Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Keeneland, October 3, 2025.

Race #1 Expert Picks

Handicappers and their picks:

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: I Had That One Too #6, Place: Nerazurri #7, Show: Miss Ellary #2
Tom Leech: Win: Miss Ellary #2, Place: Landan #5, Show: Nerazurri #7
Kyle Hampton: Win: Nerazurri #7, Place: I Had That One Too #6, Show: Indy Label #4
Racing Dudes: Win: Nerazurri #7
FanDuel: Win: Nerazurri #7, Place: All About Alice #8, Show: Indy Label #4
Tip Meerkat: Win: Miss Ellary #2, Place: Indy Label #4, Show: I Had That One Too #6
At The Races: Win: Indy Label #4, Place: Miss Ellary #2
Betting News: Win: Miss Ellary #2, Place: Landan #5, Show: I Had That One Too #6
Keeneland Picks: Win: Nerazurri #7, Place: Indy Label #4, Show: Miss Ellary #2
VSiN – Mr. Ed: Win: Miss Ellary #2, Show: Nerazurri #7

Race #2 Expert Picks

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: A Cab On the Rocks #2, Place: Vino Subito #4, Show: Fame Chaser #9
Tom Leech: Win: Zucchero #1, Place: Alexander K #6, Show: Fame Chaser #9
Racing Dudes: Win: Perfect Audible #8
FanDuel: Win: Romantic Ride #3, Place: Perfect Audible #8, Show: Fame Chaser #9
Tip Meerkat: Win: Perfect Audible #8, Place: State Conceal #11, Show: Fame Chaser #9
At The Races: Win: Fame Chaser #9, Place: Perfect Audible #8
Keeneland Picks: Win: Fame Chaser #9, Place: Mountain High #12, Show: Perfect Audible #8
VSiN – Mr. Ed: Win: Perfect Audible #8, Show: Fame Chaser #9

Race #3 Expert Picks

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: Turner’s Charm #1, Place: Live Your Dreams #4, Show: Sneakily #6
Tom Leech: Win: Sneakily #6, Place: Live Your Dreams #4, Show: Menkaure #8
Kyle Hampton: Win: Sneakily #6, Place: Menkaure #8, Show: Last Curtain Call #12
Racing Dudes: Win: Sneakily #6
FanDuel: Win: Atlantic Beach #10, Place: Turner’s Charm #1, Show: Sneakily #6
Tip Meerkat: Win: Last Curtain Call #12, Place: Sneakily #6, Show: Turner’s Charm #1
At The Races: Win: Sneakily #6, Place: Turner’s Charm #1
Keeneland Picks: Win: Turner’s Charm #1, Place: Last Curtain Call #12, Show: Ginger Ale #2
VSiN – Mr. Ed: Win: Trust Account #5

Race #4 Expert Picks

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: Spa Prospector #4, Place: Donna Romano #7, Show: Fond of You #9
Tom Leech: Win: Fond of You #9, Place: Donna Romano #7, Show: Spa Prospector #4
Kyle Hampton: Win: Prowess #6, Place: Donna Romano #7, Show: Spa Prospector #4
Racing Dudes: Win: Kingsolver #1
FanDuel: Win: Kingsolver #1, Place: Donna Romano #7, Show: My Sweetheart #5
Tip Meerkat: Win: Donna Romano #7, Place: Prowess #6, Show: Kingsolver #1
At The Races: Win: Donna Romano #7, Place: Kingsolver #1
Keeneland Picks: Win: Spa Prospector #4, Place: Kingsolver #1, Show: My Sweetheart #5
VSiN – Mr. Ed: Win: Kingsolver #1, Place: Spa Prospector #4, Show: Donna Romano #7

Race #5 Expert Picks

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: Divine Justice #6, Show: Nu What’s New #3
Tom Leech: Win: Divine Justice #6, Place: Barb #10, Show: Hitchcock #5
Kyle Hampton: Win: Hitchcock #5, Place: Nu What’s New #3, Show: Divine Justice #6
Racing Dudes: Win: Divine Justice #6
FanDuel: Win: Barb #10, Place: Crazy Diamond #11, Show: Bob Mo #4
Tip Meerkat: Win: Nu What’s New #3, Place: Crazy Diamond #11, Show: Barb #10
At The Races: Win: Divine Justice #6, Place: Nu What’s New #3
Keeneland Picks: Win: Divine Justice #6, Place: Barb #10, Show: Lucius Verus #7
VSiN – Mr. Ed: Win: Hitchcock #5

Race #6 Expert Picks

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: In the Stars #6, Place: Exclusive Star #11, Show: Modern Sound #12
Tom Leech: Win: Hear the Queen #2, Place: Golden Gamble #9, Show: In the Stars #6
Kyle Hampton: Win: Modern Sound #12, Place: Hear the Queen #2, Show: Golden Gamble #9
Racing Dudes: Win: Hear the Queen #2
FanDuel: Win: Hear the Queen #2, Place: Exclusive Star #11, Show: Cliffs #14
Tip Meerkat: Win: Eunomia #10, Place: Hear the Queen #2, Show: Cliffs #14
At The Races: Win: Hear the Queen #2, Place: In the Stars #6
Keeneland Picks: Win: In the Stars #6, Place: Exclusive Star #11, Show: Golden Gamble #9
VSiN – Mr. Ed: Win: Hear the Queen #2

Race #7 Expert Picks

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: Nakatomi #5, Show: World Record #4
Tom Leech: Win: World Record #4, Place: Nakatomi #5, Show: Whatchatalkinabout #2
Kyle Hampton: Win: Nakatomi #5, Place: Whatchatalkinabout #2, Show: World Record #4
Racing Dudes: Win: World Record #4
FanDuel: Win: Whatchatalkinabout #2, Place: Skelly #3, Show: Nakatomi #5
Tip Meerkat: Win: Skelly #3, Place: World Record #4, Show: Nakatomi #5
At The Races: Win: World Record #4, Place: Nakatomi #5
Betting News: Win: Whatchatalkinabout #2, Place: Nakatomi #5, Show: Durante #1
Keeneland Picks: Win: Nakatomi #5, Place: World Record #4, Show: Skelly #3

Race #8 Expert Picks

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: Aggressive Lime #4, Place: Time to Dream #12, Show: Soloist #13 (AE)
Tom Leech: Win: Mackinac #2, Place: Time to Dream #12, Show: Aggressive Lime #4
Kyle Hampton: Win: Mackinac #2, Place: Time to Dream #12, Show: Lit Ship #1
Racing Dudes: Win: Time to Dream #12
FanDuel: Win: Imaginationthelady #11, Place: Time to Dream #12, Show: Aggressive Lime #4
Tip Meerkat: Win: Mackinac #2, Place: Imaginationthelady #11, Show: Soloist #13
At The Races: Win: Time to Dream #12, Place: Mackinac #2
Keeneland Picks: Win: Aggressive Lime #4, Place: Time to Dream #12, Show: Loveliest #8

Race #9 Expert Picks

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: Tommy Jo #3, Show: Percy’s Bar #1
Tom Leech: Win: Percy’s Bar #1, Show: Tommy Jo #3
Kyle Hampton: Win: Tommy Jo #3, Place: Haute Diva #5, Show: Percy’s Bar #1
Racing Dudes: Win: Tommy Jo #3
FanDuel: Win: Tommy Jo #3, Place: Percy’s Bar #1, Show: The Grumpy Rabbit #4
Tip Meerkat: Win: Percy’s Bar #1, Place: The Grumpy Rabbit #4, Show: Haute Diva #5
At The Races: Win: Tommy Jo #3, Place: Percy’s Bar #1
Betting News: Win: Percy’s Bar #1, Place: Haute Diva #5, Show: Tommy Jo #3
Keeneland Picks: Win: Tommy Jo #3, Place: Go to Girl #2, Show: Percy’s Bar #1
VSiN – Mr. Ed: Win: Tommy Jo #3

Race #10 Expert Picks

Roberto Rodriguez: Win: Market Chill #10, Place: Miss Watermelon #8, Show: Raiding Party (Ire) #1
Tom Leech: Win: Beach Ballad #4, Place: Market Chill #10, Show: Raiding Party (Ire) #1
Kyle Hampton: Win: Cove Spring #6, Place: Market Chill #10, Show: Miss Watermelon #8
Racing Dudes: Win: Market Chill #10
FanDuel: Win: Beach Ballad #4, Place: Dare To Impress #5, Show: Cove Spring #6
Tip Meerkat: Win: Beach Ballad #4, Place: Market Chill #10, Show: Cove Spring #6
At The Races: Win: Market Chill #10, Place: Beach Ballad #4
Keeneland Picks: Win: Market Chill #10, Place: Inkling #7, Show: Miss Watermelon #8

Consensus Expert Picks

Race #1 Consensus

Win: Nerazurri #7 (40%), Miss Ellary #2 (30%), Indy Label #4 (10%)
Place: Nerazurri #7 (30%), Indy Label #4 (30%), Miss Ellary #2 (20%)
Show: Miss Ellary #2 (30%), Nerazurri #7 (30%), I Had That One Too #6 (20%)

Race #2 Consensus

Win: Perfect Audible #8 (30%), Fame Chaser #9 (20%), A Cab On the Rocks #2 (10%)
Place: Perfect Audible #8 (20%), Fame Chaser #9 (20%), Time to Dream #12 (10%)
Show: Fame Chaser #9 (30%), Perfect Audible #8 (20%), A Cab On the Rocks #2 (10%)

Race #3 Consensus

Win: Sneakily #6 (50%), Turner’s Charm #1 (20%), Atlantic Beach #10 (10%)
Place: Sneakily #6 (20%), Turner’s Charm #1 (20%), Live Your Dreams #4 (20%)
Show: Sneakily #6 (20%), Turner’s Charm #1 (20%), Menkaure #8 (20%)

Race #4 Consensus

Win: Donna Romano #7 (30%), Kingsolver #1 (30%), Spa Prospector #4 (20%)
Place: Donna Romano #7 (50%), Kingsolver #1 (30%), Spa Prospector #4 (20%)
Show: Spa Prospector #4 (30%), My Sweetheart #5 (20%), Kingsolver #1 (20%)

Race #5 Consensus

Win: Divine Justice #6 (50%), Hitchcock #5 (20%), Barb #10 (10%)
Place: Barb #10 (20%), Nu What’s New #3 (20%), Divine Justice #6 (20%)
Show: Divine Justice #6 (20%), Hitchcock #5 (20%), Barb #10 (20%)

Race #6 Consensus

Win: Hear the Queen #2 (50%), In the Stars #6 (30%), Modern Sound #12 (10%)
Place: Hear the Queen #2 (30%), Exclusive Star #11 (20%), Golden Gamble #9 (20%)
Show: In the Stars #6 (20%), Golden Gamble #9 (20%), Cliffs #14 (20%)

Race #7 Consensus

Win: World Record #4 (30%), Nakatomi #5 (30%), Whatchatalkinabout #2 (20%)
Place: Nakatomi #5 (40%), World Record #4 (30%), Whatchatalkinabout #2 (20%)
Show: Nakatomi #5 (30%), World Record #4 (20%), Whatchatalkinabout #2 (20%)

Race #8 Consensus

Win: Time to Dream #12 (30%), Mackinac #2 (30%), Aggressive Lime #4 (20%)
Place: Time to Dream #12 (60%), Mackinac #2 (20%), Aggressive Lime #4 (10%)
Show: Aggressive Lime #4 (30%), Soloist #13 (20%), Lit Ship #1 (20%)

Race #9 Consensus

Win: Tommy Jo #3 (70%), Percy’s Bar #1 (30%)
Place: Percy’s Bar #1 (30%), Haute Diva #5 (20%), The Grumpy Rabbit #4 (10%)
Show: Percy’s Bar #1 (40%), Tommy Jo #3 (30%), Haute Diva #5 (20%)

Race #10 Consensus

Win: Market Chill #10 (50%), Beach Ballad #4 (30%), Cove Spring #6 (10%)
Place: Market Chill #10 (40%), Beach Ballad #4 (20%), Dare To Impress #5 (10%)
Show: Cove Spring #6 (30%), Miss Watermelon #8 (20%), Raiding Party (Ire) #1 (20%)

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback