Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!
Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced AI-Powered Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.
Race 1 Claiming 1320Y Dirt
Win: SEBASTIANTHE FIRST (5) – 100% confidence
Place: DEVELOP PRODUCT (3) – 50% confidence
Show: R N R AUDIBLE (1) – 33% confidence
Alternative: TROOPS (4) – 16% confidence
The opening race shows absolute alignment among every analyst for the top spot. While there is minor debate over the minor placings between the 3 and the 1, the consensus on the winner makes this a potential single for multi-race wagers. Analysts note that the 5 has already proven successful at this track earlier in the prep.
Race 2 Claiming 1540Y Dirt
Win: IF I CAN DREAM (5) – 83% confidence
Place: EL OREJON (7) – 67% confidence
Show: W W STAR (6) – 50% confidence
Alternative: DUCK DUCK GOOSE (3) – 16% confidence
Most analysts are looking for the 5 to build on a recent maiden victory. There is a strong secondary consensus for the 7 to fill the exacta spot. A single analyst has identified the 3 as a potential spoiler, but the majority feel the top two are likely to dominate the finish.
Race 3 Claiming 8F 110Y Dirt
Win: MY LUCKY ANGEL (1) – 50% confidence
Place: MONGOLIAN CHAMP (7) – 33% confidence
Show: TONY B (4) – 33% confidence
Alternative: TIZTIMONIAL (6) – 16% confidence
Opinion is somewhat fractured in the third. While the 1 holds the highest number of top-tier selections, analysts are also showing significant interest in the 7 and 4. The rail draw for the 1 is cited as a major tactical advantage by those supporting the favorite.
Race 4 Starter Optional Claiming 8F 110Y Dirt
Win: THE BEST DISTANCE (8) – 67% confidence
Place: EL CHISPAZO (3) – 33% confidence
Show: EMBRACE MY UNCLE (5) – 33% confidence
Alternative: UNNAMED HORSE (6) – 16% confidence
The 8 is the primary choice here following a dominant performance in its previous outing. Analysts generally view the 3 as the main threat, though one analyst has thrown a wildcard pick with the 5 for the top spot. The 8’s history of five wins at this track is a recurring theme in the notes.
Race 5 Starter Allowance 8F Turf
Win: RIGEL (1) – 67% confidence
Place: NOBLE FACTOR (6) – 33% confidence
Show: ELDEST SON (4) – 33% confidence
Alternative: DOUBLE NEAT (8) – 33% confidence
The 1 is the preferred selection for the majority of analysts, highlighted for its record as a favorite. However, there is no clear second choice, with votes split evenly between the 6, 4, and 8. Analysts suggest this turf route could be susceptible to a late-closing upset.
Race 6 Allowance Optional Claiming 8F 110Y Dirt
Win: TORTUGA ISLAND (5) – 83% confidence
Place: WITS AND WAGES (6) – 33% confidence
Show: MI AMORE (3) – 33% confidence
Alternative: MY LITTLE WILDCAT (7) – 16% confidence
The 5 is a very strong consensus pick following an impressive win at this distance. While the 6 and 3 have their supporters for the lower rungs of the exotic ladder, analysts are largely in agreement that the race runs through the 5.
Race 7 Maiden Claiming 8F Turf
Win: D’ARGENTO BOLT (5) – 67% confidence
Place: FORGET TOMORROW (2) – 33% confidence
Show: GO K J GO (3) – 16% confidence
Alternative: TOO MUCH FUN (4) – 16% confidence
Analysts are leaning heavily on the 5 after a narrow miss in its last start. The 2 and 3 are viewed as the most likely candidates to complete the exacta, though one analyst suggests the 4 could offer value at longer odds.
Race 8 Starter Optional Claiming 1540Y Dirt
Win: QUESTNBLED’CISIONS (5) – 50% confidence
Place: AUTHENTIC WAVE (7) – 50% confidence
Show: RIDGIE (1) – 33% confidence
Alternative: LA CHISMOSA (6) – 16% confidence
This is the most competitive race on the card according to the analysts, who are deadlocked between the 5 and the 7. Both horses have shown excellent form at this track. Analysts suggest using both in any horizontal wagers to avoid being knocked out by a split opinion.
Race 9 Claiming 8F 110Y Turf
Win: TOK TOK (8) – 67% confidence
Place: SOUPER ATTENTIVE (10) – 33% confidence
Show: PERSISTEN (6) – 33% confidence
Alternative: TRACKSTER (5) – 16% confidence
The finale features a strong preference for the 8, which is dropping in class. The 10 is the most common alternative for the place position. Analysts note that while the 5 has won here recently, the class relief for the 8 should be the deciding factor.
Recommended Exotic Plays by Race
Race 1: Analysts suggest a Straight Exacta using SEBASTIANTHE FIRST (5) over DEVELOP PRODUCT (3). For those looking for more coverage, a Trifecta Key with the 5 over 1, 3, and 4 is recommended.
Race 2: A Cold Exacta 5-7 is the primary recommendation. Analysts also suggest a Superfecta 5 / 7 / 3, 6 / 3, 4, 6 to capture the likely dominant performance of the top two.
Race 3: Given the split opinion, analysts recommend an Exacta Box 1-7-4. A Trifecta Wheel 1, 7 / 1, 4, 7 / 4, 6, 7 is also suggested to account for the tactical variability.
Race 4: An Exacta Key 8 over 3, 5, and 6 is the preferred structure. Analysts also suggest a Trifecta 8 / 3, 5 / 3, 4, 5, 6 to maximize value on the heavy favorite.
Race 5: Analysts favor a Trifecta Box 1-4-6. For a more aggressive play, a Daily Double starting in this race using 1 and 6, moving into the heavy favorite in Race 6, is recommended.
Race 6: A Straight Exacta 5-6 is the consensus play. Analysts also suggest a Superfecta 5 / 6 / 3 / 7 to play for a narrow, logical result.
Race 7: Analysts recommend an Exacta Box 2-3-5. A Trifecta Key 5 over 2, 3, and 4 is also a viable option given the 5’s strong recent form.
Race 8: Because analysts are tied on the win spot, an Exacta Box 5-7 is essential. Analysts also recommend a Trifecta 5, 7 / 1, 5, 7 / 1, 6 to cover the most likely outcomes.
Race 9: A Trifecta Key 8 over 6 and 10 is the standard play. Analysts suggest a late Pick 4 or Pick 5 ending here with the 8 as a potential anchor.
Value Play Observations
Race 2: DUCK DUCK GOOSE (3) is identified as a potential overlay. While analysts largely favor the 5 and 7, the 10-1 morning line on the 3 provides significant value if the favorites falter after their recent efforts.
Race 3: TONY B (4) is viewed as an under-the-radar value play at 5-2. Analysts note that while the 1 is the consensus win pick, the 4’s recent form makes its current price attractive relative to its actual win probability.
Race 5: NOBLE FACTOR (6) at 4-1 is considered an overlay by analysts who believe its class drop and track record justify a lower price. Compare this to ELDEST SON (4), who may be overvalued at 5-2 based on its recent win.
Race 7: TOO MUCH FUN (4) is a notable value play at 6-1. While analysts are focused on the 5 and 2, the 4 has shown flashes of talent that suggest it could outperform its current odds in this maiden field.
Race 9: TRACKSTER (5) at 10-1 is the standout value play in the finale. Despite being a recent winner at this track, analysts have largely looked elsewhere for the top spot, creating a pricing inefficiency for bettors.
Overall Wagering Strategy
The racing card at Tampa Bay Downs for February 20, 2026, presents a clear structure for bettors, defined by several high-confidence anchors and a few tactical puzzles. The strongest consensus races occur early and in the middle of the card, specifically Race 1 with SEBASTIANTHE FIRST (5), Race 2 with IF I CAN DREAM (5), and Race 6 with TORTUGA ISLAND (5). In these instances, analyst confidence exceeds 80 percent, suggesting these horses are suitable as singles in multi-race sequences like the Pick 3 or Pick 5. The dominance of the 5 in multiple races is a statistical anomaly that simplifies the construction of many tickets.
Split-opinion races are primarily found in the latter half of the program, most notably in Race 8. Analysts are evenly divided between QUESTNBLED’CISIONS (5) and AUTHENTIC WAVE (7), indicating a high degree of volatility. This analytical tension suggests that bettors should avoid narrowing their focus to a single horse in this leg and instead use both primary contenders to protect their horizontal wagers. Race 3 also shows a significant spread of opinion, making it a prime candidate for wider exacta or trifecta boxes to catch a less obvious winner.
Multi-race sequences look particularly lucrative starting in Race 1 or Race 5. A Pick 3 starting in Race 1 (5 / 5 / 1, 7) offers a high probability of success given the overwhelming consensus on the first two legs. Similarly, a late Pick 4 starting in Race 6 can be anchored by the 5 and ended with a strong preference for the 8 in the finale, allowing for more spread in the difficult Race 7 and Race 8. This strategy leverages the strongest analyst convictions to minimize the cost of covering more unpredictable fields.
Exotic value opportunities are most prevalent in the turf races, such as Race 5 and Race 9. Form unpredictability in these categories often leads to pricing inefficiencies where recent winners or class-droppers are ignored in favor of more established names. Analysts recommend using four-horse combinations or superfecta wheels in these races to capture potential upsets at a minimal cost. For instance, including TRACKSTER (5) in the finale’s exotics could significantly boost payouts if the heavy favorites fail to fire.
Environmental and track factors appear stable, with the dirt surface expected to favor horses with tactical speed and proven track records, like those identified in Race 1 and Race 4. The turf routes may favor those with inside draws, reinforcing the interest in RIGEL (1) in Race 5. Bettors should monitor early results for any developing bias, particularly if the rail remains the preferred path.
Key takeaways for the day include prioritizing the 5 in Races 1, 2, and 6 as the foundation of any wagering strategy. Additionally, bettors should focus on Race 8 as the primary point of diversification, ensuring coverage of both top analyst picks to avoid an early exit from multi-race pools. Finally, looking for value in the turf exotics by including overlays like TRACKSTER (5) could provide the necessary upside to make the day profitable.
