Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.
Race 1 – Claiming, 1323Y (6f), Dirt, $15,372 Purse BOXED TRIFECTA
Win: 3-Vitaemi (88% confidence)🥉
Place: 5-Miss Shady (62% confidence)🥈
Show: 2-Full Time Strutin (50% confidence)🥇
Alternative: 1-Oaxaca (25% confidence)
Strong two-horse battle expected between Vitaemi and Miss Shady. Vitaemi shows consistent placing in similar races and draws overwhelming support from handicappers. Miss Shady returns from a six-week layoff with solid Mahoning Valley form. Full Time Strutin has finished close behind these two in recent starts and represents solid show value. The surface should be fast with temperatures around 39 degrees, favoring horses with tactical speed. Consider exacta box with top two selections.
Race 2 – Allowance, 1323Y (6f), Dirt, $25,000 Purse
Win: 3-City Scene (100% confidence)Place: 2-Minestress (62% confidence)🥉Show: 4-Candlelight Hours (50% confidence)Alternative: 1-Practicallyelusive (38% confidence)🥇
City Scene receives unanimous support after impressive stakes victory last time. Every handicapper has this filly in their top three selections. Minestress drops in class and should benefit from the move. Candlelight Hours has multiple wins at this venue and represents solid value in the place and show positions. Practicallyelusive returns from a 20-week layoff which creates some uncertainty despite strong past performances. This looks like a standout race for City Scene.
Race 3 – Claiming, 8F, Dirt, $12,500 Purse
Win: 6-Action Man (56% confidence)
Place: 3-Citizen (56% confidence)
Show: 4-Tetched (44% confidence)🥈
Alternative: 1-Third City (33% confidence)🥇
Extremely close call between Action Man and Citizen for the win. Action Man won last time at this track and has excellent venue-specific form. Citizen shows strong overall form with two wins from nine starts this campaign and finished third last time at Thistledown. Tetched placed as favorite last start and should run fitter with additional seasoning. The two-turn mile configuration favors horses with strong closing ability. Third City offers value as an each-way proposition for vertical exotics.
Race 4 – Allowance, 1323Y (6f), Dirt, $25,000 Purse WIN
Win: 1-Win Herbie Win (75% confidence)🥇
Place: 6-Bold Buckeye (50% confidence)
Show: 2-Excitement (50% confidence)🥉Alternative: 5-Big Prankster (38% confidence)
Win Herbie Win emerges as clear consensus choice after impressive victory over course and distance last time. Three wins from seven attempts this campaign demonstrate consistency at this level. Bold Buckeye returns from seven-week break with two wins from five tries this prep. Excitement has been consistently placed in similar races and represents solid value in exotics. Big Prankster returns from five-week layoff and could provide upset potential at a price. Strong pace scenario expected with multiple speed types.
Race 5 – Claiming, 1323Y (6f), Dirt, $15,372 Purse
Win: 1-Style In Time (62% confidence)🥈
Place: 3-Marmara (50% confidence)Show: 10-Miss Foxann (50% confidence)Alternative: 2-Crackle (38% confidence)🥇
Competitive claiming event with multiple legitimate contenders. Style In Time won first time out this prep and draws ideally for tactical positioning. Marmara comes off victory at Charles Town and shows strong form with two wins from eight attempts. Miss Foxann drops in class after competitive efforts at higher levels. Crackle provides early speed and could control the pace scenario. The wide-open nature of this race creates excellent opportunities for exotic wagering. Consider trifecta and superfecta combinations with top four selections.
Race 6 – Claiming, 8F 66Y, Dirt, $12,500 Purse BOXED TRIFECTA
Win: 3-Smash (75% confidence)🥉Place: 2-Only Getn Better (75% confidence)Show: 5-Master Of The Nite (38% confidence)🥈
Alternative: 6-Poppys Pride (38% confidence)🥇
Rare situation where two horses receive equal strong support for different positions. Smash finished runner-up when resuming last time, beaten just a length. Only Getn Better drops in class and has placed six times at Mahoning Valley showing excellent consistency at this venue. Master Of The Nite has three previous victories here making the track specialist angle appealing. Poppys Pride stretches out in distance for first time which adds intrigue. The extended distance favors closers and horses with proven stamina.
Race 7 – Claiming, 1323Y (6f), Dirt, $15,372 Purse WIN + EXACTA ($11.40)
Win: 4-Reasons We Drink (88% confidence)🥇
Place: 5-Watch Me Daddy (62% confidence)🥈
Show: 6-Mandated Event (50% confidence)
Alternative: 7-Devoutly (38% confidence)🥉
Overwhelming consensus support for Reasons We Drink returning from seven-week layoff. Handicappers describe this as a one-horse race with the favorite rated far ahead of the competition. Watch Me Daddy finished second last time at this track and drops back in distance. Mandated Event has won at Thistledown and placed once this campaign. Devoutly breaks maiden last time and tries winners for first time. Strong favorite scenario limits exotic value but presents potential single opportunity in multi-race wagers.
Race 8 – Starter Allowance, 1323Y (6f), Dirt, $19,000 Purse WIN + EXACTA ($16.40)
Win: 7-Absolute Miracle (100% confidence)🥇
Place: 4-Fast N Happy (62% confidence)🥈
Show: 5-Big Ginger (50% confidence)
Alternative: 8-Mali Bali (38% confidence)
Absolute Miracle receives unanimous top-three support from all handicappers making this the strongest consensus of the card. Finished close second in stronger company last time and drops into more suitable conditions. Fast N Happy won impressively most recent start and has four wins from this campaign. Big Ginger returns from seven-week break after winning at Thistledown. Mali Bali won last time at Mahoning Valley and has won twice when favored. Top three selections look solid for trifecta purposes.
Recommended Exotic Wagers and Value Plays
Early Pick 4 (Races 1-4)
The Pick Pony analysis suggests focusing on the strong consensus horses while creating depth in Race 3 where opinion is divided. Consider building tickets around Vitaemi or Miss Shady in Race 1, keying City Scene in Race 2, using Action Man and Citizen in Race 3, and spreading to Win Herbie Win, Bold Buckeye, and Excitement in Race 4.
Suggested ticket structure: Race 1 (2 horses) x Race 2 (1 horse) x Race 3 (3 horses) x Race 4 (3 horses) = 18 combinations
Late Pick 4 (Races 5-8)
This sequence includes two races with 100% and 88% consensus picks (Races 7 and 8), making it an attractive proposition for multi-race exotic wagers. Spread in the more competitive Races 5 and 6 while keying the standouts in Races 7 and 8.
Suggested ticket: Race 5 (4 horses) x Race 6 (4 horses) x Race 7 (1 horse) x Race 8 (2 horses) = 32 combinations
Daily Double Opportunities
Race 1-2: Key Vitaemi with City Scene for small investment with solid return potential
Race 7-8: Reasons We Drink with Absolute Miracle creates strong two-horse parlay with both receiving overwhelming support
Trifecta Value Plays
Race 3: Most competitive race on card with tight consensus. Box Action Man, Citizen, Tetched, and Third City for solid coverage at reasonable cost
Race 5: Wide-open claiming race perfect for trifecta box with Style In Time, Marmara, Miss Foxann, and Crackle
Race 6: Unusual equal support for Smash and Only Getn Better creates interesting trifecta opportunities. Box these two with Master Of The Nite and Poppys Pride
Exacta Box Recommendations
Race 2: City Scene with Minestress represents strong value given 100% consensus on winner
Race 4: Win Herbie Win with Bold Buckeye offers solid return potential
Race 8: Absolute Miracle with Fast N Happy creates reliable exacta based on unanimous support
Superfecta Longshot Special
Race 5 presents the best superfecta opportunity given the competitive nature and multiple legitimate contenders. Consider boxing Style In Time, Marmara, Miss Foxann, Crackle, Geegees Story, and Loop Of Henle for larger payoff potential
Rolling Exotic Strategy
The Buckeye Pick 6 covering Races 3-8 offers significant value. Key the strong consensus selections in Races 4, 7, and 8 while spreading in the more competitive races. Total investment of 72 combinations provides excellent coverage while managing risk.
