Pick Pony Picks – Consensus Expert Picks for Horseshoe Indianapolis, May 12, 2026.


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Consensus Expert Picks

Consensus rankings based on 7 experts. Scoring: 1st pick = 4 pts, 2nd = 3 pts, 3rd = 2 pts, 4th = 1 pt. Agreement % = share of experts that included each horse.

Race 1

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Win:6 – Daphne Brewnette (2-1)6/785.7%21 pts
Place:5 – High Dollar Dolly (6-1)4/757.1%13 pts
Show:7 – My Wish (4-1)4/757.1%8 pts

Alternatives

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Alt 1:4 – Long Tail Sally (5-1)2/728.6%7 pts
Alt 2:3 – Not Today Boss (15-1)2/728.6%4 pts
Alt 3:1 – Baytown Munny (4-1)1/714.3%1 pts
Alt 4:8 – Spirit Moves Me (15-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 5:2 – Le Bien Le Mal (15-1)0/70.0%0 pts

Race 2

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Win:5 – Ryan's Wish (4-1)7/7100.0%26 pts
Place:6 – Good Stuff (6-1)5/771.4%9 pts
Show:1 – Chisel (4-1)3/742.9%9 pts

Alternatives

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Alt 1:3 – Einstein's Ghost (4-1)3/742.9%9 pts
Alt 2:2 – You're Fired (5-1)1/714.3%1 pts
Alt 3:4 – Machts Nichts (3-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 4:7 – Hanksatank (15-1)0/70.0%0 pts

Race 3

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Win:4 – Four Star General (4-1)6/785.7%18 pts
Place:1 – Gotanotiontodrink (1-1)5/771.4%18 pts
Show:6 – U R Not The Father (4-1)3/742.9%8 pts

Alternatives

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Alt 1:5 – Polar Drift (4-1)3/742.9%4 pts
Alt 2:3 – Practical Justice (10-1)2/728.6%6 pts
Alt 3:2 – Mystery Impact (8-1)0/70.0%0 pts

Race 4

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Win:3 – Dawn At Normandy (2-1)7/7100.0%24 pts
Place:2 – Sargent Sully (2-1)5/771.4%18 pts
Show:7 – Lil Muggs (5-1)3/742.9%4 pts

Alternatives

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Alt 1:1 – Love In Lights (10-1)2/728.6%3 pts
Alt 2:6 – Tap Tap Tap It In (6-1)1/714.3%3 pts
Alt 3:8 – Zapping Strike (12-1)1/714.3%2 pts
Alt 4:5 – Poetic Words (30-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 5:4 – Dreaming Smart (30-1)0/70.0%0 pts

Race 5

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Win:2 – Breakaway (3-1)5/771.4%16 pts
Place:8 – He's A Charmer (2-1)4/757.1%14 pts
Show:9 – The Fed's Plot (6-1)3/742.9%10 pts

Alternatives

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Alt 1:13 – Amberssohn (15-1)2/728.6%2 pts
Alt 2:15 – Zun Reyder (10-1)1/714.3%4 pts
Alt 3:6 – Rosie's Words (10-1)1/714.3%3 pts
Alt 4:7 – In The Tank (15-1)1/714.3%2 pts
Alt 5:11 – The Blue Factor (20-1)1/714.3%2 pts
Alt 6:3 – Moral Man (8-1)1/714.3%1 pts
Alt 7:12 – Punkin Boy (20-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 8:5 – Miss You Mo (30-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 9:10 – Run Louie Run (30-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 10:1 – Stop The Nonsense (20-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 11:4 – Happy I Got It (30-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 12:14 – Fuoco (20-1)0/70.0%0 pts

Race 6

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Win:5 – Star Saver (2-1)6/785.7%21 pts
Place:6 – No Mo Moolah (3-1)5/771.4%16 pts
Show:7 – Drogon (5-1)3/742.9%8 pts

Alternatives

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Alt 1:8 – Nehalem (4-1)3/742.9%5 pts
Alt 2:3 – Run David Run (6-1)1/714.3%2 pts
Alt 3:4 – Flaming Embers (15-1)1/714.3%2 pts
Alt 4:2 – Howlin' Wolf (20-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 5:1 – K J High Country (30-1)0/70.0%0 pts

Race 7

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Win:6 – Terre Haute (4-1)4/757.1%15 pts
Place:10 – Candy Cane Crain (5-1)4/757.1%13 pts
Show:2 – Dionysus (6-1)4/757.1%10 pts

Alternatives

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Alt 1:7 – Roktar (12-1)2/728.6%4 pts
Alt 2:11 – Boonesboro (10-1)1/714.3%4 pts
Alt 3:14 – Diamondlanejimmy (10-1)1/714.3%3 pts
Alt 4:12 – Feline Curious (15-1)1/714.3%2 pts
Alt 5:5 – En Pointe (12-1)1/714.3%2 pts
Alt 6:3 – El Tio (8-1)1/714.3%1 pts
Alt 7:8 – Thespian (10-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 8:4 – Mr American Pie (15-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 9:9 – King Of Heat (6-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 10:13 – Put Me In Coach (30-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 11:1 – Blazy (30-1)0/70.0%0 pts

Race 8

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Win:5 – Hungry Reggae (4-1)6/785.7%19 pts
Place:1 – I'malittlethirsty (4-1)5/771.4%19 pts
Show:11 – Onelilconquest (8-1)2/728.6%4 pts

Alternatives

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Alt 1:12 – Blazen Eyes (6-1)2/728.6%4 pts
Alt 2:4 – Whakaari (20-1)2/728.6%4 pts
Alt 3:9 – Jogger (5-1)1/714.3%3 pts
Alt 4:2 – Innisfree Prayer (10-1)1/714.3%1 pts
Alt 5:3 – Chelle Shocked (15-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 6:10 – Miss Candy Pop (10-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 7:7 – Justiceontherail (15-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 8:6 – Cover Art (20-1)0/70.0%0 pts
Alt 9:8 – Misty Moon Song (15-1)0/70.0%0 pts

Race 9

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Win:5 – Run N For The Roses (3-1)5/683.3%16 pts
Place:8 – Scarcity (4-1)3/650.0%9 pts
Show:6 – Hurricane Beach (4-1)3/650.0%9 pts

Alternatives

PickHorseExpertsAgreementScore
Alt 1:3 – Politicallybodacious (8-1)2/633.3%4 pts
Alt 2:4 – Cyber Dash (6-1)1/616.7%4 pts
Alt 3:7 – Marys Tacha (6-1)1/616.7%2 pts
Alt 4:1 – Checkout Liz 897 (20-1)0/60.0%0 pts
Alt 5:2 – Hf Arkansas Dave (12-1)0/60.0%0 pts
Alt 6:9 – Dna Chrystaldaleswin (10-1)0/60.0%0 pts

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback