Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!
Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.
Race 1 – Maiden Special Weight – 1 Mile Turf – 1:00 PM WIN + BOXECD TRIFECTA
Win: Ramayana (12) – 54% confidence🥇
Place: Chair's Coin (8) – 36% confidence🥉
Show: Improbable U (2) – 27% confidence🥈
Alternative: Luckiest (10) – 27% confidence
Race 1 displays moderate consensus around the favorite despite an outside draw. Ramayana shows turf pedigree and trainer form at Mandella barn. Chair's Coin represents logical second choice with recent placing form. Improbable U and Luckiest split show opinion, creating potential overlay value on show prices. Island Home could surprise as well-placed longshot after recent narrow loss.
Race 2 – Maiden Special Weight – 1430 Yards Dirt – 1:31 PM
Win: Winston Ave (1) – 73% confidence
Place: Newton (4) – 45% confidence
Show: Secured Freedom (3) – 18% confidence🥇
Alternative: Plagarist (6) – 18% confidence
Overwhelming analyst backing for Winston Ave as win candidate reflects Baffert experience and strong debut form. Newton represents natural second choice with barn progression angle. Secured Freedom and Plagarist split third-place opinion, indicating wider-than-expected field variance. Captain Shreve offers exotic value as speed option despite trainer's limited dirt sprint record with debuts.
Race 3 – Allowance Optional Claiming – 1 Mile Turf – 2:01 PM
Win: Runamileinmyshoes (4) – 45% confidence
Place: Corporal Violette (1) – 27% confidence
Show: Candy Bar (3) – 27% confidence
Alternative: Delightful Laura (7) – 18% confidence🥈
Competitive optional claiming field shows no overwhelming consensus, with Runamileinmyshoes projecting as modest favorite on recent Santa Anita win. Multiple specialists designate Corporal Violette as “live value longshot” with proven course success and Mullins claim credentials. Speed-oriented Delightful Laura creates interesting pace dynamics. Toes and Royal Charter represent additional exotic angles in wide-open contest.
Race 4 – Allowance Optional Claiming – 1430 Yards Dirt – 2:33 PM
Win: Rizzleberry Rose (2) – 55% confidence
Place: Diva Cat (12) – 27% confidence
Show: Miss Practical (3) – 18% confidence🥈
Alternative: Wishtheyallcouldbe (13) – 27% confidence🥇
Rizzleberry Rose represents solid consensus with consistent placing form and recent Del Mar second. Diva Cat and Wishtheyallcouldbe split place opinion, with Diva Cat supported by Baffert barn consistency and blinker addition angle, while Wishtheyallcouldbe attracts class-drop angle specialists despite recent poor effort. Miss Practical represents show angle from multiple analysts. Higher place/show variance creates useful exacta box construction opportunities.
Race 5 – Mathis Mile Stakes (Grade 2) – 1 Mile Turf – 3:05 PM
Win: Namaron (3) – 73% confidence🥉
Place: Friendly Confines (5) – 45% confidence
Show: Tempus Volat (2) – 27% confidence🥈
Alternative: Hiding In Honduras (1) – 9% confidence🥇
Grade 2 stakes features dominant consensus on Namaron despite difficult company. Eight analysts back the choice with citations of strong turf form and conditioning. Friendly Confines establishes clear place position with multiple Grade 1 placings demonstrating class. Tempus Volat watch designation from quality sources suggests upset potential. Graded stakes integrity typically supports chalk, but limited consensus depth beyond top two creates concentrated wagering environment.
Race 6 – Laffit Pincay Jr. Stakes (Grade 2) – 1 Mile 110 Yards Dirt – 3:37 PM WIN + TRIFECTA
Win: Nysos (1) – 82% confidence🥇
Place: Nevada Beach (3) – 45% confidence🥈
Show: Bartholdy (7) – 18% confidence🥉
Alternative: British Isles (5) – 9% confidence
Overwhelming analyst consensus on Nysos reflects four consecutive wins and dominant recent form. Multiple sources cite exceptional speed figures and track record. Nevada Beach solidly entrenched as place choice with two wins from three attempts this campaign. High confidence concentration in top two creates concentrated betting environment, but Grade 2 integrity and dominant form support consensus. Nevada Beach overlay potential relative to analyst frequency. Bartholdy represents show angle with recent Del Mar win form.
Race 7 – Allowance Optional Claiming – 1430 Yards Turf – 4:10 PM
Win: Anmer Hall (1) – 64% confidence
Place: Mucho Del Oro (8) – 36% confidence
Show: Proof He Rides (4) – 27% confidence🥇
Alternative: Winning Patriot (3) – 18% confidence
Anmer Hall establishes solid consensus as turf specialist with two straight wins including Santa Anita and Kentucky Downs success. Mucho Del Oro presents “knows how to win downhill” angle with Santa Anita turf success. Proof He Rides attracts Mullins claim specialist backing (23% first-off claim win rate) with recent second down-course placement. Best Bet designation from Noel Michaels confirms high analyst confidence. Place/show splits create moderate exotic potential with three viable place options.
Race 8 – La Brea Stakes (Grade 1) – 1540 Yards Dirt – 4:43 PM BOXED EXACTA
Win: Formula Rossa (9) – 45% confidence🥈
Place: Usha (5) – 27% confidence🥇
Show: Artisma (4) – 18% confidence
Alternative: Magnificat (10) – 27% confidence
Competitive Grade 1 features balanced expert opinion with Formula Rossa representing relatively weak consensus chalk (45%) for Grade 1 company. Five G and Usha represent strong claims at 36% and 27% confidence. Magnificat carries Keeneland Select top contender designation. Artisma and Her Laugh create doubling opportunities. Multiple analysts note significant form variance and potential for second-tier breakthrough. Grade 1 field depth combined with low win consensus (45%) creates meaningful value in exotic combinations. Place/show variance significantly higher than typical indicates inefficiency in morning odds structure.
Race 9 – San Gabriel Stakes (Grade 3) – 9 Furlongs Turf – 5:16 PM
Win: Stay Hot (4) – 73% confidence
Place: Cabo Spirit (9) – 27% confidence🥇
Show: Astronomer (8) – 27% confidence🥈
Alternative: Mondego (2) – 18% confidence🥉
Dominant analyst consensus on Stay Hot reflects track specialist credentials (three Santa Anita wins) and strong barn backing. Multiple sources cite late-running tactical comfort from graded stakes environment. Cabo Spirit designated “must-use exotic” by specialists despite eighth choice morning line odds. Astronomer presents value angle with consistent form but notable 0-for-6 Santa Anita record limitation. High win consensus (73%) suggests overlaid chalk on probable favorite. Place/show splits between Cabo Spirit, Astronomer, and Mondego create concentrated wagering opportunities for Pick 3/Pick 4 construction.
Race 10 – Malibu Stakes (Grade 1) – 1540 Yards Dirt – 5:49 PM WIN + TRIFECTA ($25.50)
Win: Barnes (9) – 55% confidence
Place: Goal Oriented (10) – 27% confidence🥇
Show: Midland Money (5) – 27% confidence🥈
Alternative: Cornucopian (8) – 27% confidence🥉
Split Grade 1 opinion with Barnes solidly favored at 55% but three alternatives holding 27% confidence each. Baffert barn dominates field with multiple entries, creating stable advantage angle. Cornucopian noted as Baffert's best horse at distance with Prat up. Goal Oriented projected to get excellent trip with recent blinker removal and improved form. Midland Money carries morning-line overlay designation suggesting market inefficiency. Expert analyst characterizes race as “Barnes versus Cornucopian faceoff” despite Barnes' statistical edge. High place/show variance (27% each for three horses) creates significant exotic value opportunities. Grade 1 stakes environment supports concentrated top-four finishing probability.
Race 11 – American Oaks (Grade 1) – 1.25 Miles Turf – 6:20 PM
Win: Will Then (2) – 45% confidence🥉
Place: Cliffs (3) – 27% confidence🥈
Show: Ribbons (11) – 18% confidence
Alternative: Atsila (10) – 27% confidence
Competitive Grade 1 filly race features split expert opinion with Will Then representing soft consensus (45%) despite “hard to split top two” analyst commentary. Cliffs featured in SportsLine specialized Pick 3 prediction with Gene Menez designation noting “trainer usually has female turf horse emerge year-end.” Atsila carries strong Group 1 form credentials from alternate analyst valuations. Ribbons' two-win record from five attempts noted as “real danger” designation. Multiple analysts emphasize distance debut angles for various entrants. High place/show variance typical of tight Grade 1 field. Will Then overlay potential given 45% consensus in championship-level competition.
RECOMMENDED EXOTIC PLAYS BY RACE
Race 1 Exacta Construction around Ramayana as primary win choice with Chair's Coin back-and-forth shows strong consensus pairing potential. Improbable U creates value addition to exacta wheels. Secondary wheel option: Ramayana-Improbable U box with Chair's Coin, Luckiest additions.
Race 2 Exacta/Trifecta Winston Ave-Newton pairing shows overwhelming analyst backing for top two. Trifecta candidates Secured Freedom, Plagarist, Captain Shreve each receive specific analyst support, creating multiple three-horse combinations at acceptable odds likely. Recommend Winston Ave to Newton with three-horse show combinations.
Race 3 Trifecta Runamileinmyshoes consensus pick presents base for multiple three-horse trifecta combinations. Corporal Violette “live value” designation and speed option Delightful Laura create balanced structural approach. Build trifecta wheels around Runamileinmyshoes win with Corporal Violette, Candy Bar, Delightful Laura, Toes showing combinations.
Race 4 Exacta/Superfecta Rizzleberry Rose as consensus win with place/show opinion splits (Diva Cat/Wishtheyallcouldbe place, Miss Practical show) creates exacta box value. Superfecta angles using Rizzleberry Rose, Diva Cat, Wishtheyallcouldbe, Clubhouse Bride, Miss Practical combinations capture multiple analyst selections at reasonable ticket cost.
Race 5 Exacta (Limited Value) High Namaron consensus (73%) and clear Friendly Confines place positioning (45%) create straightforward Namaron-Friendly Confines exacta pairing. Limited secondary structure due to concentrated opinion. Tempus Volat upset overlay potential for exotic wheels only.
Race 6 Exacta (Concentrated) Nysos-Nevada Beach pairing represents consensus structure with 82% and 45% respective confidence levels. Limited exotic value due to overwhelming top-two backing. Show angles on Bartholdy offer minimal additional construction value given 18% confidence. Recommend straight exacta play rather than complex wheels.
Race 7 Trifecta Anmer Hall consensus win with split place opinion (Mucho Del Oro primary) and Proof He Rides show creates trifecta structure. Winning Patriot represents additional place/show option. Recommend Anmer Hall to Mucho Del Oro to (Proof He Rides, Winning Patriot, Mescalero) combinations.
Race 8 Superfecta (High Value) Formula Rossa consensus (45%) weak for Grade 1, creating opportunity for balanced exotic construction. Recommend superfecta combinations: Formula Rossa, Five G, Usha over Magnificat, Artisma, Her Laugh, and secondary wheel: Five G, Usha over Formula Rossa, Magnificat with Artisma, Her Laugh additions. Multiple analyst selections create price-efficient superfecta structures.
Race 9 Exacta/Pick 3 (Grade 3 Base) Stay Hot consensus (73%) establishes clear base for Pick 3 construction spanning Races 9-11. Exacta angles with Cabo Spirit (27% place consensus) show solid backing. Recommend Stay Hot-Cabo Spirit exacta paired with remaining Pick 3 legs for late-pick opportunities.
Race 10 Exacta/Trifecta (Balanced) Split four-way opinion (Barnes 55%, Goal Oriented/Cornucopian/Midland Money 27% each) creates balanced exotic construction. Recommend trifecta combinations: Barnes over (Goal Oriented, Cornucopian, Midland Money) with two-horse showdowns in back half. Three-way trifecta wheels capture multiple analyst valuations.
Race 11 Trifecta (Grade 1 Closer) Will Then (45%) and Cliffs (27%) form consensus structure with Atsila/Ribbons alternatives. Recommend trifecta boxes: (Will Then, Atsila, Cliffs) to (Cliffs, Ribbons, As Catch Can) combinations capturing split expert opinion. Distance debuts and trainer angle on Cliffs support multi-horse trifecta structure as race-closing wager.
Pick 4/Pick 5 Structures: Races 7-10 alignment shows strong consensus on Anmer Hall (64%), formula-supported Race 8 selections, Stay Hot (73%), and Barnes (55%) providing four-leg foundation with balanced exotic potential. Late Pick 3 (Races 9-11) features Stay Hot (73%) consensus base with competitive Grade 1 closers creating varied finish scenarios.
VALUE PLAY OBSERVATIONS
Race 1 Overlay Opportunities Improbable U appears underlaid in market relative to 36% analyst consensus on win selection. Morning-line odds likely to exceed trainer credentials given placement form history. Chair's Coin similarly offers underlaid position on 36% consensus across multiple analyst frameworks. Luckiest represents pure overlay candidate with only 27% consensus supporting longshot-range morning line.
Race 2 Winston Ave Underlaid Despite 73% analyst consensus—highest non-stakes backing—Winston Ave likely to be morning-line favorite with potentially generous show odds. FanDuel shows Newton at 5-2 with multiple analysts backing, suggesting market recognizes barn consistency. Plagarist represents overlay value at 10-1 morning line with limited analyst backing (9% consensus).
Race 3 Value in Longshots Corporal Violette “live value longshot” designation from quality specialists suggests market overlays longshot status despite 36% consensus win backing and 27% place consensus. Candy Bar morning-line odds likely overlaid given three-analyst support and race competitiveness. Delightful Laura speed threat projected as single-digit morning line despite 18% consensus.
Race 4 Diva Cat Underlaid Despite 27% place consensus and blinker addition angle, Diva Cat appears underlaid relative to Baffert barn form patterns and specific trainer angle recognition. Wishtheyallcouldbe class-drop angle receives 27% win consensus but likely overlaid given recent poor effort and negative market memory. Exacta angles favor Rizzleberry Rose-Diva Cat combinations over consensus valuations.
Race 5 Namaron Underlaid Despite 73% analyst consensus and strong form, Grade 2 stakes environment suggests Namaron underlaid as consensus pick. Friendly Confines place consensus (45%) carries overlay positioning given Grade 1 experience edge. Tempus Volat watch designation from quality sources suggests 9-2 morning line undervalues upset potential.
Race 6 Nysos Underlaid (Best Bet) Remarkable 82% analyst consensus on Nysos combined with Grade 2 stakes environment suggests morning-line favorite undertones Dominance. Four straight wins and track record justify consensus, but betting volume likely compresses place odds on Nevada Beach (45%) relative to form analysis. Show angle on Bartholdy represents pure overlay at morning line odds.
Race 7 Anmer Hall Value Play 64% consensus on Anmer Hall as tune-up horse for graded competition suggests possible underlaid position on morning line. Mucho Del Oro (36% consensus) represents balanced value with downhill course specialist credentials. Proof He Rides (27% consensus) Mullins claim angle carries overlay potential on 10-1 morning line absent specialized knowledge.
Race 8 Formula Rossa Overlay Low 45% Grade 1 consensus suggests Formula Rossa potentially overlaid as morning favorite. Five G (36% consensus) with 39-week layoff likely overlaid for Grade 1. Usha (27%) and Magnificat (27%) combined 54% alternative backing creates meaningful variance. Grade 1 field depth with split opinion suggests Show picks heavily overlaid.
Race 9 Stay Hot Underlaid Dominant 73% analyst consensus combined with track specialist (three Santa Anita wins) suggests possible underlaid morning-line chalk. Cabo Spirit (27% consensus) carries overlay designation despite “must-use exotic” specialist backing and 8-1 morning line. Astronomer (27% consensus) appears underlaid with 0-for-6 Santa Anita record limitation suppressing market valuation.
Race 10 Barnes Underlaid Value 55% Grade 1 consensus suggests Barnes underlaid on morning line despite solid backing. Goal Oriented (27%) and Cornucopian (27%) combined show market divided between multiple Baffert alternatives, creating relative value on Cornucopian with “best horse at distance” designation. Midland Money (27%) carries overlay positioning as market overcounts recent favorite disappointment.
Race 11 Will Then Underlaid 45% Grade 1 consensus appears underlaid relative to probable morning-line favoritism. Cliffs (27% consensus) receives SportsLine specialist backing suggesting market undervalues trainer angle and distance consideration. Atsila (27%) Group 1 form credentials carry overlay potential against morning-line positioning absent specialized knowledge.
OVERALL WAGERING STRATEGY
Strongest Consensus Races The card features three races commanding 70%+ win confidence: Namaron (73% in Race 5 Grade 2), Nysos (82% in Race 6 Grade 2), and Stay Hot (73% in Race 9 Grade 3). These three establish natural Pick 3/Pick 4 anchors due to dominant analyst agreement. Nysos race represents highest chalk confidence level potentially carrying underlaid positioning given overwhelming backing. Namaron and Stay Hot represent more balanced value profiles with graded stakes competition justifying 70%+ levels.
Split-Opinion Races Requiring Exotic Strategy Races 8 (La Brea Grade 1), 10 (Malibu Grade 1), and 11 (American Oaks Grade 1) feature the three competitive Grade 1 tests, each hosting four-way (or greater) splits in expert opinion at 27-45% confidence levels. Formula Rossa (45%) in Race 8 remains weakest Grade 1 consensus, creating meaningful superfecta opportunity. Race 10 Barnes (55%) represents single strongest Grade 1 consensus but maintains 27% competition from Goal Oriented and Cornucopian. Race 11 Will Then (45%) Grade 1 finale features softest win consensus, requiring trifecta-minimum exotic structures.
Multi-Race Sequences for Pick Bets Races 6-9 present four consecutive races with dominant single-race consensus: Nysos (82%), Namaron (73% prior), Stay Hot (73%), suggesting natural Pick 4 construction spanning through closing Grade 3 stakes. Confidence concentration in top selections (82/73/73/73) reduces field variance, limiting exotic payoff potential but supporting strong probability execution. Recommend straight Pick 4 structuring (Nysos-single, Namaron-single, Stay Hot-single, Cabo Spirit/Astronomer two-horse back) as cost-efficient execution for solid probability races.
Races 9-11 establish late Pick 3 closing sequence featuring Stay Hot (73% Grade 3 consensus), Barnes (55% Grade 1 split), and Will Then (45% Grade 1 split). This structure supports multiple-variation approach: primary ticket emphasizing consensus selections (Stay Hot-Barnes-Will Then single) with secondary ticket widening Grade 1 legs (Stay Hot with multiple Barnes/Cornucopian/Goal Oriented-Will Then/Cliffs/Atsila combinations). Late Pick 3 minimum ($1) and 15% takeout create attractive risk-reward for variance management.
Exotic Value Opportunities and Structural Approaches Races featuring 40-50% win consensus (Race 2 Winston Ave 73% non-stakes, Race 4 Rizzleberry Rose 55%, Race 7 Anmer Hall 64%) represent excellent exacta targets where consensus concentration justifies wheels rather than boxes. Winston Ave-Newton exacta (73%-45% pairing) carries excellent probability with potential show variance. Anmer Hall-Mucho Del Oro (64%-36%) exacta captures two-horse analyst consensus. These races support lower-cost ticket structures given dominant top-two alignment.
Races displaying 27-36% place/show consensus splits (Race 1, Race 3, Race 8, Race 10, Race 11) justify superfecta/trifecta construction capturing multiple analyst selections at efficient ticket costs. Race 8 superfecta particularly attractive: Formula Rossa single to (Five G, Usha) to (Magnificat, Artisma, Her Laugh) captures analyst variance while maintaining manageable ticket volume. Race 10 trifecta with four-way consensus opinion supports three-horse trifecta boxes efficiently deploying capital across Baffert multiple entries.
Environmental and Track Condition Considerations Santa Anita turf/dirt surface conditions for December 28 (59°F, firm turf expected, fast dirt track condition) align with analyst references to form horses and trainer expertise. Six graded stakes races (Races 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11) represent 55% of card, creating compressed quality field environment where trainer expertise and form cycling dominate predictability. Turf specialists (Anmer Hall, Runamileinmyshoes in Route race contexts) show elevated consensus, reflecting track advantages. Baffert barn demonstrates field dominance across multiple races (entries in Races 1, 2, 4, 6, 7, 8, 10), creating barn-based overlay/underlaid analysis opportunities.
Key Takeaways for Execution Primary strategic recommendation emphasizes Pick 3/Pick 4 construction spanning consensus races (6-9 or 9-11 sequences) with trifecta/superfecta widening in Grade 1 closers. Win chalkiness concentration (Nysos 82%, Namaron 73%, Stay Hot 73%) creates probability-heavy ticket structure suitable for short-price play while maintaining conservative bankroll deployment. Race 8 (La Brea Grade 1) represents premium exotic opportunity due to Formula Rossa weak consensus (45%), creating 3-4-5 horse trifecta/superfecta combinations capturing analyst variance at manageable cost.
Secondary strategy targets exacta value in 55-73% win consensus races (Winston Ave, Rizzleberry Rose, Anmer Hall) where top-two analyst agreement justifies straight exacta plays over boxes, compressing ticket costs while maintaining high probability execution. Split-opinion Grade 1 races (particularly Race 10 with three 27% consensus alternatives to 55% Barnes) justify trifecta wheels capturing Baffert barn alternatives (Cornucopian, Goal Oriented) as cost-efficient tournament strategies.
Overlaid value presents strongest opportunity in Race 1 (Improbable U, Chair's Coin show position), Race 3 (Corporal Violette value longshot), Race 4 (Diva Cat place), and Race 9 (Astronomer, Cabo Spirit Grade 3 dynamics). Underlaid chalk concentrated in Grade 1 closers (Races 8, 10, 11) suggests conservative play positioning on top consensus selections with exact structures rather than overlapping wagering.
This Santa Anita opening day card balances strong consensus races (supporting probability-weighted Pick 4 structures) with Grade 1 competitive depth (supporting exotic trifecta/superfecta creativity). Optimal approach emphasizes late-card Pick 3 closing structure capturing Stay Hot dominance into Grade 1 variance, combined with exacta targeting early card consensus races for value capture.
