin (6) filling out logical exotics and Mighty Money (5) the only other runner frequently name‑checked. Other runners include: Dashing American (1), Blues Money (2), Giuliano's Song (3), American Class (4), Here I Go Again (8), Perfect Ruler (9).

Race 7 – Claiming – 1430Y Dirt – Purse not listed

Win: Wild Steel (2) – 45% confidence
Place: Leonas Girl (8) – 25% confidence
Show: Girls Don't Cry (3) – 20% confidence
Alternative: True Lovin (4) – 10% confidence

Race notes: Wild Steel (2) is a narrow consensus choice but Leonas Girl (8) and Girls Don't Cry (3) are close behind, creating a competitive three‑deep core with True Lovin (4) as a pace‑trip wild card. Other runners include: Danjerus Cloud (1), Contessa's Song (5), Empress In Front (6), Hazhoni (7), Sapello City Girl (9).

Race 8 – Claiming – 1100Y Dirt – Purse not listed

Win: American Cherub (8) – 70% confidence
Place: Just Keep Laughin (6) – 15% confidence
Show: Sis Spender (2) – 10% confidence
Alternative: Pop's Party (3) – 5% confidence

Race notes: American Cherub (8) is a heavy consensus choice and projects as a key single in multi‑race wagers, while Just Keep Laughin (6), Sis Spender (2), and Pop's Party (3) are widely viewed as the logical supporting cast. Other runners include: La Bella Bella (1), Pop's Party (3), I Get Stormed (4), K P Blamengame (5), Annie Get Ur Guns (7).

Race 9 – Starter Optional Claiming – 990Y Dirt – Purse not listed

Win: Red Leader (4) – 55% confidence
Place: Mister Mafioso (3) – 30% confidence
Show: Teddy's Triumph (5) – 10% confidence
Alternative: Bye Bye Matty P (9) – 5% confidence

Race notes: Analysts repeatedly key Red Leader (4) on win with Mister Mafioso (3) a solid alternative and heavy exacta/trifecta anchor, while Teddy's Triumph (5) and Bye Bye Matty P (9) profile as price‑sensitive upset or underneath types. Other runners include: Discreet Tiger (1), Leap Day (2), Diamond Rapper (6), Sheza Hailstorm (7), Blazing To Gold (8), Follow The Facts (10), Tsunami Gold (11).

Race 10 – Maiden Special Weight – 1210Y Dirt – Purse not listed

Win: Gypsy Wildcat (10) – 55% confidence
Place: Whitney Jayne (9) – 25% confidence
Show: Songcat (3) – 15% confidence
Alternative: Wash Money (6) – 5% confidence

Race notes: Gypsy Wildcat (10) is a strong but not absolute consensus on top, with Whitney Jayne (9) and Songcat (3) both taking meaningful support and Wash Money (6) the main alternative on perceived upside. Other runners include: Bye Bye Vicki (1), Eighteyesondeborah (2), Wicked Whiskey (5), Wash Money (6), Pass The Test (7), Equity Search (8).

Recommended Exotic Plays by Race

Race 1 – Recommended Exotic Plays

Analysts generally see Race 1 as a relatively straightforward claiming sprint centered on George Who (5), Peekay (1), and Our Valentino (2), making exacta and trifecta structures around those three logical. A common approach is an exacta box using George Who (5), Peekay (1), and Our Valentino (2) with a saver including Ghostly Chance (4) in second and third for coverage.

Race 2 – Recommended Exotic Plays

Race 2 shapes as a spread race for vertical exotics with Whiskey Rye (3), Running Bear (6), Hank Hill (7), and I'mnotforeveryone (4) all drawing meaningful support. Analysts would likely build trifectas focusing on Whiskey Rye (3) and Running Bear (6) on top while rotating Hank Hill (7) and I'mnotforeveryone (4) underneath to capture variance in trip and pace outcomes.

Race 3 – Recommended Exotic Plays

With Fifth Street (5) commanding the strongest single profile on the card, many multi‑race tickets will lean heavily here, and vertical exotics can key Fifth Street (5) over Crossrighthands (1) and Diablo Rosso (6). Trifecta players may use a 5 over 1,6 over 1,2,4,6,8 structure to incorporate Corie's Boy (2) and a couple of prices while still depending on the main trio to hit the frame.

Race 4 – Recommended Exotic Plays

Race 4 projects as another race where analysts are comfortable singling Royal Lineage (6) in multi‑race wagers and keying that runner in exactas and trifectas. An efficient play is Royal Lineage (6) over Hennessy Looker Rf (2), Ronchetti (4), and Attila's Boy (7) with a small backup ticket that reverses Hennessy Looker Rf (2) and Royal Lineage (6) in case of a tight finish.

Race 5 – Recommended Exotic Plays

Given the maiden nature and mixed opinions in Race 5, analysts are more inclined to spread and look for trifecta value around Gimme A Who (8), Made American (6), American Century (9), and Onwithit (4). One structure would be 6,8 over 4,6,8,9 over 4,5,6,7,8,9, using the stronger consensus pair in win slots while fishing for a long‑shot third such as Shiny Shores (7) or I'm Just Playing (5).

Race 6 – Recommended Exotic Plays

Race 6 offers a classic single in Nogal (7) for horizontals with a strong case for cold exacta and trifecta plays involving Dashing American (1) and Low Rollin (6). Many exotic tickets will feature Nogal (7) over Dashing American (1) and Low Rollin (6) in exactas, with superfectas adding Mighty Money (5) and one or two others on the bottom rung for coverage at modest additional cost.

Race 7 – Recommended Exotic Plays

The competitive feel of Race 7 suggests boxing Wild Steel (2), Leonas Girl (8), and Girls Don't Cry (3) in exactas and trifectas while peppering True Lovin (4) into third and fourth positions. Analysts may also treat this as a “use four” race in multi‑race sequences, leaning on Wild Steel (2) but recognizing the possibility that a stalking trip benefits either Leonas Girl (8) or Girls Don't Cry (3).

Race 8 – Recommended Exotic Plays

American Cherub (8) is likely to be a central single in horizontal bets and a heavy key in vertical exotics given the overwhelming analyst support. Exacta and trifecta strategies can key American Cherub (8) over Just Keep Laughin (6), Sis Spender (2), and Pop's Party (3), with patient players adding one price such as K P Blamengame (5) for superfecta spice.

Race 9 – Recommended Exotic Plays

Race 9 is tailor‑made for strong exacta and trifecta opinions built around Red Leader (4) and Mister Mafioso (3), who comprise a widely supported top pair. A logical structure is 4,3 over 3,4,5,9 over 1,2,3,4,5,8,9, while multi‑race tickets frequently treat Red Leader (4) as an A with Mister Mafioso (3) a strong B‑level backup.

Race 10 – Recommended Exotic Plays

In Race 10, Gypsy Wildcat (10) is the primary win anchor but the depth of support for Whitney Jayne (9) and Songcat (3) encourages a three‑deep core. Analysts may play 10 over 3,9 over 1,3,6,7,8,9,10 trifectas while also using a small saver with Whitney Jayne (9) and Songcat (3) on top in case the favorite finds trouble.

Value Play Observations

Across the card, several horses appear overlaid relative to how often analysts mention them positively, especially those repeatedly slotted in underneath roles in competitive races. In Race 2, Hank Hill (7) and I'mnotforeveryone (4) show up consistently in the second and third slots, suggesting their win probabilities may exceed their likely betting public odds, which remain anchored on more obvious types like Whiskey Rye (3) and Running Bear (6).

In Race 3, Corie's Boy (2) receives some quiet support as a minor alternative to the dominant Fifth Street (5), which may leave Corie's Boy (2) as an appealing exotic key at double‑digit prices if the favorite underperforms. Similarly, in Race 4, Attila's Boy (7) and Nobody's Perfect (3) have modest but real analyst backing while public attention figures to cluster almost exclusively on Royal Lineage (6) and Hennessy Looker Rf (2).

Race 5's maiden context can produce dramatic overlays on second‑time starters; here, Made American (6) and American Century (9) could both be undervalued if the crowd over‑bets the more exposed Gimme A Who (8). In Race 7, Girls Don't Cry (3) and True Lovin (4) look like logical price alternatives to Wild Steel (2) and Leonas Girl (8), especially if pace dynamics favor off‑the‑speed runners more than the market expects.

Race 9 offers value considerations with Teddy's Triumph (5) and Bye Bye Matty P (9), each frequently appearing as supporting choices but likely to go off at higher prices behind Red Leader (4) and Mister Mafioso (3). Race 10 may produce an underlay in Gypsy Wildcat (10) if the analyst consensus and recent near‑misses cause the public to compress the price too far, leaving Whitney Jayne (9), Songcat (3), and Wash Money (6) as more attractive overlays relative to their actual win chances.

Overall Wagering Strategy

The card features several races with strong analyst alignment that lend themselves to aggressive singling in multi‑race sequences, particularly Race 3 with Fifth Street (5), Race 4 with Royal Lineage (6), Race 6 with Nogal (7), and Race 8 with American Cherub (8). Confidence levels in these spots are generally above the 65 percent range, making them the backbone for Pick 3, Pick 4, and Pick 5 structures in which bettors can concentrate capital and accept short prices in exchange for high hit probability.

By contrast, races such as Race 2, Race 5, Race 7, and Race 9 exhibit more divided opinion, with two or three horses in each race drawing meaningful analyst support for the win position and another layer of runners consistently featured underneath. These split‑opinion races are where bettors should consider broadening coverage and leaning on exotics that reward variance, such as deeper trifecta and superfecta constructions or multi‑race tickets that explicitly account for alternative outcomes beyond the most obvious public choices.

Stringing together multi‑race sequences, one approach is to treat the strongest consensus legs as anchors and use them to afford extra coverage in the more chaotic spots. For example, combining Race 3, Race 4, Race 6, and Race 8 into a Pick 4 built around single or two‑deep structures creates room to spread in Race 2 or Race 5 without inflating ticket cost excessively; similarly, a late Pick 4 from Race 7 through Race 10 can lean on American Cherub (8) and Red Leader (4) while respecting the competitive nature of Race 7 and Race 10 with three‑ and four‑deep coverage.

Exotic value is most promising in the races where favorites are clear but analyst commentary points to multiple logical underneath contenders, such as Race 1, Race 2, Race 5, and Race 9, which offer trifecta and superfecta opportunities built around a strong top choice but a wide, price‑inclusive net underneath. Structural approaches like pressing a key horse on top with several mid‑priced runners in second and third, or using “A/B” and “C” levels for vertical ladders, can capture meaningful payoffs while still respecting the overall consensus hierarchy.

Environmental and track factors, based on the information provided, indicate a warm 75°F afternoon on a dirt surface with no explicit mention of adverse conditions or strong bias, suggesting a relatively fair track where pace and trip will matter more than surface anomalies. In this context, pace‑dependent opinions in sprints such as Race 2 and Race 7 merit special attention, as the distribution between speed and off‑the‑pace types within the analyst picks can hint at subtle expectations about how the track plays by mid‑card.

The key takeaways are that bettors should be willing to strongly commit to the clearest consensus selections in races like 3, 4, 6, and 8, exploit the competitive races by spreading and emphasizing value horses that analysts like but the public may overlook, and design multi‑race tickets that balance narrow, high‑confidence legs with more creative coverage where opinions diverge. Emphasizing disciplined bankroll allocation between singles in strong consensus spots and deeper coverage in volatile races offers the best opportunity to convert the collective analyst perspective into efficient, value‑conscious wagering strategies.

Tags:

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback