Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Presque Isle Downs, October 13, 2025.

Race #1 Expert Picks

Twinspires:

  • Win: (5) Valiant Victoria
  • Place: (2) Runaway Breeze
  • Show: (4) Echo Seven

Fanduel:

  • Win: (5) Valiant Victoria
  • Place: (2) Runaway Breeze
  • Show: (4) Echo Seven

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: (5) Valiant Victoria

Tip Meerkat:

  • Win: (4) Echo Seven
  • Place: (5) Valiant Victoria
  • Show: (3) Wild Looker

Racenet:

  • Win: (5) Valiant Victoria
  • Place: (4) Echo Seven
  • Show: (2) Runaway Breeze
  • Fourth: (1) Team Feisty

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: (5) Valiant Victoria

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: (2) Runaway Breeze
  • Place: (4) Echo Seven
  • Show: (5) Valiant Victoria

At The Races:

  • Win: (5) Valiant Victoria
  • Place: (4) Echo Seven

Race #2 Expert Picks

Twinspires:

  • Win: (4) Starship Legacy
  • Place: (6) Pivot To The Power
  • Show: (1) Dowhateverittakes

Fanduel:

  • Win: (1) Dowhateverittakes / (4) Starship Legacy (tie)
  • Place: (3) English Indy

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: (5) Rainbow Rania

Tip Meerkat:

  • Win: (5) Rainbow Rania
  • Place: (6) Pivot To The Power
  • Show: (1) Dowhateverittakes

Racenet:

  • Win: (1) Dowhateverittakes
  • Place: (6) Pivot To The Power
  • Show: (4) Starship Legacy
  • Fourth: (5) Rainbow Rania

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: (1) Dowhateverittakes

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: (2) Thy Name Is Woman
  • Place: (5) Rainbow Rania
  • Show: (3) English Indy

At The Races:

  • Win: (5) Rainbow Rania
  • Place: (1) Dowhateverittakes

Race #3 Expert Picks

Twinspires:

  • Win: (3) Malibu Muse
  • Place: (1) Maclean’s Lullaby
  • Show: (4) Forbidden Friend

Fanduel:

  • Win: (4) Forbidden Friend
  • Place: (1) Maclean’s Lullaby
  • Show: (2) Got A Complex

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: (3) Malibu Muse

Tip Meerkat:

  • Win: (4) Forbidden Friend
  • Place: (3) Malibu Muse
  • Show: (6) Tworly Bluebell

Racenet:

  • Win: (3) Malibu Muse
  • Place: (5) Joyous Song
  • Show: (2) Got A Complex
  • Fourth: (1) Maclean’s Lullaby

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: (3) Malibu Muse

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: (5) Joyous Song
  • Place: (4) Forbidden Friend
  • Show: (3) Malibu Muse

At The Races:

  • Win: (3) Malibu Muse
  • Place: (4) Forbidden Friend

Race #4 Expert Picks

Twinspires:

  • Win: (5) Thalberg
  • Place: (2) Kotylos
  • Show: (7) Pearl Of Aclaim

Fanduel:

  • Win: (5) Thalberg
  • Place: (7) Pearl Of Aclaim
  • Show: (3) Where You Was

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: (5) Thalberg

Tip Meerkat:

  • Win: (5) Thalberg
  • Place: (4) Colonel Poppy
  • Show: (3) Where You Was

Racenet:

  • Win: (5) Thalberg
  • Place: (7) Pearl Of Aclaim
  • Show: (3) Where You Was
  • Fourth: (4) Colonel Poppy

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: (7) Pearl Of Aclaim

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: (4) Colonel Poppy
  • Place: (6) Calypso Charlie
  • Show: (5) Thalberg

At The Races:

  • Win: (5) Thalberg
  • Place: (3) Where You Was

Race #5 Expert Picks

Twinspires:

  • Win: (9) Honor Bright
  • Place: (5) Midwest Princess
  • Show: (1) Colonial Sense

Fanduel:

  • Win: (9) Honor Bright
  • Place: (7) I Choose Joy / (10) Inspire Courage (tie)

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: (9) Honor Bright

Tip Meerkat:

  • Win: (9) Honor Bright
  • Place: (4) Limited Vintage
  • Show: (10) Inspire Courage

Racenet:

  • Win: (6) Jen D’oro
  • Place: (4) Limited Vintage
  • Show: (5) Midwest Princess
  • Fourth: (1) Colonial Sense

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: (5) Midwest Princess

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: (5) Midwest Princess
  • Place: (2) Baby Me Good
  • Show: (4) Limited Vintage

At The Races:

  • Win: (9) Honor Bright
  • Place: (4) Limited Vintage

Race #6 Expert Picks

Twinspires:

  • Win: (4) Expresso Bay
  • Place: (5) Leftnateawalkin
  • Show: (6) Jes See Me

Fanduel:

  • Win: (2) Mo Dodgy / (7) Wildncrazyguy (tie)
  • Place: (6) Jes See Me

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: (4) Expresso Bay

Tip Meerkat:

  • Win: (7) Wildncrazyguy
  • Place: (4) Expresso Bay
  • Show: (2) Mo Dodgy

Racenet:

  • Win: (5) Leftnateawalkin
  • Place: (4) Expresso Bay
  • Show: (6) Jes See Me
  • Fourth: (1) Wedge

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: (5) Leftnateawalkin

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: (8) Mr Randy
  • Place: (2) Mo Dodgy
  • Show: (5) Leftnateawalkin

At The Races:

  • Win: (2) Mo Dodgy
  • Place: (5) Leftnateawalkin

Race #7 Expert Picks

Twinspires:

  • Win: (2) Toddchero
  • Place: (7) You Bet A Fortune
  • Show: (4) Saint Goar

Fanduel:

  • Win: (4) Saint Goar / (7) You Bet A Fortune (tie)
  • Place: (2) Toddchero

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: (2) Toddchero

Tip Meerkat:

  • Win: (7) You Bet A Fortune
  • Place: (4) Saint Goar
  • Show: (2) Toddchero

Racenet:

  • Win: (2) Toddchero
  • Place: (4) Saint Goar
  • Show: (3) Call Me Later
  • Fourth: (6) Drunk On Sake

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: (7) You Bet A Fortune

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: (3) Call Me Later
  • Place: (7) You Bet A Fortune
  • Show: (4) Saint Goar

At The Races:

  • Win: (7) You Bet A Fortune
  • Place: (2) Toddchero

Race #8 Expert Picks

Twinspires:

  • Win: (5) Fadethenoise
  • Place: (6) Shy Da Runner
  • Show: (8) Ransom Money

Fanduel:

  • Win: (5) Fadethenoise / (6) Shy Da Runner (tie)
  • Place: (4) We Called Sol

Racing Dudes:

  • Win: (5) Fadethenoise

Tip Meerkat:

  • Win: (8) Ransom Money
  • Place: (5) Fadethenoise
  • Show: (7) Face Down

Racenet:

  • Win: (5) Fadethenoise
  • Place: (6) Shy Da Runner
  • Show: (3) Leonard’s Legacy
  • Fourth: (8) Ransom Money

Guaranteed Tip Sheet:

  • Win: (5) Fadethenoise

Hitch Abernathy:

  • Win: (5) Fadethenoise
  • Place: (6) Shy Da Runner
  • Show: (3) Leonard’s Legacy

At The Races:

  • Win: (5) Fadethenoise
  • Place: (6) Shy Da Runner

Consensus Calculations

Race #1 Consensus

  • Win: (5) Valiant Victoria – 75% confidence
  • Place: (4) Echo Seven – 63% confidence
  • Show: (2) Runaway Breeze – 75% confidence

Race #2 Consensus

  • Win: (1) Dowhateverittakes – 50% confidence
  • Place: (6) Pivot To The Power – 50% confidence
  • Show: (5) Rainbow Rania – 63% confidence

Race #3 Consensus

  • Win: (3) Malibu Muse – 63% confidence
  • Place: (4) Forbidden Friend – 50% confidence
  • Show: (1) Maclean’s Lullaby – 38% confidence

Race #4 Consensus

  • Win: (5) Thalberg – 75% confidence
  • Place: (7) Pearl Of Aclaim – 50% confidence
  • Show: (3) Where You Was – 63% confidence

Race #5 Consensus

  • Win: (9) Honor Bright – 63% confidence
  • Place: (5) Midwest Princess – 38% confidence
  • Show: (4) Limited Vintage – 50% confidence

Race #6 Consensus

  • Win: (4) Expresso Bay – 38% confidence
  • Place: (5) Leftnateawalkin – 50% confidence
  • Show: (6) Jes See Me – 50% confidence

Race #7 Consensus

  • Win: (7) You Bet A Fortune / (2) Toddchero – 50% confidence (tie)
  • Place: (4) Saint Goar – 50% confidence
  • Show: (2) Toddchero – 38% confidence

Race #8 Consensus

  • Win: (5) Fadethenoise – 75% confidence
  • Place: (6) Shy Da Runner – 63% confidence
  • Show: (3) Leonard’s Legacy – 38% confidence

The analysis includes picks from eight major handicapping sources, with consensus calculations showing the most popular selections across all experts. All horse names have been verified against the official race entries to ensure accuracy in the analysis.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback