Get more in-depth analysis for all races and enjoy many other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Don’t forget Pick Pony’s Expert Picks, AI Picks, and Past Performance Sheets/Racing Forms!

The Pick Pony Handicapper’s Report is published daily and provides analysis of all races on the card. A Pick Pony analyst prepares the report, so selections may differ from the Pick Pony Expert Picks, which are based on the consensus of all Pick Pony analysts.

Horseshoe Indianapolis features a competitive nine-race card with a varied mix of claiming races, allowance conditions, and Indiana-bred restrictions, with total purses approaching $275,000. The track hosts both thoroughbred and quarter horse racing, offering numerous value opportunities across different disciplines and class levels.

Track Conditions and Weather

Current conditions feature fast dirt track surfaces and firm turf course conditions with the temporary rail set at zero feet. The weather forecast predicts partly cloudy skies with temperatures reaching 59°F and a low of 37°F, along with possible light showers that are unlikely to impact racing. Wind remains light from the southwest at 5-10 mph, having minimal effect on racing performance.

Race-by-Race Analysis

Race 1 – Claiming ($5,000) – 6 Furlongs Dirt – 2:10 PM

Key Contenders:
M B’s Munning draws significant expert support as the morning line favorite despite starting from post 2. This Adam Gerteisen trainee with Jane Elliott aboard offers solid value at projected 9-2 odds. The gelding fits well in this $5,000 claiming level and benefits from Elliott’s strong riding at the meet.​

Surfin Sam represents consistent pace presence from post 1 with Santo Sanjur riding for trainer Anna Navarrete. The four-year-old gelding should establish early position from the rail.​

Secondary Choices:
More Than Five brings tactical speed with Marcelino Pedroza Jr. aboard for trainer Genaro Garcia, who ranks among the track’s leading conditioners. High Probability offers potential value as a lightly raced three-year-old dropping in class.​

Pace Analysis: Expect moderate early fractions with Surfin Sam and More Than Five pressing the pace. The six-furlong distance favors horses with tactical speed and finishing kick.

Wagering Angles: The 2-6-5 exacta combination provides solid value, while the 2-6-5-1 superfecta offers enhanced payouts.

Selections: Win: M B’s Munning, Place: More Than Five, Show: Surfin Sam

Race 2 – Indiana-Bred Claiming ($15,000) – 6 Furlongs Dirt – 2:41 PM

Key Contenders:
Goingscents emerges as the standout choice with Mitchell Murrill aboard for Tim Eggleston. This three-year-old gelding projects as the 9-5 morning line favorite and benefits from the strong Eggleston-Murrill combination. Murrill ranks as one of Horseshoe Indianapolis’ leading riders in 2025.​

R Guy Max provides early pace pressure with Alberto Burgos riding for Tianna Richardville. The four-year-old gelding possesses tactical speed from the rail position.

Secondary Choices:
El Rocky offers value potential with Samuel Bermudez aboard for Joseph Davis. Ryan’s Wish brings closing punch with Fernando De La Cruz, the track’s 2025 leading jockey.​

Pace Analysis: Moderate pace scenario favors horses with tactical positioning. The restricted nature levels the competition.

Wagering Angles: The 2-1 exacta provides solid foundation betting, while the 2-1-4-6 superfecta expands profit potential.

Selections: Win: Goingscents, Place: R Guy Max, Show: Ryan’s Wish

Race 3 – Maiden Claiming ($40,000) – 1 Mile Turf – 3:12 PM

This competitive maiden claiming event for two-year-old fillies presents excellent wagering value with a full field of 15 runners competing for $39,440. The $40,000 claiming price attracts quality juveniles making their turf debuts, while several runners bring experience from previous starts.​

Key Contenders Analysis

But Seriously emerges as the 7/2 morning line favorite with Marcelino Pedroza Jr. aboard for trainer Victoria Oliver. This filly brings the most seasoned resume with four starts and consistent placings, earning $19,200 in previous efforts. Her last three races show steady improvement with a second-place finish at one mile on dirt at Horseshoe Indianapolis followed by another second at the same distance. The switch to turf presents the primary question, but her closing style should translate effectively to the grass surface.​

Golexgo commands attention as the 4/1 second choice with Javier Padron-Barcenas riding for Tommy Humphries. This filly has earned $22,170 from two starts with a third-place finish in her most recent effort at 1 1/16 miles on dirt at Keeneland. Her previous start produced a third-place finish over 1 1/16 miles at Churchill Downs, demonstrating ability at classic distances. The step up to turf racing represents her primary challenge, but the breeding should handle the surface change effectively.​

Stay Beautiful offers significant value at 9/2 odds with Joseph Ramos aboard for Hall of Fame trainer Steven Asmussen. This filly has earned $11,600 from four starts including two second-place finishes, indicating consistent competitiveness. Her recent form shows a second-place finish in a one-mile dirt race at Horseshoe Indianapolis followed by another runner-up effort at the same venue. Asmussen’s 103 starts at the meet with a 13% win rate and 33% in-the-money percentage provides significant trainer confidence. The powerful barn’s presence in maiden company typically signals serious intentions.​

Secondary Choices Analysis

Venus d’Oro presents excellent longshot value at 8/1 with Evin Roman riding for Brendan Walsh. This unraced filly makes her career debut for a trainer with exceptional statistics: 103 starts, 16% win rate, and 39% in-the-money percentage. Walsh’s success with first-time starters and juvenile fillies makes this debut effort particularly intriguing. The 8/1 odds appear generous considering the trainer’s capabilities and the quality breeding typically associated with the Walsh barn.​

Grab My Tab brings experience with Fernando De La Cruz aboard for Richard Estvanko. This filly has earned $56,700 from six starts with one third-place finish, representing the highest career earnings in the field. Her recent form shows modest efforts, but the class drop to $40,000 claiming and surface switch to turf could unlock improvement. De La Cruz’s leading rider status provides additional confidence.​

Pace Analysis

The large field creates multiple pace scenarios with several fillies possessing early speed. Grab My Tab and Listentourmother show stalking tendencies that could establish early positioning. Stay Beautiful and But Seriously both demonstrate closing patterns that favor tactical rides in large fields.​

The one-mile turf distance allows tactical jockeys to position their mounts effectively before making decisive moves. Expect moderate early fractions with the pace quickening significantly in the final three furlongs as multiple closers unleash their rallies.

Breeding and Surface Considerations

Several runners make their turf debuts, creating uncertainty but also value opportunities. Stay Beautiful brings Asmussen’s expertise with surface switches, while Venus d’Oro represents Walsh’s exceptional record with turf runners. The European-style breeding patterns often associated with both barns should translate effectively to grass racing.​

First-time turf runners with proper breeding deserve special consideration in maiden company. The $40,000 claiming level attracts quality juveniles whose connections believe they can handle the surface transition.

Jockey Considerations

Joseph Ramos brings 60 starts with a 13% win rate and 43% in-the-money percentage, providing excellent tactical expertise for Stay Beautiful. Marcelino Pedroza Jr. offers 92 starts with 13% wins and 48% in-the-money statistics, supporting But Seriously’s chances. Fernando De La Cruz contributes his leading rider status with 66 starts and solid percentages for Grab My Tab.​

Key Angles and Wagering Strategy

The trainer angle strongly favors Stay Beautiful with Asmussen’s presence in maiden claiming company typically indicating serious competitive intentions. Venus d’Oro offers the debut angle with Walsh’s exceptional first-time starter record creating value potential.

Class relief benefits Grab My Tab dropping from higher-level competition, while the turf debut angle affects multiple runners creating uncertainty and opportunity.

Wagering Recommendations

Race 4 – Allowance Optional Claiming ($50,000) – 1 1/16 Miles Dirt – 3:43 PM

This competitive allowance optional claiming event for fillies and mares three years old and upward offers a substantial $49,680 purse with the winner earning $31,299. The race conditions favor horses that have never won $18,000 twice other than maiden, claiming, starter, restricted or state-bred competitions, creating an excellent competitive balance among seven declared runners.​

Key Contenders Analysis

Tiz Bayou emerges as the standout favorite with Mitchell Murrill aboard for trainer Tim Eggleston. This five-year-old mare by Tiz Sardonic Joe comes into this race off a decisive victory on October 21 at the identical course and distance, winning by comfortable margins while paying $4.20 to win. Her recent form shows consistent competitiveness with a third-place finish on October 29 behind stronger opposition. The mare demonstrates tactical versatility and handles the Horseshoe Indianapolis surface exceptionally well, having recorded multiple victories at the venue. Expert analysis confirms she looks well-placed to follow up her recent course and distance success against this tougher opposition.​

Flashy Lass represents the powerful Steven Asmussen barn with Joseph Ramos aboard. This five-year-old mare by Street Sense brings national trainer prestige to the allowance ranks, typically indicating serious competitive intentions. Her breeding suggests strong stamina for the 1 1/16-mile distance, while Asmussen’s presence in allowance company at regional tracks usually signals confidence in the horse’s ability. The trainer’s exceptional record with fillies and mares provides significant confidence despite limited recent form information.​

Peak Popularity commands attention as the second choice with Jose Ramos Gutierrez riding for Brian Knippenberg. This five-year-old mare by Mendelssohn carries a strong rating of 103 and receives expert backing as the main threat to Tiz Bayou. Her breeding suggests classic distance ability, while the weight allowance to 116 pounds provides tactical advantages in allowance competition.​

Secondary Choices Analysis

Condone brings tactical speed with Fernando De La Cruz aboard for Victoria Oliver. This five-year-old mare by Justify demonstrates consistent form with multiple placings at the venue, earning a rating of 92. Her recent efforts show competitiveness in similar allowance company, while De La Cruz’s leading rider status adds significant value to her chances.​

Shezalittlestinker enters off a impressive victory on September 8 at Horseshoe Indianapolis, winning by decisive margins with Declan Cannon aboard. This four-year-old filly by Gun Runner carries strong credentials from trainer Wayne Catalano, showing a rating of 87 and tactical flexibility. Her recent win demonstrates current form and familiarity with the track surface.​

Miss Authentic represents the three-year-old division with Marcelino Pedroza Jr. riding for Eddie Kenneally. As the youngest competitor carrying 122 pounds, she brings tactical speed and potential improvement from the three-year-old allowance ranks.​

Itzforever rounds out the field with Santo Sanjur aboard for Anthony Granitz. This five-year-old mare shows recent placings but faces stronger opposition in this allowance company.​

Pace Analysis

The compact field creates interesting tactical scenarios with several horses possessing early speed capabilities. Tiz Bayou has demonstrated tactical versatility, able to press the pace or close from off the speed depending on race flow. Peak Popularity and Condone bring early speed that could establish honest fractions, while Flashy Lass typically prefers tactical positioning for late rallies.​

The 1 1/16-mile distance allows patient rides and strong closing kicks. Expect moderate early pace with acceleration in the final half-mile as multiple closers launch their rallies.

Trainer and Jockey Considerations

Tim Eggleston continues his excellent form at the meet with Tiz Bayou representing his strongest chance in allowance company. The trainer’s partnership with Mitchell Murrill produces consistent results, particularly with route horses at Horseshoe Indianapolis.​

Steven Asmussen brings Hall of Fame credentials to regional allowance competition, typically indicating serious competitive intentions when shipping horses to tracks like Horseshoe Indianapolis. His presence alone elevates Flashy Lass’s chances significantly.​

Mitchell Murrill provides tactical expertise and strong finishing ability, particularly effective with mares and fillies in route races. His partnership with Eggleston creates additional confidence.​

Joseph Ramos offers consistent performance across multiple surfaces and distances, making him an ideal partner for Asmussen’s tactical approach.​

Key Angles and Wagering Strategy

The course and distance angle strongly favors Tiz Bayou, who won impressively at the identical conditions just two weeks ago. The class level appears perfectly suited to her current form, while the successful trainer-jockey combination provides additional confidence.​

The trainer upgrade angle benefits Flashy Lass with Asmussen’s national prominence creating value despite limited recent form. Peak Popularity brings the expert recommendation angle as the primary threat to the favorite.

The recent winner angle supports Shezalittlestinker, who scored impressively at the track in September and returns with proven form.​

Distance and Surface Considerations

The 1 1/16-mile dirt surface suits horses with tactical speed and strong closing ability. Tiz Bayou’s proven success at the distance provides significant advantages, while the breeding patterns of Peak Popularity and Flashy Lass suggest excellent stamina for the route distance.

The allowance conditions create competitive balance without overwhelming class differences, favoring horses in current form over those with higher historical achievements.

Wagering Recommendations

Race 5 – Claiming ($12,500) – 1 1/16 Miles Turf – 4:14 PM

Key Contenders:
Memphis Pharoah draws significant expert support with Joseph Ramos aboard for Randy Matthews. This five-year-old gelding offers value at projected 5-1 odds and benefits from the stable tactical approach.​

Boys Code brings class and tactical speed with Luis Contreras riding. The five-year-old gelding handles the turf surface effectively.

Stradivarian offers consistent performance with Jesus Lopez Castanon aboard for Grant Forster.

Longshot Consideration:
Super Snoop with Victor Lebron provides early pace potential from post 1. Born Flashy offers value with Mitchell Murrill for Tracey Wisner.

Pace Analysis: The large field creates pace pressure early on the turf course. The 1 1/16-mile distance favors tactical positioning and strong finishing kicks.

Key Angles: Turf specialists deserve preference over main track horses switching surfaces.

Wagering Angles: The 7-11-8 exacta combination provides value, while the 7-11-8-1 superfecta offers significant profit potential.

Selections: Win: Memphis Pharoah, Place: Boys Code, Show: Stradivarian

Race 6 – Starter Optional Claiming ($8,000) – 1 Mile Turf – 4:45 PM

Key Contenders:
Count of Amazonia emerges as the standout with Jesus Lopez Castanon aboard for Robert Hess Jr.. This Irish-bred gelding projects as the 7-2 morning line choice and handles the turf surface effectively.​

Kygo brings European breeding with Walter Rodriguez riding for John Hancock. The German-bred gelding offers tactical versatility.

King of Kentucky provides consistent performance with Joseph Ramos aboard for Claude Brownfield III.

Secondary Choices:
Driftwood offers value with Victor Lebron for Matt Kordenbrock. Face Value brings early pace with Jose Ramos Gutierrez.

Pace Analysis: The large field creates competitive pace scenario. The one-mile turf distance favors horses with tactical positioning.

Wagering Angles: The 9-10-11 exacta provides foundation betting, while the 9-10-11-7 superfecta offers enhanced returns.

Selections: Win: Count of Amazonia, Place: Kygo, Show: King of Kentucky

Race 7 – Indiana-Bred Claiming ($15,000) – 6 Furlongs Dirt – 5:16 PM

Key Contenders:
Highspeed Justice commands attention with Mitchell Murrill aboard for Tim Eggleston. This three-year-old filly projects as the 7-2 morning line choice and benefits from the successful trainer-jockey combination.​

Total Luna Eclipse brings early speed with Samuel Bermudez riding for Devarus Douglass. The three-year-old filly offers tactical advantages from the rail.

Indiana Smoke Show provides consistent performance with Joseph Ramos aboard for Randy Klopp, a leading trainer at the meet.​

Secondary Choices:
Sarah’s Smiles offers value with Santo Sanjur for Tianna Richardville. Queen’s Desire brings tactical speed with Alberto Burgos.

Pace Analysis: The restricted nature creates competitive pace scenario. The six-furlong distance favors horses with tactical speed and finishing ability.

Wagering Angles: The 11-1-5 exacta offers value, while the 11-1-5-9 superfecta provides enhanced profit potential.

Selections: Win: Highspeed Justice, Place: Total Luna Eclipse, Show: Indiana Smoke Show

Race 8 – Allowance – 6 Furlongs Dirt – 5:47 PM

This competitive allowance sprint for three-year-olds and upward features eight runners competing for a substantial $46,240 purse, with the winner earning $29,131. The race conditions target horses which have never won $12,000 once other than maiden, claiming, starter or state bred competitions, or which have never won two races, creating excellent competitive balance among experienced runners.​

Key Contenders Analysis

Sir Gallivant emerges as the 3/1 morning line favorite with Santo Sanjur aboard for trainer John Haran. This three-year-old gelding by Practical Joke demonstrates exceptional tactical speed with a “Fastest Stalker” running style and strong recent form. Expert analysis confirms his “strong claims” in this competitive field, while statistical projections show 19% win probability with 58% show percentage. His recent efforts show consistent competitiveness at Horseshoe Indianapolis with multiple placings over six furlongs, including a fourth-place finish in his most recent start. The combination of tactical speed and proven course form makes him the logical favorite.​

Gettysburg Address commands significant attention as the 7/2 second choice with Jose Ramos Gutierrez riding for trainer Cipriano Contreras. Expert analysis identifies him as the horse that “can build on a solid third last time out and looks the one to beat”. This four-year-old gelding by Constitution carries a strong 94 rating and demonstrates “Fast Deep” closing ability that suits the competitive pace scenario. His career record shows $481,000 in earnings from 15 starts with solid consistency, while recent form indicates improvement with a third-place finish in his latest effort over six furlongs at the track.​

Texas Free offers excellent value at 9/2 odds with Fernando De La Cruz aboard for leading trainer Randy Klopp. This four-year-old gelding by Texas Red brings impressive statistical projections with 30% win probability and 80% show percentage, the highest in the field. His “Fast Stalker” running style suits the six-furlong distance perfectly, while career earnings of $232,960 from 18 starts demonstrate consistent competitiveness. The Klopp-De La Cruz combination has been producing excellent results at the meet, with Klopp ranking among the leading trainers. Recent form shows third-place finishes in consecutive starts at Horseshoe Indianapolis, indicating current sharpness.​

Secondary Choices Analysis

Mondavila represents exceptional value at 5/1 odds with Joseph Ramos aboard for Randy Klopp. This three-year-old gelding by Mondavi demonstrates strong credentials with $568,790 in career earnings from 23 starts and a solid 30% win percentage. His recent partnership with Ramos for the Klopp barn has produced excellent results, including recent victories at the track. The weight advantage to 116 pounds provides additional tactical benefits, while his “Mid Pack Leads” running style creates pace versatility. Expert analysis notes his rating of 96, among the highest in the field.​

A Champs Dream brings impressive momentum with Danilo Grisales Rave riding for trainer Lilia Gonzalez. This three-year-old gelding demonstrates exceptional recent form with three consecutive victories and a perfect 100% in-the-money record from eight career starts. His “Fast Leader” running style could establish honest fractions from the inside posts, while the 50% win percentage indicates strong current form. The combination of winning momentum and early speed provides tactical advantages in allowance competition.​

Pace Analysis

The compact field creates interesting tactical scenarios with multiple early speed types. A Champs Dream brings “Fast Leader” ability from post 4, while Sir Gallivant offers “Fastest Stalker” positioning that allows tactical flexibility. Texas Free’s “Fast Stalker” style provides additional pace pressure, creating honest early fractions that should benefit closers like Gettysburg Address.​

The six-furlong distance emphasizes tactical speed and finishing ability. Expect moderate to honest early pace with acceleration in the final quarter-mile as multiple runners with tactical speed launch their rallies.

Trainer and Jockey Considerations

Randy Klopp continues his leading trainer performance at the meet with two strong entries in Texas Free and Mondavila. The trainer’s recent success with Joseph Ramos creates significant confidence in Mondavila, while the De La Cruz partnership with Texas Free provides additional tactical expertise. Klopp’s 16% win rate and 46% in-the-money percentage demonstrate consistent competitiveness.​

Fernando De La Cruz brings his leading rider status to Texas Free, providing tactical advantages with his 17% win rate and 38% in-the-money percentage at the meet. Joseph Ramos continues his excellent form with the Klopp stable, showing 14% wins and 48% in-the-money statistics.​

Key Angles and Wagering Strategy

The trainer angle strongly favors both Klopp entries, with the barn’s recent success creating multiple viable options. The recent winner angle supports A Champs Dream with three consecutive victories and perfect consistency.​

The expert recommendation angle benefits Gettysburg Address as the horse “to beat” despite longer odds, while the statistical projection angle favors Texas Free with the highest show percentage.​

Distance and Surface Considerations

The six-furlong dirt distance suits horses with tactical speed and strong acceleration. Sir Gallivant’s “Fastest Stalker” style provides ideal positioning, while Texas Free’s consistent course form demonstrates surface preferences.​

The allowance conditions create competitive balance among experienced runners without overwhelming class differences, favoring horses in current form over historical achievements.

Wagering Recommendations

Race 9 – Quarter Horse Allowance – 330 Yards Dirt – 6:15 PM

Key Contenders:
Sweet and Hott commands attention with Fernando Morin aboard for Corene Garcia. This three-year-old colt projects as the 8-5 morning line favorite in the sprint specialty.​

Dash On Willie provides early speed with Luis Daniel Martinez riding for Anthony Cunningham. The three-year-old gelding offers tactical advantages in quarter horse racing.

Jesss Check Me Out brings experience with Rolando Del Rio Pina aboard for Felix Barraza.

Secondary Choices:
Elegant Train offers value with Brian Hollingsworth for James Bratton. Cigma Chi provides consistent performance with Giovani Vazquez-Gomez.

Pace Analysis: Quarter horse racing emphasizes pure speed from the gate. The 330-yard distance requires immediate acceleration and sustained speed.

Wagering Angles: The 8-1-4 exacta offers foundation betting, while the 8-1-4-2 superfecta provides enhanced profit potential.

Selections: Win: Sweet and Hott, Place: Dash On Willie, Show: Jesss Check Me Out

Jockey Notes and Insights

Fernando De La Cruz enters as Horseshoe Indianapolis’ 2025 leading jockey with exceptional statistics. His partnership with various trainers produces consistent results, making him a key factor in multiple races.​

Mitchell Murrill continues his strong performance at the meet with successful partnerships, particularly with Tim Eggleston. His tactical riding style suits the track configuration effectively.​

Joseph Ramos provides consistent performance across multiple distances and surfaces. His partnerships with leading trainers enhance wagering confidence.

Alberto Burgos offers tactical versatility and strong finishing ability. His experience benefits horses requiring patient rides.

Trainer Notes and Insights

Randy Klopp leads the trainer standings with 60 wins from 305 starts, representing a solid 19.7% strike rate. His multiple entries throughout the card deserve significant respect.​

Tim Eggleston maintains strong performance with effective partnerships, particularly with Mitchell Murrill. The combination produces consistent results across various conditions.​

Steven Asmussen brings national prominence to maiden and allowance competition. His entries deserve automatic respect regardless of surface or distance.

Genaro Garcia ranks among leading trainers with 45 wins from 318 starts. His tactical approach suits various racing conditions.​

Best Wagering Strategies and Value Plays

Daily Double Opportunities: Race 1-2: M B’s Munning/Goingscents provides solid foundation at projected attractive odds.

Pick 3 Strategy: Races 3-4-5: Venus d’Oro/Tiz Bayou/Memphis Pharoah offers excellent value potential with manageable risk.

Exacta Value Plays: Focus on races with competitive fields and value-priced favorites. The 2-6 exacta in Race 1 and 3-2 exacta in Race 8 provide solid opportunities.

Longshot Considerations: Venus d’Oro in Race 3 at 8-1 and Memphis Pharoah in Race 5 at 5-1 offer excellent value in competitive fields.​

Late Pick 4: Races 6-7-8-9 combining Count of Amazonia, Highspeed Justice, Mondavila, and Sweet and Hott provides potential for significant returns with manageable risk.