Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Belmont at the Big A, October 16, 2025.

Race #1 Expert Picks

Andy Serling: 6-5-1-3

  • Win: Endernite (#6), Place: Brooklyn Styles (#5), Show: Mr. Mashigina (#1)

David Aragona: 1-2-5-3

  • Win: Mr. Mashigina (#1), Place: Felonious (#2), Show: Brooklyn Styles (#5)

Racing Dudes: Uncle Aldo (#4)

  • Win: Uncle Aldo (#4)

FanDuel: Felonious (#2), Likeness (#3), Brooklyn Styles (#5)

  • Win: Felonious (#2), Place: Likeness (#3), Show: Brooklyn Styles (#5)

Tip Meerkat: Mr. Mashigina (#1), Felonious (#2), Brooklyn Styles (#5)

  • Win: Mr. Mashigina (#1), Place: Felonious (#2), Show: Brooklyn Styles (#5)

Racenet: Uncle Aldo (#4), Brooklyn Styles (#5), Felonious (#2), Mr. Mashigina (#1)

  • Win: Uncle Aldo (#4), Place: Brooklyn Styles (#5), Show: Felonious (#2)

At The Races: Felonious (#2), Uncle Aldo (#4)

  • Win: Felonious (#2), Place: Uncle Aldo (#4)

Betting News: Brooklyn Styles (#5), Likeness (#3), Felonious (#2), Uncle Aldo (#4)

  • Win: Brooklyn Styles (#5), Place: Likeness (#3), Show: Felonious (#2)

Fan Odds: Uncle Aldo (#4), Brooklyn Styles (#5), Felonious (#2), Mr. Mashigina (#1)

  • Win: Uncle Aldo (#4), Place: Brooklyn Styles (#5), Show: Felonious (#2)

Race #2 Expert Picks

Andy Serling: 3-2-6-5

  • Win: Tim and Sam (#3), Place: Twirling Lad (#2), Show: Fazzone (#6)

David Aragona: 2-5-3-1

  • Win: Twirling Lad (#2), Place: You’re Lookin Good (#5), Show: Tim and Sam (#3)

Racing Dudes: Twirling Lad (#2)

  • Win: Twirling Lad (#2)

FanDuel: Twirling Lad (#2), Fazzone (#6), Tim and Sam (#3)

  • Win: Twirling Lad (#2), Place: Fazzone (#6), Show: Tim and Sam (#3)

Tip Meerkat: Twirling Lad (#2), Tim and Sam (#3), The Obliterator (#8)

  • Win: Twirling Lad (#2), Place: Tim and Sam (#3), Show: The Obliterator (#8)

Racenet: Twirling Lad (#2), Tim and Sam (#3), Kuleana (#1), Fazzone (#6)

  • Win: Twirling Lad (#2), Place: Tim and Sam (#3), Show: Kuleana (#1)

At The Races: Talk to Me Jimmy (#9), The Obliterator (#8)

  • Win: Talk to Me Jimmy (#9), Place: The Obliterator (#8)

Fan Odds: Twirling Lad (#2), Tim and Sam (#3), Kuleana (#1), Fazzone (#6)

  • Win: Twirling Lad (#2), Place: Tim and Sam (#3), Show: Kuleana (#1)

Race #3 Expert Picks

Andy Serling: 4-2-1-3

  • Win: Another Cleeshay (#4), Place: Cha Cha Wren (#2), Show: Spirit of Esther (#1)

David Aragona: 2-1-8-6

  • Win: Cha Cha Wren (#2), Place: Spirit of Esther (#1), Show: Twirly (#8)

Racing Dudes: Twirly (#8)

  • Win: Twirly (#8)

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: Twirly (#8)

  • Win: Twirly (#8)

FanDuel: Spirit of Esther (#1), Toxic Girl (#7) (Note: Twirly #8 scratched)

  • Win: Spirit of Esther (#1), Place: Toxic Girl (#7)

Tip Meerkat: Spirit of Esther (#1), Furry Fox (#3), Cha Cha Wren (#2)

  • Win: Spirit of Esther (#1), Place: Furry Fox (#3), Show: Cha Cha Wren (#2)

Racenet: Spirit of Esther (#1), Twirly (#8), Furry Fox (#3), Cha Cha Wren (#2)

  • Win: Spirit of Esther (#1), Place: Twirly (#8), Show: Furry Fox (#3)

At The Races: Twirly (#8), Spirit of Esther (#1)

  • Win: Twirly (#8), Place: Spirit of Esther (#1)

Betting News: Spirit of Esther (#1), Furry Fox (#3), Twirly (#8), Cha Cha Wren (#2)

  • Win: Spirit of Esther (#1), Place: Furry Fox (#3), Show: Twirly (#8)

Fan Odds: Spirit of Esther (#1), Twirly (#8), Furry Fox (#3), Cha Cha Wren (#2)

  • Win: Spirit of Esther (#1), Place: Twirly (#8), Show: Furry Fox (#3)

Race #4 Expert Picks

Andy Serling: 6-2-5-7

  • Win: Practical Lov (#6), Place: With the Angels (#2), Show: Sarir (#5)

David Aragona: 2-6-1-5

  • Win: With the Angels (#2), Place: Practical Lov (#6), Show: Wild Mama (#1)

Racing Dudes: With the Angels (#2)

  • Win: With the Angels (#2)

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: With the Angels (#2)

  • Win: With the Angels (#2)

FanDuel: With the Angels (#2), Filly Crystal (#7), Looks First (#4)

  • Win: With the Angels (#2), Place: Filly Crystal (#7), Show: Looks First (#4)

Tip Meerkat: With the Angels (#2), Sarir (#5), Practical Lov (#6)

  • Win: With the Angels (#2), Place: Sarir (#5), Show: Practical Lov (#6)

Racenet: With the Angels (#2), Practical Lov (#6), Sporting Lady (#3), Wild Mama (#1)

  • Win: With the Angels (#2), Place: Practical Lov (#6), Show: Sporting Lady (#3)

At The Races: With the Angels (#2), Practical Lov (#6)

  • Win: With the Angels (#2), Place: Practical Lov (#6)

Betting News: With the Angels (#2), Filly Crystal (#7), Practical Lov (#6), Sarir (#5)

  • Win: With the Angels (#2), Place: Filly Crystal (#7), Show: Practical Lov (#6)

Fan Odds: With the Angels (#2), Practical Lov (#6), Sporting Lady (#3), Wild Mama (#1)

  • Win: With the Angels (#2), Place: Practical Lov (#6), Show: Sporting Lady (#3)

Race #5 Expert Picks

Andy Serling: 9-3-5-7

  • Win: Britain (#9), Place: Ms Sophistication (#3), Show: Quiddity (#5)

David Aragona: 5-9-3-6

  • Win: Quiddity (#5), Place: Britain (#9), Show: Ms Sophistication (#3)

Racing Dudes: Saratoga Party (#4)

  • Win: Saratoga Party (#4)

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: Ms Sophistication (#3)

  • Win: Ms Sophistication (#3)

FanDuel: Quiddity (#5), Ms Sophistication (#3), Tiz the Lady (#7)

  • Win: Quiddity (#5), Place: Ms Sophistication (#3), Show: Tiz the Lady (#7)

Tip Meerkat: Ms Sophistication (#3), Shilling (#6), Quiddity (#5)

  • Win: Ms Sophistication (#3), Place: Shilling (#6), Show: Quiddity (#5)

Racenet: Britain (#9), Full of Tact (#2), Baffle (#1), Ms Sophistication (#3)

  • Win: Britain (#9), Place: Full of Tact (#2), Show: Baffle (#1)

At The Races: Ms Sophistication (#3), Baffle (#1)

  • Win: Ms Sophistication (#3), Place: Baffle (#1)

Fan Odds: Britain (#9), Full of Tact (#2), Baffle (#1), Ms Sophistication (#3)

  • Win: Britain (#9), Place: Full of Tact (#2), Show: Baffle (#1)

Race #6 Expert Picks

Andy Serling: 7-3-1-5

  • Win: Meg’s Foxy Grey (#7), Place: Sailaway (#3), Show: I’m Buzzy (#1)

David Aragona: 8-3-1-6

  • Win: Melle Mel (#8), Place: Sailaway (#3), Show: I’m Buzzy (#1)

Racing Dudes: I’m Buzzy (#1)

  • Win: I’m Buzzy (#1)

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: She’s Complicated (#5)

  • Win: She’s Complicated (#5)

FanDuel: Melle Mel (#8), Spun Size (#2), Sailaway (#3)

  • Win: Melle Mel (#8), Place: Spun Size (#2), Show: Sailaway (#3)

Tip Meerkat: I’m Buzzy (#1), Melle Mel (#8), Sailaway (#3)

  • Win: I’m Buzzy (#1), Place: Melle Mel (#8), Show: Sailaway (#3)

Racenet: She’s Complicated (#5), I’m Buzzy (#1), Melle Mel (#8), Sight to See (#6)

  • Win: She’s Complicated (#5), Place: I’m Buzzy (#1), Show: Melle Mel (#8)

At The Races: Sailaway (#3), She’s Complicated (#5)

  • Win: Sailaway (#3), Place: She’s Complicated (#5)

Fan Odds: She’s Complicated (#5), I’m Buzzy (#1), Melle Mel (#8), Sight to See (#6)

  • Win: She’s Complicated (#5), Place: I’m Buzzy (#1), Show: Melle Mel (#8)

Race #7 Expert Picks

Andy Serling: 5-8-2-7

  • Win: Winnebago (#5), Place: Innate (#8), Show: Niagara Skyline (#2)

David Aragona: 5-2-8-6

  • Win: Winnebago (#5), Place: Niagara Skyline (#2), Show: Innate (#8)

Racing Dudes: No Evidence (#6) (Note: Scratched)

  • Win: No Evidence (#6)

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: Innate (#8)

  • Win: Innate (#8)

FanDuel: Innate (#8) (Note: Georgia Magic #10 and No Evidence #6 scratched)

  • Win: Innate (#8)

Tip Meerkat: Niagara Skyline (#2), No Evidence (#6), Winnebago (#5)

  • Win: Niagara Skyline (#2), Place: No Evidence (#6), Show: Winnebago (#5)

Racenet: Innate (#8), Finestkind (#4), Niagara Skyline (#2), Hilarious Affair (#3)

  • Win: Innate (#8), Place: Finestkind (#4), Show: Niagara Skyline (#2)

At The Races: Niagara Skyline (#2), No Evidence (#6)

  • Win: Niagara Skyline (#2), Place: No Evidence (#6)

Fan Odds: Innate (#8), Finestkind (#4), Niagara Skyline (#2), Hilarious Affair (#3)

  • Win: Innate (#8), Place: Finestkind (#4), Show: Niagara Skyline (#2)

Race #8 Expert Picks

Andy Serling: 4-3-1-2

  • Win: Mis Brunellas (#4), Place: Belle of Georgia (#3), Show: Consider Me First (#1)

David Aragona: 6-4-9-2

  • Win: Just Tell Anne (#6), Place: Mis Brunellas (#4), Show: Market Hours (#9)

Racing Dudes: Market Hours (#9)

  • Win: Market Hours (#9)

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: Great Actress (#7)

  • Win: Great Actress (#7)

FanDuel: Just Tell Anne (#6), Belle of Georgia (#3) (Note: Year End Bonus #12 scratched)

  • Win: Just Tell Anne (#6), Place: Belle of Georgia (#3)

Tip Meerkat: Belle of Georgia (#3), Mis Brunellas (#4), Market Hours (#9)

  • Win: Belle of Georgia (#3), Place: Mis Brunellas (#4), Show: Market Hours (#9)

Racenet: Fonzi Angel (#10), Great Actress (#7), Market Hours (#9), Mis Brunellas (#4)

  • Win: Fonzi Angel (#10), Place: Great Actress (#7), Show: Market Hours (#9)

At The Races: Year End Bonus (#12), Belle of Georgia (#3)

  • Win: Year End Bonus (#12), Place: Belle of Georgia (#3)

Fan Odds: Fonzi Angel (#10), Great Actress (#7), Market Hours (#9), Mis Brunellas (#4)

  • Win: Fonzi Angel (#10), Place: Great Actress (#7), Show: Market Hours (#9)

Consensus Picks Analysis

Race #1 Consensus

  • Win: Uncle Aldo (33% confidence)
  • Place: Brooklyn Styles (56% confidence)
  • Show: Felonious (56% confidence)

Race #2 Consensus

  • Win: Twirling Lad (75% confidence)
  • Place: Tim and Sam (63% confidence)
  • Show: Fazzone (38% confidence)

Race #3 Consensus

  • Win: Spirit of Esther (63% confidence)
  • Place: Twirly (38% confidence)
  • Show: Furry Fox (38% confidence)

Race #4 Consensus

  • Win: With the Angels (90% confidence)
  • Place: Practical Lov (70% confidence)
  • Show: Sporting Lady (30% confidence)

Race #5 Consensus

  • Win: Ms Sophistication (44% confidence)
  • Place: Britain (33% confidence)
  • Show: Quiddity (44% confidence)

Race #6 Consensus

  • Win: I’m Buzzy (33% confidence)
  • Place: Sailaway (33% confidence)
  • Show: Melle Mel (56% confidence)

Race #7 Consensus

  • Win: Innate (44% confidence)
  • Place: Niagara Skyline (56% confidence)
  • Show: Winnebago (33% confidence)

Race #8 Consensus

  • Win: Market Hours (33% confidence)
  • Place: Belle of Georgia (44% confidence)
  • Show: Mis Brunellas (44% confidence)

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback