Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Tampa Bay Downs, December 5, 2025.


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Race #1 Claiming – 1 Mile 40 Yards, Dirt – 11:30 AM WIN + BOXED TRIFECTA

Win: #6 If I Were You – 75% confidence🥇

Place: #1 Theos Thunder – 38% confidence🥉

Show: #5 Fore Flag – 38% confidence🥈

Alternative: #3 Strengthnguidance – 25% confidence

If I Were You commands strong consensus support with 75% confidence. However, significant divergence exists in secondary positions. Theos Thunder and Fore Flag each carry 38% confidence for place and show. This lack of consensus in supporting roles suggests potential for upsets or alternative exotic strategies.

Pick Pony analysts recommend Pick 3-4 with Jokes Up (Race 6) using the strong If I Were You single. Exacta box (6-1-5) offers middle value given the competing picks between Betting News and At The Races analysis.


Race #2 Claiming – 1323 Yards, Dirt – 12:00 PM

Win: #1 Answer The Call – 43% confidence

Place: #6 Heavenly Dancer – 29% confidence

Show: #2 Wildcat Minny – 29% confidence🥉

Alternative: #5 Deetz – 14% confidence

Unlike Race 1, consensus weakens significantly with Answer The Call at only 43% confidence for the win. Heavenly Dancer and Wildcat Minny split place and show votes with 29% each, suggesting a competitive, less predictable contest. Multiple analysts back different top contenders.

Pick Pony analysts suggest trifecta using Answer The Call over the place/show combinations (1-6-2, 1-6-7) provides value given the wider splits. Consider single ticket with Betsylicious as an overlay play appearing in multiple second positions.


Race #3 Claiming – 1323 Yards, Dirt – 12:29 PM

Win: #8 Go Yoshida – 50% confidence🥉

Place: #4 Divo Doro – 83% confidence

Show: #2 Hasten – 50% confidence

Alternative: #1 Son Of A Slew – 17% confidence

Divo D'Oro demonstrates exceptional strength for place position with 83% confidence—an unusually high consensus for secondary position. Go Yoshida (50% win) and Hasten (50% show) maintain broader consensus, but Divo D'Oro's place dominance signals potential exacta opportunities.

Pick Pony analysts recommend Go Yoshida-Divo D'Oro exacta carries strong value given the 50-83 confidence split. Using Divo D'Oro as banker in place position over varying win candidates maximizes the consensus advantage.


Race #4 Claiming – 1 Mile 40 Yards, Dirt – 12:59 PM

Win: #2 Passioned – 100% confidence

Place: #7 Anchises – 57% confidence🥇

Show: #9 Mission Mike – 57% confidence🥈

Alternative: #8 Street Glide – 14% confidence

Passioned achieves rare unanimous support with 100% confidence across all seven experts for the win. This perfect consensus is exceptional. Anchises (57%) and Mission Mike (57%) provide balanced competing claims for place and show, though both command less certainty than the betting favorite.

Pick Pony analysts recommend Passioned single in win position of Pick 4 is highly justified. Exactas with 2-7-9 or 2-9-7 leverage the consensus win while maintaining flexibility in supporting roles.


Race #5 Claiming – 1 Mile 110 Yards, Turf – 1:29 PM WIN

Win: #2 Stillthinkingofyou – 71% confidence🥇

Place: #1 Whirlwind – 43% confidence

Show: #4 Nicky Jolene – 43% confidence🥉

Alternative: #7 Summer Flower – 14% confidence🥈

Stillthinkingofyou establishes 71% confidence for win, a strong if not dominant position. Whirlwind and Nicky Jolene equally split place and show votes at 43% each. The turf course surface requires careful attention to form adjustments. Analysts appear divided between speed-favoring and late-closing styles.

Pick Pony analysts suggest place/show double on Whirlwind and Nicky Jolene across multiple combinations leverages their 43% consensus. Key Race Bet utilizing Stillthinkingofyou as banker with varying second and third positions.


Race #6 Claiming – 1214 Yards, Dirt – 1:59 PM WIN

Win: #9 Jokes Up – 57% confidence🥇

Place: #3 Wild Delight – 29% confidence

Show: #2 Next Episode – 57% confidence

Alternative: #10 Captured Darling – 14% confidence

Jokes Up (57% win) and Next Episode (57% show) command equal consensus confidence—unusual symmetry. Wild Delight carries only 29% for place despite appearing in multiple experts' top three. This structural imbalance suggests potential misalignment between public perception and expert consensus.

Pick Pony analysts recommend using Jokes Up as single in win position with multiple place/show combinations captures value. Exacta 9-2 (Jokes Up-Next Episode) or reverse box benefits from the parallel 57% confidence levels.


Race #7 Claiming – 1 Mile 110 Yards, Turf – 2:29 PM

Win: #1 Mrs. Katz – 71% confidence🥉

Place: #7 Classy Disposition – 43% confidence

Show: #5 Ariana Valentina – 43% confidence

Alternative: #6 Alcohol – 14% confidence🥈

Mrs. Katz achieves 71% win consensus on turf—strong support for the favorite. Classy Disposition and Ariana Valentina maintain balanced 43% confidence for place and show. Multiple analysts recognize this race's competitive nature despite clear Mrs. Katz preference.

Pick Pony analysts recommend Mrs. Katz single as banker in win position of exotic wagers. Trifecta box (1-7-5) offers middle-range ticket cost with three-way place/show flexibility for the secondary positions.


Race #8 Claiming – 1542 Yards, Dirt – 2:59 PM

Win: #6 Shabam – 29% confidence

Place: #5 Good Bright Flames – 29% confidence

Show: #2 Efficacious – 43% confidence🥉

Alternative: #9 E Ms Treasuregirl – 14% confidence

This race shows the weakest consensus pattern encountered. Shabam (29%) and Efficacious (43%) command modest confidence levels, suggesting genuine uncertainty. At The Races identifies Foxy Lady as win pick while consensus leans toward Shabam. The dispersed picks indicate value opportunities but higher volatility.

Pick Pony analysts recommend superfecta or exacta with multiple horse combinations given the weak consensus. Efficacious carrying 43% confidence for show may offer place-show combinations better than win probability.


Race #9 Allowance Optional Claiming – 1 Mile 110 Yards, Turf – 3:29 PM

Win: #4 Eldest Son – 57% confidence🥉

Place: #2 Tok Tok – 57% confidence

Show: #1 X Y Prime – 43% confidence

Alternative: #9 Royal Majesty – 14% confidence🥈

Eldest Son and Tok Tok both achieve 57% confidence in their respective positions (win and place), indicating balanced expert approval. X Y Prime (43% show) provides the secondary finishing line. The allowance optional claiming class adds complexity but consensus remains relatively clear compared to Race 8.

Pick Pony analysts recommend exacta 4-2 leverages the parallel 57% confidence levels. Using Tok Tok as banker in place position with varying win-show combinations provides value given the secondary confidence levels.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback