Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!
Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.
RACE 1 CLAIMING 1M 39Y DIRT PURSE $13,230
Win: LUCKY CURLIN (5) – 71% confidence
Place: SUPREME SONG (1) – 43% confidence
Show: FUNKENSTEIN (4) – 29% confidence
Alternative: WHITING FIELD (3) – 29% confidence
The analyst community is overwhelmingly aligned on the top selection, citing strong recent form and success over the Tampa surface. While some variance exists in the underneath positions due to a secondary favorite, the majority of professionals view the top pick as the primary win candidate.
RACE 2 CLAIMING 6F DIRT PURSE $14,490
Win: ALLONS (6) – 57% confidence
Place: THEE NEW BEGINNING (5) – 29% confidence
Show: MT. D’ORO (4) – 29% confidence
Alternative: BAYOU MELODY (1) – 29% confidence
Opinions are moderately split between the top speed figures of a recent shipper and local horses with established consistency. The analyst consensus suggests the shipper holds the edge if they can replicate recent performances on the local dirt track.
RACE 3 STARTER OPTIONAL CLAIMING 5.5F DIRT PURSE $17,640
Win: SECRET EMPIRE (4) – 71% confidence
Place: PROTEGE (5) – 43% confidence
Show: GUAPO AGAIN (7) – 43% confidence
Alternative: MORNING CUP (1) – 29% confidence
Strong consensus exists for the win position, with analysts highlighting a significant class advantage and high win percentage. The secondary tiers show more competition between horses coming off recent victories.
RACE 4 MAIDEN CLAIMING 1M TURF PURSE $14,490
Win: MAGNUS GOLD (8) – 43% confidence
Place: RONS LEGACY (3) – 29% confidence
Show: ASHRYVER (7) – 29% confidence
Alternative: LEONIDAS STAND (1) – 29% confidence
This race presents as a wide-open maiden event. Analysts are scattered across several first-time starters and horses with limited experience, resulting in lower confidence scores across the board.
RACE 5 CLAIMING 6.5F DIRT PURSE $16,695
Win: TIMELY REWARD (5) – 71% confidence
Place: JUST LIKE YOU (7) – 43% confidence
Show: EROS’S GIRL (1) – 29% confidence
Alternative: BRAMBLE BUSH (3) – 29% confidence
The field is dominated by a clear favorite in the eyes of the analysts. Strategic guidance suggests the top selection is the anchor for most multi-race sequences, despite some minor interest in a class dropper.
RACE 6 MAIDEN CLAIMING 1M TURF PURSE $17,955
Win: BEAUTIFUL EMMA (9) – 71% confidence
Place: OUR LADY DONNA D (2) – 57% confidence
Show: GETAHOLDAYOURSELF (3) – 29% confidence
Alternative: KISS ME FOR LUCK (10) – 29% confidence
There is a very clear top-two tier identified by analysts. The consensus suggests the race will likely be decided between the two highest-rated fillies, with significant separation between them and the rest of the field.
RACE 7 CLAIMING 6F DIRT PURSE $20,475
Win: MISTY MONEY (5) – 57% confidence
Place: PRANCIN INTHE DARK (1) – 43% confidence
Show: FLY LIFE (8) – 43% confidence
Alternative: CHAPITA (7) – 29% confidence
Analytical tension is present here as experts weigh recent win consistency against class drops. The consensus narrowly favors the horse with the most reliable local form over the last two starts.
RACE 8 CLAIMING 1 1/8M TURF PURSE $15,309
Win: PERKY (3) – 86% confidence
Place: SUMMER FLOWER (1) – 43% confidence
Show: SEA SHANTY (5) – 43% confidence
Alternative: MORGS WORLD (11) – 29% confidence
This represents the highest confidence level on the entire card. Analysts are nearly unanimous in selecting the favorite to win, viewing this as the most predictable outcome of the day.
RECOMMENDED EXOTIC PLAYS BY RACE
Race 1: Analysts recommend a straight Exacta using LUCKY CURLIN (5) over SUPREME SONG (1). For more coverage, a Trifecta keying the (5) over (1, 3, 4) is suggested.
Race 2: Professionals suggest an Exacta Box featuring ALLONS (6), THEE NEW BEGINNING (5), and BAYOU MELODY (1). The variance in speed figures makes a box play safer here.
Race 3: Analysts lean toward a Trifecta with SECRET EMPIRE (4) in the top spot, keyed over PROTEGE (5) and GUAPO AGAIN (7).
Race 4: Given the analytical uncertainty, professionals advise a Superfecta Box with (8, 3, 7, 1) to account for potential upsets in an unpredictable maiden field.
Race 5: A clear preference is shown for an Exacta with TIMELY REWARD (5) on top of JUST LIKE YOU (7) and EROS’S GIRL (1).
Race 6: Analysts recommend an Exacta Box (2, 9) or a Trifecta Part-Wheel using (9) and (2) in the first and second slots.
Race 7: Professionals suggest a Daily Double connecting MISTY MONEY (5) and PRANCIN INTHE DARK (1) to the high-confidence favorite in Race 8.
Race 8: Analysts strongly recommend using PERKY (3) as a cold win bet or as a banker in all exotic structures, including Trifecta and Superfecta wheels.
VALUE PLAY OBSERVATIONS
In Race 4, MAGNUS GOLD (8) appears to be an overlay if the morning line remains near 20-1, as several analysts have moved it to the top of their selections despite the long odds. Conversely, LEONIDAS STAND (1) is viewed by some as an underlaid favorite in a race with so many unproven factors.
Race 7 features PRANCIN INTHE DARK (1) as a potential value play. While MISTY MONEY (5) commands the consensus, the morning line for the (1) offers better relative value compared to its frequency of selection among professional handicappers.
In Race 2, BAYOU MELODY (1) is getting enough analyst attention to warrant consideration as a value alternative to the favorite ALLONS (6), especially if the latter sees heavy betting action that depresses the odds too far.
OVERALL WAGERING STRATEGY
The racing card at Tampa Bay Downs for February 12 presents several high-conviction opportunities balanced by a few volatile maiden contests. Analysts have identified three specific races where consensus exceeds the 70 percent threshold, providing a solid foundation for structured wagering. The clearest path to success appears to be centered on a few dominant favorites who possess significant class advantages over their respective fields.
Strongest Consensus Races: Analysts are most aligned on Race 8, Race 1, Race 3, and Race 5. In Race 8, the consensus on PERKY (3) is nearly universal, making it the primary anchor for the day. Similarly, LUCKY CURLIN (5) in Race 1 and SECRET EMPIRE (4) in Race 3 command high confidence due to their superior local records and recent speed figures. TIMELY REWARD (5) in Race 5 also stands out as a dominant selection, benefiting from a favorable post position and a lack of depth in the opposing field.
Split-Opinion Races: Race 4 and Race 7 represent the areas of highest analytical tension. In Race 4, no single horse holds more than a 43 percent confidence rating, reflecting the inherent unpredictability of maiden claiming events on turf. In Race 7, opinions are divided between the consistent form of the local favorites and the class potential of those dropping from higher levels. These races are best approached with broader exotic coverage rather than heavy win bets on single individuals.
Multi-Race Sequences: The late Pick 3 and Pick 4 sequences are particularly attractive due to the presence of high-confidence anchors in the final races. Analysts suggest that a sequence ending with BEAUTIFUL EMMA (9) in Race 6 and PERKY (3) in Race 8 allows bettors to take more “spread” positions in the more competitive Race 7. This structure minimizes risk by relying on dominant favorites to close out the sequence while providing coverage for potential upsets in the middle legs.
Exotic Value Opportunities: The maiden turf races (Race 4 and Race 6) offer the best pricing inefficiency. Because form is less established, bettors can often find value by wheeling consistent “Show” candidates underneath the primary consensus picks. Superfecta wheels in Race 4, in particular, may yield high payouts if one of the longer-priced analyst picks like MAGNUS GOLD (8) manages to hit the board alongside more heavily bet contenders.
Environmental/Track Factors: The dirt surface at Tampa Bay Downs has recently favored horses with tactical speed who can stay clear of the kickback. Analysts note that in the sprint races (Race 2, 3, and 7), drawing an inside or middle post has been advantageous. On the turf, a lack of significant moisture in the forecast suggests a firm surface, which typically rewards horses with a strong late turn of foot and efficient closing fractions.
Key Takeaways: Priority should be given to utilizing the primary anchors in Races 1, 3, 5, and 8 to leverage multi-race horizontal bets. Secondly, bettors should look to the maiden turf events for vertical exotic value where analyst opinions are most diverse. Finally, focusing on the high-confidence late-card favorites provides the most stable path for those looking to capitalize on the consensus landscape.
