Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Belmont at the Big A October 2, 2025.

Race #1 Expert Picks

Sara Elbadwi: 3 Rest Ashore (W), 4 Caitlins Threes (P), 6 Coola Boola (S), 7 Oscar Bound (4th)

FanDuel: 2 Tapit Back (W), 1 Peace Of Gold (P) Note: Coola Boola scratched

Racing Dudes: 7 Oscar Bound (W)

Betting News: 4 Caitlins Threes (W), 7 Oscar Bound (P), 2 Tapit Back (S), 6 Coola Boola (4th)

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: 6 Coola Boola (W) Note: Scratched

Tip Meerkat: 4 Caitlins Threes (W), 6 Coola Boola (P), 7 Oscar Bound (S) Note: Coola Boola scratched

Racenet: 4 Caitlins Threes (W), 1 Peace Of Gold (P), 6 Coola Boola (S), 2 Tapit Back (4th) Note: Coola Boola scratched

At The Races: 6 Coola Boola (W), 2 Tapit Back (P) Note: Coola Boola scratched

Hitch Abernathy: 7 Oscar Bound (W), 6 Coola Boola (P), 4 Caitlins Threes (S) Note: Coola Boola scratched

Race #2 Expert Picks

Sara Elbadwi: 7 Underbidder (W), 10 Glavine (P), 1 Jet Off (S), 8 Copa de Plata (4th)

FanDuel: 7 Underbidder (W), 5 Bellamy (P), 8 Copa de Plata (P)

Racing Dudes: 7 Underbidder (W)

Betting News: No picks provided for Race 2

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: 10 Glavine (W)

Tip Meerkat: 4 Omaha Storm (W), 7 Underbidder (P), 3 Jubilee Parade (S)

Racenet: 10 Glavine (W), 7 Underbidder (P), 8 Copa de Plata (S), 1 Jet Off (4th)

At The Races: 10 Glavine (W), 7 Underbidder (P)

Hitch Abernathy: 7 Underbidder (W), 10 Glavine (P), 5 Bellamy (S)

Race #3 Expert Picks

Sara Elbadwi: 1 Tahoe Sunrise (W), 7 Flying Liam (P), 5 Celestial Glaze (S), 6 Notah (4th)

FanDuel: 4 Crushed It (W), 5 Celestial Glaze (W), 7 Flying Liam (P)

Racing Dudes: 6 Notah (W)

Betting News: No picks provided for Race 3

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: 2 Tarpaulin (W)

Tip Meerkat: 2 Tarpaulin (W), 4 Crushed It (P), 5 Celestial Glaze (S)

Racenet: 2 Tarpaulin (W), 1 Tahoe Sunrise (P), 4 Crushed It (S), 8 Free Dance (4th)

At The Races: 4 Crushed It (W), 2 Tarpaulin (P)

Hitch Abernathy: 6 Notah (W), 5 Celestial Glaze (P), 4 Crushed It (S)

Race #4 Expert Picks

Sara Elbadwi: 9 Dynadee (W), 6 Behold the King (P), 2 Special Envoy (S), 7 Chambersville (4th)

FanDuel: 7 Chambersville (W), 8 Oban (W), 1 Fleet N Ready (P)

Racing Dudes: 2 Special Envoy (W)

Betting News: No picks provided for Race 4

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: 6 Behold the King (W)

Tip Meerkat: 2 Special Envoy (W), 3 Epic Desire (P), 6 Behold the King (S)

Racenet: 6 Behold the King (W), 3 Epic Desire (P), 7 Chambersville (S), 5 Stream It (4th)

At The Races: 6 Behold the King (W), 2 Special Envoy (P)

Hitch Abernathy: 6 Behold the King (W), 3 Epic Desire (P), 7 Chambersville (S)

Race #5 Expert Picks

Sara Elbadwi: 6 Snow Face Princess (W), 3 Just Philtored (P), 12 Bella Knows (S), 2 Snappy Comeback (4th) Note: Snow Face Princess scratched

FanDuel: 3 Just Philtored (W), 4 Should’ve (P) Note: Snow Face Princess scratched

Racing Dudes: 4 Should’ve (W)

Betting News: No picks provided for Race 5

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: 3 Just Philtored (W)

Tip Meerkat: 2 Snappy Comeback (W), 8 Royal Testament (P), 5 Final Accord (S)

Racenet: 6 Snow Face Princess (W), 3 Just Philtored (P), 1 Oscar’s Encore (S), 4 Should’ve (4th) Note: Snow Face Princess scratched

At The Races: 8 Royal Testament (W), 6 Snow Face Princess (P) Note: Snow Face Princess scratched

Hitch Abernathy: 1 Oscar’s Encore (W), 2 Snappy Comeback (P), 5 Final Accord (S)

Race #6 Expert Picks

Sara Elbadwi: 5 Graywing (W), 9 Master of Arms (P), 2 Gatsby (S), 3 Forgiving Spirit (4th) Note: Gatsby scratched

FanDuel: 4 Manta Rey (W), 9 Master of Arms (P) Note: Gatsby scratched

Racing Dudes: 9 Master of Arms (W)

Betting News: 9 Master of Arms (W), 3 Forgiving Spirit (P), 4 Manta Rey (S), 1 Fitzpatrick (4th)

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: 9 Master of Arms (W)

Tip Meerkat: 2 Gatsby (W), 3 Forgiving Spirit (P), 9 Master of Arms (S) Note: Gatsby scratched

Racenet: 2 Gatsby (W), 9 Master of Arms (P), 3 Forgiving Spirit (S), 4 Manta Rey (4th) Note: Gatsby scratched

At The Races: 9 Master of Arms (W), 2 Gatsby (P) Note: Gatsby scratched

Hitch Abernathy: 4 Manta Rey (W), 2 Gatsby (P), 9 Master of Arms (S) Note: Gatsby scratched

Race #7 Expert Picks

Sara Elbadwi: 9 Brocknardini (W), 4 Avenue Niel (P), 8 Grayosh (S), 3 Immensitude (4th)

FanDuel: 8 Grayosh (W), 3 Immensitude (P), 2 Fun With Flags (S)

Racing Dudes: 8 Grayosh (W)

Betting News: 3 Immensitude (W), 1 Fantasy Performer (P), 8 Grayosh (S), 2 Fun With Flags (4th)

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: 8 Grayosh (W)

Tip Meerkat: 2 Fun With Flags (W), 8 Grayosh (P), 3 Immensitude (S)

Racenet: 3 Immensitude (W), 8 Grayosh (P), 2 Fun With Flags (S), 5 Allamericanbeauty (4th)

At The Races: 3 Immensitude (W), 2 Fun With Flags (P)

Hitch Abernathy: 8 Grayosh (W), 9 Brocknardini (P), 4 Avenue Niel (S)

Race #8 Expert Picks

Sara Elbadwi: 2 Tahila (W), 1 Garden of Grace (P), 5 Five Dozen Roses (S), 11 Froghollowsummer (4th)

FanDuel: 1 Garden of Grace (W), 11 Froghollowsummer (W), 2 Tahila (P)

Racing Dudes: 2 Tahila (W)

Betting News: No picks provided for Race 8

Guaranteed Tip Sheet: 1 Garden of Grace (W)

Tip Meerkat: 1 Garden of Grace (W), 2 Tahila (P), 5 Five Dozen Roses (S)

Racenet: 2 Tahila (W), 1 Garden of Grace (P), 5 Five Dozen Roses (S), 10 In Fact Sheza Zask (4th)

At The Races: 1 Garden of Grace (W), 2 Tahila (P)

Hitch Abernathy: 1 Garden of Grace (W), 9 Bourbon Slip (P), 7 Amelia (S)

Additional Source – Keeneland: 3 Just Philtored (W), 6 Snow Face Princess (P), 5 Final Accord (S) for Race 5; 9 Master of Arms (W), 5 Graywing (P), 2 Gatsby (S) for Race 6; 8 Grayosh (W) for Race 7

Additional Source – Xpressbet: 6 Notah (W) for Race 3

Additional Source – DRF TimeformUS: 3 Forgiving Spirit (W) for Race 6


Consensus Picks Summary

Race #1 Consensus

Win: 4 Caitlins Threes (75% confidence)
Place: 7 Oscar Bound (67% confidence)
Show: 2 Tapit Back (60% confidence)

Race #2 Consensus

Win: 7 Underbidder (78% confidence)
Place: 10 Glavine (75% confidence)
Show: 8 Copa de Plata (50% confidence)

Race #3 Consensus

Win: 2 Tarpaulin (50% confidence)
Place: 4 Crushed It (60% confidence)
Show: 5 Celestial Glaze (67% confidence)

Race #4 Consensus

Win: 6 Behold the King (78% confidence)
Place: 2 Special Envoy (60% confidence)
Show: 3 Epic Desire (50% confidence)

Race #5 Consensus

Win: 3 Just Philtored (60% confidence)
Place: 8 Royal Testament (50% confidence)
Show: 4 Should’ve (50% confidence)

Race #6 Consensus

Win: 9 Master of Arms (89% confidence)
Place: 3 Forgiving Spirit (67% confidence)
Show: 4 Manta Rey (75% confidence)

Race #7 Consensus

Win: 8 Grayosh (78% confidence)
Place: 3 Immensitude (67% confidence)
Show: 2 Fun With Flags (60% confidence)

Race #8 Consensus

Win: 1 Garden of Grace (78% confidence)
Place: 2 Tahila (89% confidence)
Show: 5 Five Dozen Roses (50% confidence)

Note: Several horses were scratched including Coola Boola (Race 1), Snow Face Princess (Race 5), and Gatsby (Race 6), which affected some handicappers’ original selections.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback