Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Tampa Bay Downs, December 26, 2025. 67% WIN RATE + 1 EXACTA


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Race 1 – Allowance Optional Claiming, 6f 110yds, 11:35am, $56,500 WIN

Win: CHROME GHOST (2) – 57%🥇
Place: FREEDOM ROAD (4) – 43%
Show: LIFE IS PRECIOUS (6) – 43%🥉
Alternative: KHOZEIRESS (1) – 29%

CHROME GHOST (2) emerges as the clear consensus choice after winning last start at Gulfstream in the same class level. The gelding shows consistent form and benefits from strong tactical speed. FREEDOM ROAD (4) returns after a five-week layoff with excellent Tampa Bay form, having won three times at the track. The class relief after competing in higher-grade company recently positions this runner as a legitimate threat. LIFE IS PRECIOUS (6) ran within three-quarters of a length of the winner last time at this track and distance, suggesting fitness improvement with each start. Track familiarity and recent form make this filly a logical show contender.

Race 2 – Claiming, 1m 39yds, 12:05pm, $18,500 WIN + EXACTA

Win: PLAY FREE BIRD (7) – 71%🥇
Place: VIKING QUEEN (1) – 57%🥈
Show: RED ELEANOR (4) – 43%
Alternative: BRAMBLE BUSH (3) – 29%🥉

PLAY FREE BIRD (7) represents the strongest consensus across nearly all analysts, suggesting sharp recent form patterns analysts recognize. The mare comes from Steve Klesaris' barn with proven ability at this level. VIKING QUEEN (1) finished just a neck behind the winner last start at this track and distance, demonstrating readiness to win. The short turnaround favors horses in peak condition. RED ELEANOR (4) brings strong current form with two wins from 11 starts this campaign and benefits from the Aldana Spieth training operation, known for placing horses strategically.

Race 3 – Maiden Claiming, 1m 39yds, 12:35pm, $18,500 WIN

Win: GAP TO GAP (8) – 60%🥇
Place: CAREER RISK (2) – 50%
Show: MATTY B GOOD (1) – 33%
Alternative: TIZTIMONIAL (6) – 33%🥈

GAP TO GAP (8) has knocked on the door repeatedly with six placings from seven Tampa Bay starts and shows two placings from four runs this preparation. Consistent runners breaking through at this claiming level often dominate. CAREER RISK (2) drops significantly in class after competing at Aqueduct and comes from Kevin Rice's barn with tactical speed that suits the distance. The class relief provides significant advantage. MATTY B GOOD (1) draws the rail and represents a solid barn, though the distance stretch from turf routes to dirt may present questions.

Race 4 – Starter Allowance, 6f (1320Y), 1:04pm, $31,000 WIN

Win: SILVER SLUGGER (5) – 67%🥇
Place: EL PRINCIPITO (4) – 50%🥉
Show: JOHN DUTTON (8) – 50%
Alternative: ROME'S CONQUEST (2) – 33%🥈

SILVER SLUGGER (5) stands as the overwhelming consensus with a current three-race winning streak at Tampa Bay and seven career victories at this track. Track specialists with winning momentum at this distance rarely fail. EL PRINCIPITO (4) won impressively last start at this exact track and distance when fresh, suggesting the Gerald S. Bennett trainee is primed for another strong effort. JOHN DUTTON (8) returns from a nine-week break after winning at Presque Isle Downs, bringing fresh legs and proven class to challenge.

Race 5 – Maiden Claiming, 1M Turf, 1:33pm, $18,500

Win: HE'S MY UNCLE (4) – 60%🥉
Place: CAPE STORM (5) – 40%
Show: SILENT TONE (7) – 40%
Alternative: LANDING FORCE (9) – 40%🥈

HE'S MY UNCLE (4) has competed in higher company and now drops to maiden claiming level, suggesting class advantage. Gerald S. Bennett's operation excels with these tactical drops. CAPE STORM (5) returns after a layoff and placed when fresh previously, indicating the gelding runs well with freshness. SILENT TONE (7) finished midfield in his only Tampa Bay start but represents Chad J. Stewart's barn, which shows improved form patterns with turf runners. The open nature of this maiden race on grass creates opportunity for multiple contenders.

Race 6 – Claiming, 6f (1320Y), 2:03pm, $19,000

Win: COERCIVE (5) – 60%🥉
Place: STAR OF ABRAHAM (10) – 50%
Show: WAJDA (14) – 40%
Alternative: PROFITABILITY (1) – 33%

COERCIVE (5) represents Joseph F. Orseno's barn and finished in the middle of the pack last start, suggesting room for improvement with better positioning. The gelding's tactical speed suits the sprint distance. STAR OF ABRAHAM (10) broke his maiden last start at this track when returning from a layoff, indicating peak fitness. First-time winners often follow through. WAJDA (14) drops in class after finishing fifth in higher company, positioning for a bounce-back effort with the class relief providing significant edge.

Race 7 – Allowance, 1M Turf, 2:33pm WIN

Win: RISK TOLERANCE (5) – 83%🥇
Place: CHICAGO THEATRE (2) – 50%🥉
Show: NOBLE FACTOR (9) – 33%
Alternative: THUNDERING (10) – 33%🥈

RISK TOLERANCE (5) represents Chad C. Brown's powerhouse barn and narrowly missed when heavily backed last start at Belmont. Brown's turf routers returning after brief layoffs show exceptional win rates. CHICAGO THEATRE (2) returns off a Tampa Bay victory when fresh and possesses outstanding form at this track, making the Thomas F. Proctor trainee a consistent threat. NOBLE FACTOR (9) won last start at this track when fresh and demonstrates very strong form at this venue, suggesting track bias favors this runner's style.

Race 8 – Starter Optional Claiming, 6f (1320Y), 3:03pm

Win: FIELDS OF GREEN (11) – 40%
Place: LONG GONE SALLY (9) – 40%🥇
Show: HOT DANCE (7) – 25%🥉
Alternative: D' TIGER LILY (8) – 25%

FIELDS OF GREEN (11) won last start at Tampa Bay and represents a strong barn with momentum. The filly's recent form trajectory suggests continued improvement. LONG GONE SALLY (9) brings a two-race winning streak at Tampa Bay and has won all previous races as favorite, demonstrating consistency and reliability. HOT DANCE (7) finished second at this track when returning from a layoff, indicating fitness levels support another strong effort. This competitive race features multiple live contenders with recent winning form.

Race 9 – Claiming, 1 1/16M Turf, 3:40pm, $22,800 WIN

Win: TRUE MYTH (4) – 67%🥇
Place: CLASSICALS FINALE (8) – 40%
Show: CLASSY LASS (11) – 33%🥈
Alternative: NELIDA (9) – 25%

TRUE MYTH (4) shows as a track specialist with two Tampa Bay victories and represents David Vanwinkle's barn. Turf routers with proven track form provide significant edge in claiming routes. CLASSICALS FINALE (8) finished third last start at this track over one mile on turf, suggesting the distance stretch suits. The Richard P. Sillaman trainee shows consistent form patterns. CLASSY LASS (11) finished fourth when returning from a layoff at this track, indicating fitness improvement. Marcus J. Vitali's operation excels with second-time-back runners on turf.


Recommended Exotic Plays by Race

Race 1

Exacta Box: 2-4 (CHROME GHOST, FREEDOM ROAD) – Both horses show strong consensus support and complementary running styles. CHROME GHOST's recent class form pairs well with FREEDOM ROAD's track specialization.

Trifecta: 2,4/2,4,6/1,3,6 – Key the top two consensus choices over the field in third position, with value underlays KHOZEIRESS (1) and TAKESHI FRANK (3) as potential upset threats.

Race 2

Win Bet: 7-PLAY FREE BIRD – The 71% consensus support at 4-1 morning line odds represents exceptional value for a horse showing this level of analytical agreement.

Exacta: 7/1,4,3 – Key PLAY FREE BIRD over the logical place contenders, particularly VIKING QUEEN (1) and RED ELEANOR (4) who bring different running styles.

Race 3

Exacta: 8-GAP TO GAP with 2-CAREER RISK – The class drop for CAREER RISK combined with GAP TO GAP's consistency creates a logical pairing.

Race 4

Win Bet: 5-SILVER SLUGGER – The three-race winning streak at Tampa Bay with 67% consensus support makes this the strongest single-race play of the card.

Trifecta: 5/4,8/2,4,8 – Key SILVER SLUGGER on top with EL PRINCIPITO and JOHN DUTTON underneath, adding ROME'S CONQUEST as the value alternative.

Race 5

Exacta Box: 4-5-7 (HE'S MY UNCLE, CAPE STORM, SILENT TONE) – Open maiden races on turf require wider coverage. These three represent different analyst perspectives and running styles.

Race 6

Exacta: 5/10,14 – Key COERCIVE over STAR OF ABRAHAM and WAJDA, both showing strong recent form and class positioning.

Race 7

Win Bet: 5-RISK TOLERANCE – The 83% consensus from analysts represents the strongest agreement on the entire card. Chad Brown turf runners first off layoff provide exceptional value.

Exacta: 5/2,9,10 – Key the dominant choice over logical place threats with different tactical approaches.

Race 8

Trifecta Box: 7-9-11 (HOT DANCE, LONG GONE SALLY, FIELDS OF GREEN) – The competitive nature of this race requires broader coverage of the top consensus selections.

Race 9

Exacta: 4/8,11 – Key TRUE MYTH over CLASSICALS FINALE and CLASSY LASS, both showing consistent form at the track and distance.

Pick 3 (Races 7-8-9): 5/9,11/4,8 – Build around the strong consensus in Race 7 with logical progressions through the final two competitive races.


Value Play Observations

Race 1 – TAKESHI FRANK (3): Morning line 8-1 with only two analyst top picks suggests the public may overlook this Victor Carrasco trainee. The post position from the middle of the field provides tactical options.

Race 2 – PLAY FREE BIRD (7): The 71% consensus at 4-1 morning line represents the card's strongest value proposition. When seven different analytical approaches converge on the same conclusion, the odds should be significantly shorter.

Race 4 – SILVER SLUGGER (5): Despite three consecutive victories at the track, the 8-5 morning line provides playable value for bettors. Track specialists maintaining winning form typically close at shorter odds.

Race 5: The open nature of this maiden turf race creates value opportunities across the board. HE'S MY UNCLE (4) at 3-1 dropping in class provides the strongest value angle, while LANDING FORCE (9) at 9-2 represents analyst support without public recognition.

Race 6 – STAR OF ABRAHAM (10): The 8-1 morning line for a last-out maiden winner from Mario Roberto Lopez's barn provides value, particularly with 50% place consensus support.

Race 7 – RISK TOLERANCE (5): The 6-5 morning line for an 83% consensus choice from Chad Brown's barn represents fair value given the trainer's success rate with turf routers off layoffs.

Race 8: The wide-open nature creates multiple value angles. FIELDS OF GREEN (11) at 7-2 with two analyst top picks provides the strongest value, while D' TIGER LILY (8) at 12-1 represents a potential upset with limited public support.

Race 9 – TRUE MYTH (4): The 7-2 morning line for a 67% consensus choice with proven track form represents excellent value. Track specialists in claiming turf routes provide consistent returns when properly identified.

Multi-Race Value: The Pick 3 covering Races 7-8-9 provides exceptional value by keying RISK TOLERANCE (5) in Race 7, then spreading through the competitive final two races. The probable payout far exceeds the individual probabilities due to RISK TOLERANCE's dominant consensus support.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback