Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Aqueduct, December 26, 2025. 60% WIN RATE + 2 EXACTAS + 1 BOXED TRIFECTA


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Race 1 – Maiden Special Weight, 6.5 Furlongs, Dirt WIN

Win: Interstatelovesong (1) – 90% confidence🥇
Place: Carolannie (3) – 75% confidence
Show: Pulling Threads (5) – 65% confidence🥈
Alternative: Dolly's Jolene (4) – 55% confidence

Race 2 – Maiden Special Weight, 8 Furlongs, Dirt WIN ($5.22)

Win: Margarita Molly (8) – 85% confidence🥇
Place: Bernina Express (1) – 80% confidence
Show: Roseberns Dream (7) – 70% confidence
Alternative: Credit Risk (2) – 60% confidence

Race 3 – Allowance Optional Claiming, 9 Furlongs, Dirt WIN ($10.32) + EXACTA ($15.48)

Win: Dreamlike (3) – 90% confidence🥇
Place: Double Your Money (1) – 85% confidence🥈
Show: Military Road (4) – 75% confidence
Alternative: Valentinian (7) – 65% confidence

Race 4 – Maiden Claiming, 8 Furlongs, Dirt

Win: Sequential (6) – 80% confidence🥈
Place: Beck's Dreamer (1) – 75% confidence
Show: Dr. Insel (2) – 70% confidence
Alternative: Thorsness (3) – 55% confidence🥉

Race 5 – Starter Allowance, 8 Furlongs, Dirt WIN ($18.68)

Win: Sailaway (1) – 75% confidence🥇
Place: Sassy Princess (4) – 80% confidence
Show: Sassafrassness (8) – 85% confidence🥈
Alternative: Chocolatechocolate (6) – 60% confidence

Race 6 – Maiden Claiming, 1,430 Yards, Dirt WIN + EXACTA ($19.38)

Win: Baseball Lady (7) – 85% confidence🥇
Place: Makealittlelove (5) – 80% confidence🥈
Show: Sassy Sats (3) – 65% confidence
Alternative: Spicey Ticey (6) – 55% confidence

Race 7 – Allowance, 9 Furlongs, Dirt

Win: Off Script (4) – 85% confidence🥈
Place: Grace And Grit (1) – 75% confidence
Show: Early On (3) – 70% confidence🥉
Alternative: Otherpeoplesmoney (7) – 50% confidence

Race 8 – Allowance Optional Claiming, 1,320 Yards, Dirt

Win: Reliable Lady (6) – 75% confidence🥈
Place: All Class (2) – 75% confidence🥉
Show: Top Gun Girl (8) – 70% confidence
Alternative: Mega Mil (4) – 65% confidence🥇

Race 9 – Alex M. Robb Stakes, 8 Furlongs, Dirt WIN + BOXED TRIFECTA

Win: Doc Sullivan (4) – 95% confidence🥇
Place: Bank Frenzy (2) – 85% confidence🥉
Show: Quick To Accuse (5) – 75% confidence🥈
Alternative: The Wine Steward (1) – 65% confidence

Race 10 – Maiden Claiming, 1,430 Yards, Dirt

Win: Gypsy Dreaming (1) – 90% confidence
Place: Hello Newman (9) – 75% confidence
Show: Freedom Maker (5) – 70% confidence
Alternative: Grey Ace (6) – 60% confidence


Race 1 Exacta: Interstatelovesong (1) with Carolannie (3) represents strong value. The top selection should control the race with Carolannie (3) offering solid second-position credentials. Box Interstatelovesong (1) and Carolannie (3) with Dolly's Jolene (4) for additional coverage.

Race 2 Trifecta: Margarita Molly (8) on top with Bernina Express (1) and Roseberns Dream (7) underneath creates logical ticket structure. Consider wheeling Margarita Molly (8) across the top with multiple second and third combinations given the depth in the field.

Race 3 Daily Double (into Race 4): The transition from Race 3 to Race 4 offers value if Dreamlike (3) or Double Your Money (1) connects. Sequential (6) in Race 4 creates a playable double at modest odds with strong technical support.

Race 4 Pick 3 (Races 4-5-6): Sequential (6), followed by Sassy Princess (4) or Sailaway (1), into Baseball Lady (7) creates a strong three-race sequence. Analysts project consecutive favorites with solid technical form, suggesting value in the pick-3 structure.

Race 5 Exacta: Sailaway (1) over Sassy Princess (4) maintains logical order, though Sassy Princess (4) over Sassafrassness (8) offers an intriguing alternate sequence given the statistical strength of both candidates.

Race 6 Superfecta: Baseball Lady (7) with Makealittlelove (5), Sassy Sats (3), and Spicey Ticey (6) creates comprehensive ticket structure. This race exhibits moderate predictability with four clear contenders warranting superfecta consideration.

Race 7 Exacta: Off Script (4) with Grace And Grit (1) forms the technical backbone. The consensus strongly favors Off Script (4) on top, though multi-leg tickets should include Grace And Grit (1) in alternate positions given the horse's compelling place credentials.

Race 8 Trifecta: Reliable Lady (6) with All Class (2) and Top Gun Girl (8) represents the projected finish order. Consider adding Mega Mil (4) as a deeper alternative given recent technical improvements and moderate odds positioning.

Race 9 Pick 4 (Races 7-8-9-10): This sequence showcases consensus strength. Off Script (4) into Reliable Lady (6) into Doc Sullivan (4) into Gypsy Dreaming (1) creates a reasonable expectation with high confidence ratings across all four selections. The Pick 4 structure offers mutual fund value when favorites align with technical metrics.

Race 10 Superfecta: Gypsy Dreaming (1) with Hello Newman (9), Freedom Maker (5), and Grey Ace (6) creates logical ticket construction. The consensus supports Gypsy Dreaming (1) across multiple expert sources with legitimate secondary contenders beneath.


Value Play Observations

Race 4 Value: Sequential (6) at 7-to-5 offers superior value compared to Beck's Dreamer (1) at 2-to-1. While Beck's Dreamer (1) commands recent experience and trainer credentials, Sequential (6) shows consistent recent form with identical barn support. The public perception may be inflating Beck's Dreamer (1) odds following its Churchill Downs appearance, presenting overlay opportunity on Sequential (6).

Race 5 Value: Sassafrassness (8) at 6-to-1 offers significant overlay potential compared to top-line selections. Five wins from nine attempts represents elite recent performance with minimal market recognition. The horse's recent form suggests competitive equity with the favorites while offering meaningful mutual window value.

Race 7 Value: Otherpeoplesmoney (7) at 20-to-1 represents potential overlay following a narrow defeat at Finger Lakes under heavy backing. Recent form patterns and distance credentials suggest the horse possesses winning probability materially exceeding its overlay odds. Consider underneath trifecta and superfecta construction.

Race 8 Value: Mega Mil (4) at 4-to-1 demonstrates technical improvement curves suggesting potential underlay at current morning line. Recent technical metrics indicate statistical velocity exceeding perceived market value. The consensus ranks Mega Mil (4) fourth, yet odds positioning suggests potential mutual window value despite tight margins.

Race 9 Consistent: Doc Sullivan (4) at 8-to-5 offers fair value rather than clear advantage. The consensus confidence level of 95 percent suggests appropriate odds calibration. The race structure and field quality warrant avoiding overlay pursuit at current pricing while maintaining primary selection integrity.

Race 10 Value: Grey Ace (6) at 8-to-1 warrants consideration as secondary option in exotic structures. The horse demonstrated placing credentials at Aqueduct with prior experience at the track. Current morning line appears fair value, suggesting primary ticket construction focus on consensus selections while including Grey Ace (6) in secondary combinations.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback