Pick Pony Tip Sheet – Expert picks for Oaklawn Park, December 27, 2025. 30% WIN RATE


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Race 1 – Maiden Special Weight – 8F – Dirt

Win: CATTLE BARON (4) – 75% confidence🥉
Place: SIOUX EMPIRE (8) – 62% confidence
Show: SIR HENRY OLIVER (5) – 50% confidence🥇
Alternative: SPOOKY ACTION (9) – 38% confidence

Analyst notes: Strong consensus around Cattle Baron following his runner-up effort last start. Sioux Empire draws support as the only runner with distance experience at the top level. Sir Henry Oliver and Spooky Action both have recent layoffs but could upset given pace dynamics and smaller field.


Race 2 – Maiden Special Weight – 8F 110Y – Dirt WIN

Win: SEARCH PARTY (8) – 62% confidence🥇
Place: DARE GREATLY (7) – 62% confidence🥉
Show: INTANGIBLE (4) – 62% confidence
Alternative: ROCKIN ROBIN (9) – 38% confidence🥈

Analyst notes: Wide split consensus with three horses receiving multiple win selections. Search Party and Dare Greatly both bring proven form at the distance. Intangible showed improvement in recent starts and gets support from Cox barn. This figures as a competitive affair with little separation among the top contenders.


Race 3 – Maiden Special Weight – 8F 110Y – Dirt WIN

Win: CIRCLE TAP (3) – 75% confidence🥇
Place: ROCKY RACCOON (9) – 50% confidence🥉
Show: CACTUS CHARLIE (6) – 50% confidence
Alternative: FLEEK (10) – 38% confidence

Analyst notes: Circle Tap emerges with clear consensus after showing promise with two placed efforts. Rocky Raccoon and Cactus Charlie both have placed multiple times recently and could compete for minor honors. Fleek's stakes experience at other tracks adds intrigue but must overcome recent slow form.


Race 4 – Maiden Optional Claiming – 8F – Dirt

Win: CANDY CANE CRAIN (9) – 62% confidence🥉
Place: NO MORE KINGS (11) – 62% confidence
Show: PALMER BEACH (3) – 38% confidence
Alternative: ROCHESTER (4) – 38% confidence

Analyst notes: Evenly matched contest between Candy Cane Crain and No More Kings. Candy Cane Crain's narrow loss last time out holds appeal while No More Kings benefits from dropping to non-metro grade. Palmer Beach and Rochester both enter at higher odds with upset potential if pace favors their running styles.


Race 5 – Maiden Special Weight – 8F – Dirt

Win: SECRET SLEW (9) – 75% confidence🥉
Place: TALLAHASSEE (3) – 50% confidence
Show: SHES MY LAST CALL (11) – 50% confidence
Alternative: CUTENCLASSY (5) – 38% confidence

Analyst notes: Secret Slew dominates consensus after two consecutive placings and returns to winning distance. Tallahassee and Shes My Last Call both figure in the mix with recent form supporting consideration. Cutenclassy debuts for a top barn but faces experienced competition.


Race 6 – Maiden Claiming – 1320Y – Dirt

Win: MCFASTY (6) – 62% confidence🥉
Place: MISKELL (7) – 62% confidence
Show: BROSNAN (8) – 50% confidence
Alternative: PRIME SUSPECT (3) – 38% confidence🥈

Analyst notes: McFasty benefits from class drop while Miskell seeks improvement after disappointing as favorite. Brosnan's recent layoff could help fresh; Paired and Little Krush command attention despite longer odds. Prime Suspect cannot be dismissed despite slower early support.


Race 7 – Maiden Special Weight – 1320Y – Dirt

Win: JOKE MAKER (8) – 62% confidence🥈
Place: CHARTED DESTINY (10) – 50% confidence
Show: IZZY'S GUNNA RUN (5) – 50% confidence
Alternative: FRENCH FRICTION (7) – 38% confidence🥇

Analyst notes: Joke Maker's multiple placings against tougher fields provide foundation, though pace and trip are new considerations. Charted Destiny and Izzy's Gunna Run both offer appeal with strong training pedigrees. French Friction debuts but draws support from progressive barn.


Race 8 – Year’s End Stakes – 8F – Dirt WIN

Win: COUNTING STARS (8) – 62% confidence🥇
Place: PAVING (5) – 75% confidence
Show: COPPER WIND (2) – 62% confidence
Alternative: FIZZY LASS (4) – 38% confidence

Analyst notes: Counting Stars and Paving split win consensus with both showing strong recent form. Copper Wind's impressive debut performance cannot be overlooked and appears on most expert radar. Fizzy Lass just won maiden but faces significant class climb in stakes company.


Race 9 – Maiden Optional Claiming – 1320Y – Dirt

Win: KILLA SALLY (7) – 75% confidence
Place: LEGAL LIGHTNING (2) – 62% confidence
Show: HUCK'S AGENDA (10) – 50% confidence🥉
Alternative: STEEL GIRL (3) – 38% confidence

Analyst notes: Killa Sally earns strong consensus after narrowly missing last start. Legal Lightning's consecutive placings provide steady support for place consideration. Huck's Agenda and Steel Girl both offer utility value in exotics. Trip down could favor closers if pace develops.


Race 10 – Starter Optional Claiming – 8F – Dirt

Win: HORSE OF THE SEA (7) – 62% confidence🥈
Place: AFTER PARTY (11) – 50% confidence
Show: KID CHARLEMAGNE (10) – 62% confidence
Alternative: OPUS UNO (12) – 38% confidence

Analyst notes: Horse of the Sea draws multiple expert support despite recent below-par effort and could bounce back. After Party and Kid Charlemagne both command respect with recent winning form. Opus Uno brings consistent placed efforts and Herbs Bolt remains viable at morning line odds.


Race 1 – Maiden Special Weight

Key angles focus on Cattle Baron as the likely favorite but potential overlay given his first route attempt. Pairing Cattle Baron with Sioux Empire in exacta and trifecta combinations captures the likely finish while keeping ticket prices manageable. The distance premium in Sioux Empire's favor despite slower odds creates value in exacta boxes starting with either horse. Consider: Cattle Baron-Sioux Empire exacta, and Cattle Baron-Sioux Empire-Sir Henry Oliver trifecta.


Race 2 – Maiden Special Weight

The competitive nature of this race argues for broader trifecta coverage. Given three horses receiving equivalent support, employ a box or wheel approach. Search Party-Dare Greatly exacta captures the most likely top-two finishes. For trifecta, expand to include Intangible and Rockin Robin in the third position. Value emerges in exacta wheels around Dare Greatly (7) given potential for she to be overlooked in win wagering despite equal credentials.


Race 3 – Maiden Special Weight

Circle Tap's dominant consensus makes the horse vulnerable to overplay in straight wagering. Exactas and trifectas featuring Fleek, Rocky Raccoon, and Cactus Charlie in supporting positions offer value if Circle Tap can be accepted. Consider trifecta combinations with Circle Tap across the board but emphasizing alternative top finishers given uncertain pace setup. Rocky Raccoon-Circle Tap exacta provides contrast to consensus order.


Race 4 – Maiden Optional Claiming

The split consensus between Candy Cane Crain and No More Kings creates natural exacta opportunities. Box Candy Cane Crain and No More Kings, then expand to include Palmer Beach for trifecta overlay. The class-drop angle on No More Kings merits closer examination; if dropping is the key, exacta wheeling No More Kings on top could prove lucrative. Avoid overweighting No More Kings given higher odds attracting public money.


Race 5 – Maiden Special Weight

Secret Slew's strong consensus suggests the horse will be underlaid. Exacta wheeling with Tallahassee and Shes My Last Call creates value. The maiden-breaker angle on debuts (Cutenclassy and Shrimp Cookie) could disrupt, making trifecta coverage essential. Favor Secret Slew in place positions over win, then use exotica to capture undervalued top finishes. Tallahassee-Secret Slew exacta offers contrast to consensus order.


Race 6 – Maiden Claiming

McFasty and Miskell split consensus, both viable exacta combinations. Consider the long-shot value in Paired (1) and Little Krush (11), both receiving Marketwise support despite longer odds. McFasty-Miskell exacta box captures likely top two. Expand trifecta to include Brosnan, creating value if McFasty stumbles. Prime Suspect cannot be entirely dismissed at 10-1 morning line odds.


Race 7 – Maiden Special Weight

Joke Maker emerges with slight edge but trip uncertainty (first time at 1320Y) adds risk. Exacta pairing Joke Maker with Charted Destiny and Izzy's Gunna Run. Consider trifecta with French Friction to capture potential upset if pace plays suit for fresher horse. Charted Destiny-Joke Maker exacta offers value if Charted Destiny's form holds. The higher odds on Charted Destiny make exacta wheels around that horse attractive.


Race 8 – Year's End Stakes

Stakes racing typically attracts higher-quality animals and tighter finishes. Box Counting Stars-Paving exacta with Copper Wind in supporting positions. Counting Stars-Paving-Copper Wind trifecta captures consensus range. Avoid large trifecta wheels given higher takeouts. Paving's unbeaten record and Copper Wind's impressive debut create value if either hits the board; exacta investments should reflect this quality.


Race 9 – Maiden Optional Claiming

Killa Sally's consensus suggests potential overplay. Exacta wheel with Legal Lightning on top given superior odds. Killa Sally-Legal Lightning captures top contenders; expand trifecta to include Huck's Agenda. Given the spread of opinions, broader trifecta coverage justified. Consider: Killa Sally-Legal Lightning exacta and Killa Sally-Legal Lightning-Huck's Agenda trifecta.


Race 10 – Starter Optional Claiming

Horse of the Sea's consensus despite poor recent effort creates potential overlay opportunity. Box Horse of the Sea with Kid Charlemagne; wheel After Party (11) in trifecta if bottom-heavy odds suggest public discount. Horse of the Sea-Kid Charlemagne exacta captures the consensus pair. Opus Uno's consistent placings merit consideration; Horse of the Sea-Opus Uno exacta provides alternative top-two combination.


Value Play Observations

Race 1: Sioux Empire (8) represents value in place wagering at 3-1 morning line odds despite receiving support from multiple analysts for win consideration. His only distance experience came in open company where he faced a wall of horses; the smaller field here suits his style.

Race 2: Dolladoro (1) offers intriguing value at 8-1 for win consideration given her breeding advantages for two turns and stable's history with maiden improvement. The analyst note about her auction pedigree and class suggests potential to improve significantly over early efforts.

Race 3: Cactus Charlie (6) draws consensus support but shorter odds of 2-1 suggest he may be overvalued in public markets. His four recent placings provide solid foundation, but CIRCLE TAP's improvements make the favorite more attractive on value basis.

Race 4: Rochester (4) at 8-1 offers value in trifecta combinations despite receiving minimal direct support. His placement finish on debut and connection through McPeek barn suggest upside overlooked by analysts.

Race 5: Shes My Last Call (11) – Guaranteed Tip Sheet analyst's selection as win choice at 12-1 odds represents clear value over Secret Slew's chalk. Her debut credentials and barn connections justify the longer odds.

Race 6: Paired (1) at 15-1 receives Marketwise attention despite being largely ignored elsewhere. The claim value angle and drop in class could unlock value if horse has regained focus.

Race 7: Charted Destiny (10) at 12-1 morning line odds appears undervalued given multiple analyst selections. The pace angle at 1320Y favors horses with tactical positioning; Charted Destiny's barn can position accordingly.

Race 8: Authentic Cat (9) at 8-1 receives significant Marketwise support in consensus but appears less favored in public morning lines. In a competitive stakes field, the value tilts to this horse in exacta and trifecta combinations.

Race 9: Steel Girl (3) at 5-1 offers structural value given she debuts for a solid stable and receives multiple analyst mentions. First-time starters from quality barns carry inherent unpredictability; odds may not reflect her earning potential.

Race 10: After Party (11) at 5-1 receives strong Marketwise support but appears overlooked in wider analyst consensus. The value play clusters around this horse if market underestimates the class-drop angle.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback