Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

How often our pick wins, by its price

AI Ensemble top picks grouped by morning-line odds.

Short-priced selections are where the model is strongest.

Show the numbers

Group	Win rate	Races
Odds-on to 5/2	41.6%	2,442
5/2 to 5/1	29.8%	2,188
Longer than 5/1	30.5%	82

Consensus Expert Picks

Consensus rankings based on 6 experts. Scoring: 1st pick = 4 pts, 2nd = 3 pts, 3rd = 2 pts, 4th = 1 pt. Agreement % = share of experts that included each horse. A gold star (⭐) next to a horse means Pick Pony's AI independently ranks that horse #1 as well — historically the strongest-hitting subset of picks. A recycle mark (↻) means that AI pick is the re-ranked one, after this morning's official scratches and surface changes were applied.

Race 1

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Win:	1 – Ximena (4-1) ⭐	6/6	100.0%	24 pts
Place:	8 – Spastic Bid (4-1)	3/6	50.0%	9 pts
Show:	2 – Nohai (5-1)	3/6	50.0%	6 pts

Alternatives

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Alt 1:	5 – Astrid (4-1)	3/6	50.0%	5 pts
Alt 2:	6 – Edge Of The Blade (6-1)	1/6	16.7%	2 pts
Alt 3:	7 – My Little Wildcat (6-1)	1/6	16.7%	1 pts
Alt 4:	3 – Queen Catalina (10-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts
Alt 5:	4 – Brooklyn Heights (8-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts

Race 2

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Win:	1 – No Mor Stones (3-1) ⭐	6/6	100.0%	24 pts
Place:	3 – Easter Blessing (4-1)	4/6	66.7%	9 pts
Show:	8 – Basin Bay (4-1)	3/6	50.0%	7 pts

Alternatives

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Alt 1:	2 – Final Joke (6-1)	2/6	33.3%	4 pts
Alt 2:	5 – Quick To Judge (5-1)	2/6	33.3%	3 pts
Alt 3:	6 – Catalina Cree (8-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts
Alt 4:	4 – Lucky Capo (12-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts
Alt 5:	7 – Whoosh (10-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts

Race 3

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Win:	3 – Inner Excellence (2-1) ⭐	6/6	100.0%	21 pts
Place:	5 – Wanting Attention (5-1)	3/6	50.0%	9 pts
Show:	4 – Emmyaswifty (4-1)	3/6	50.0%	4 pts

Alternatives

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Alt 1:	2 – Majestic Twirl (6-1)	2/6	33.3%	6 pts
Alt 2:	1 – My Last Dime (2-1)	2/6	33.3%	3 pts
Alt 3:	6 – Irie And Mellow (8-1)	1/6	16.7%	4 pts

Race 4

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Win:	2 – Fromanothamutha (2-1) ⭐	6/6	100.0%	20 pts
Place:	1 – Atrocious (4-1)	4/6	66.7%	7 pts
Show:	4 – Always Gambling (6-1)	3/6	50.0%	7 pts

Alternatives

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Alt 1:	6 – Traffic Master (3-1)	2/6	33.3%	7 pts
Alt 2:	3 – Whiting Field (4-1)	2/6	33.3%	6 pts
Alt 3:	5 – What It Tiz (5-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts

Race 5

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Win:	7 – Never Sway (2-1) ⭐	6/6	100.0%	21 pts
Place:	5 – Moor Strength (4-1)	4/6	66.7%	13 pts
Show:	3 – Judy's Flyer (8-1)	2/6	33.3%	4 pts

Alternatives

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Alt 1:	8 – Fussy Girl (6-1)	2/6	33.3%	4 pts
Alt 2:	1 – Laugh Like Lucy (6-1)	2/6	33.3%	3 pts
Alt 3:	6 – Zeena Swift (4-1)	1/6	16.7%	2 pts
Alt 4:	2 – She Can Scat (12-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts
Alt 5:	4 – Sunlit (15-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts

Race 6

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Win:	2 – The Magic Speed (4-1) ⭐	6/6	100.0%	21 pts
Place:	5 – Just Another Ten (3-1)	4/6	66.7%	12 pts
Show:	1 – Chance On Me (5-1)	3/6	50.0%	6 pts

Alternatives

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Alt 1:	4 – Zamirzo (4-1)	3/6	50.0%	5 pts
Alt 2:	3 – Silver Punch (6-1)	1/6	16.7%	3 pts
Alt 3:	7 – Big Hawk (6-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts
Alt 4:	6 – Craigh Na Dun (12-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts

Race 7

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Win:	4 – Lotsa Trouble (4-1) ⭐	6/6	100.0%	23 pts
Place:	5 – Lasso (3-1)	4/6	66.7%	11 pts
Show:	2 – Soze (6-1)	3/6	50.0%	7 pts

Alternatives

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Alt 1:	1 – Blazing Bucchero (5-1)	2/6	33.3%	3 pts
Alt 2:	3 – Chris's Revenge (2-1)	1/6	16.7%	2 pts
Alt 3:	6 – Yahoo Omar (4-1)	1/6	16.7%	1 pts

Race 8

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Win:	3 – Trotsky (4-1)	5/6	83.3%	17 pts
Place:	2 – Ready As Ever (4-1)	4/6	66.7%	13 pts
Show:	6 – America's Honor (4-1)	4/6	66.7%	8 pts

Alternatives

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Alt 1:	4 – N. Y. Finest (5-1)	2/6	33.3%	5 pts
Alt 2:	5 – My Military Hero (5-1)	2/6	33.3%	4 pts
Alt 3:	1 – Fenton Forever (6-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts
Alt 4:	7 – Chilling Zensation (6-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts

Race 9

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Win:	4 – Ohio Joe (8-1)	4/6	66.7%	14 pts
Place:	1 – Bourbon Aficionado (4-1)	4/6	66.7%	14 pts
Show:	2 – Roxton (4-1)	3/6	50.0%	4 pts

Alternatives

Pick	Horse	Experts	Agreement	Score
Alt 1:	8 – Home Invasion (4-1)	2/6	33.3%	7 pts
Alt 2:	6 – Tavern Time (6-1)	2/6	33.3%	4 pts
Alt 3:	5 – Fully Committed (5-1)	1/6	16.7%	2 pts
Alt 4:	3 – River's Gamble (6-1)	1/6	16.7%	2 pts
Alt 5:	7 – Smooth Motion (10-1)	0/6	0.0%	0 pts