Pick Pony Picks – Consensus Expert Picks for Mahoning Valley, April 9, 2026.


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Consensus Expert Picks

Consensus rankings based on 7 experts. Scoring: 1st pick = 4 pts, 2nd = 3 pts, 3rd = 2 pts, 4th = 1 pt. Agreement % = share of experts that included each horse.

Race 1

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Carmel Rose (2)1-17/7100.0%27 pts
2Lady Hamilton (5)3-14/757.1%10 pts
3Sip'n' Speed (3)12-14/757.1%6 pts
4Miss Serafina (6)4-13/742.9%6 pts
5Late Nite Lizzie (1)6-13/742.9%5 pts
6Oh Glorious Day (4)20-12/728.6%0 pts

Race 2

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Tricky Tiger (1)2-15/771.4%19 pts
2Trigger Point (3)3-14/757.1%14 pts
3Sock It To Me (2)2-15/771.4%11 pts
4One Smokin' Rita (4)8-15/771.4%10 pts
5Thru The Vine (5)4-12/728.6%0 pts
6Reinvest (6)12-12/728.6%0 pts

Race 3

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1More Than Five (4)2-17/7100.0%26 pts
2Brewing (1)3-14/757.1%14 pts
3Poppy's Pride (2)8-14/757.1%5 pts
4Morethanreadyeddie (7)6-13/742.9%3 pts
5Improbable First (3)8-13/742.9%3 pts
6Big Bucksalot (5)4-12/728.6%3 pts
7Priority Lane (6)8-12/728.6%0 pts

Race 4

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Big Ginger (4)2-16/785.7%22 pts
2Right Trappe (5)2-15/771.4%15 pts
3Beautiful Mandate (2)10-14/757.1%8 pts
4Tiz Independence (1)10-13/742.9%5 pts
5A Kiss For Khozan (7)4-12/728.6%2 pts
6G'day Lady (3)8-13/742.9%1 pts
7Lubu (6)6-12/728.6%1 pts

Race 5

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Honor And Obay (2)2-16/785.7%23 pts
2Hoof And Boots (5)6-15/771.4%14 pts
3Striking Lady (4)15-13/742.9%6 pts
4R Candy (6)4-13/742.9%4 pts
5Jen D'oro (3)2-12/728.6%4 pts
6Pincara (7)15-13/742.9%2 pts
7Tale Of Lemonbelle (1)8-13/742.9%1 pts
8This One's For Us (8)12-12/728.6%0 pts

Race 6

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Stomping Moon (2)2-16/785.7%20 pts
2Washington's Union (1)2-14/757.1%13 pts
3Dream Knight (6)4-13/742.9%9 pts
4Ice Blast (3)8-13/742.9%4 pts
5See Spot Run (4)5-13/742.9%4 pts
6Collectorate (5)15-13/742.9%2 pts
7Pace (7)10-13/742.9%2 pts

Race 7

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Onirico (1)1-27/7100.0%28 pts
2Kickstart (7)5-14/757.1%8 pts
3Docs Legend (2)8-14/757.1%7 pts
4Gone Wild (6)6-12/728.6%6 pts
5Mr. Bali (4)15-13/742.9%3 pts
6Little Shance (5)10-13/742.9%2 pts
7Magic Motown (3)20-12/728.6%0 pts

Race 8

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Plum Tuff (2)4-15/771.4%15 pts
2Professor Nick (5)2-15/771.4%15 pts
3Bumpkin (7)5-14/757.1%12 pts
4Glory Reigns (4)3-14/757.1%10 pts
5Guess Again (6)4-13/742.9%2 pts
6Couple Beers Deep (3)15-12/728.6%0 pts
7Truth N Soul (1)12-12/728.6%0 pts

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback