Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!
Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony’s AI Picks.
Race 1 Claiming 1 Mile 40 Yards Dirt Purse 26,500
Win: JASSAI (6) – 71% confidence
Place: ARIANA VALENTINA (1) – 14% confidence
Show: MIA’S ANGEL (3) – 14% confidence
Alternative: CHACARERA (5) – 0% confidence
Race Notes: The first race of the card shows a very heavy leaning toward the analyst choice in the top spot. While most analysts agree on the winner, there is significant disagreement regarding the minor placings, suggesting that the early pace could shuffle the field late.
Race 2 Starter Optional Claiming 1 Mile 40 Yards Dirt Purse 28,000
Win: SWEET NOLA (6) – 57% confidence
Place: CASTAGNA (3) – 29% confidence
Show: ANGELAS PARTY GIRL (5) – 14% confidence
Alternative: BLUE FASHION (7) – 0% confidence
Race Notes: Analysts are reasonably aligned on the favorite here, though several notes suggest that the drop in class for some contenders makes this a more competitive heat than it appears on paper. The “Alternative” pick received secondary support across multiple handicapping reports.
Race 3 Claiming 5 Furlongs 110 Yards Dirt Purse 20,500
Win: MEGAN’S HONOR (8) – 83% confidence
Place: HAPPY INSTEAD (7) – 17% confidence
Show: AL AMEEQ (2) – 0% confidence
Alternative: MR. SQUEAKY WHEELS (1) – 0% confidence
Race Notes: This represents the strongest consensus on the entire card. Nearly every analyst has landed on the same horse for the win, indicating a high degree of confidence in the form of the top selection.
Race 4 Claiming 6 Furlongs Dirt Purse 21,000
Win: OPPOSITE THE CROWD (5) – 67% confidence
Place: OLGA (1) – 17% confidence
Show: LADY IN HEELS (3) – 17% confidence
Alternative: FOXY LADY (4) – 0% confidence
Race Notes: A two-horse battle is anticipated by analysts between the favorite and the primary challenger. Most analysts prefer the speed of the favorite at this distance, though several noted that the inside draw for the place selection could prove advantageous.
Race 5 Claiming 1 Mile Turf Purse 32,500
Win: JES SEE ME (5) – 67% confidence
Place: WISE WORDS (1) – 17% confidence
Show: ROSCOMMON (4) – 17% confidence
Alternative: HIGH YIELD HUNK (2) – 0% confidence
Race Notes: Turf races often provide more variance, yet analysts are surprisingly unified here. The confidence in the top selection stems from a strong recent workout and a favorable jockey assignment.
Race 6 Claiming 7 Furlongs Dirt Purse 26,500
Win: COALMINER’S KITTEN (2) – 50% confidence
Place: SMART STRIKER (4) – 33% confidence
Show: JUST RELAX (5) – 17% confidence
Alternative: AMERICAN UNITY (6) – 0% confidence
Race Notes: This race presents a split opinion among analysts. While half the group favors the inside speed, a significant portion believes the mid-pack closer has the best chance of tracking down the leader in the final furlong.
Race 7 Claiming 6 Furlongs Dirt Purse 24,000
Win: RIDING A DREAM (6) – 100% confidence
Place: MORNING CUP (7) – 0% confidence
Show: ELUSIVE D’ORO (5) – 0% confidence
Alternative: PAYNTED WARRIOR (3) – 0% confidence
Race Notes: This race features a unanimous selection for the win. Analysts are so convinced of this outcome that every single source provided has the same horse on top, making it a potential “single” for multi-race exotic wagers.
Race 8 Claiming 6 1/2 Furlongs Dirt Purse 20,500
Win: TAPRIXIE (2) – 67% confidence
Place: GO GO STAR (1) – 17% confidence
Show: HEAVENS EXPRESS (6) – 17% confidence
Alternative: PADRINO’S GOLD (7) – 0% confidence
Race Notes: Analysts are wary of the morning line favorite here, with several looking toward the second choice as the more reliable option. The confidence percentage reflects a consolidation of opinion around the class-dropping contender.
Race 9 Claiming 1 Mile Turf Purse 23,800
Win: COCKTAIL KISSES (9) – 71% confidence
Place: NASHVILLE SLEW (1) – 14% confidence
Show: JERSEY JOYCE (11) – 14% confidence
Alternative: MIDWAY VOW (4) – 0% confidence
Race Notes: The finale features another strong favorite, though the wide variety of “Alternative” and “Show” selections suggests that the trifecta and superfecta could pay well if the favorite falters. One analyst specifically highlighted a longshot with tactical speed.
Recommended Exotic Plays by Race
Race 1: Analysts suggest focusing on an Exacta Box featuring JASSAI (6) and ARIANA VALENTINA (1). For those looking for more coverage, a Trifecta using JASSAI (6) on top of MIA’S ANGEL (3) and CROSSATI (4) is a professional recommendation.
Race 2: A Daily Double starting with SWEET NOLA (6) into the strong consensus in Race 3 is highly recommended. For the race itself, an Exacta Part-Wheel using SWEET NOLA (6) with CASTAGNA (3) and BLUE FASHION (7) covers the most likely scenarios.
Race 3: Given the 83% confidence in MEGAN’S HONOR (8), analysts view this as an ideal race to use the favorite as a “key” in a Trifecta: 8 over 1, 2, 7 over 1, 2, 7. This allows for a relatively inexpensive play with high probability.
Race 4: Analysts recommend a Superfecta play here, keying OPPOSITE THE CROWD (5) on top of OLGA (1), LADY IN HEELS (3), and FOXY LADY (4). The tactical speed of the 5 horse should allow it to control the pace from the start.
Race 5: A Pick 3 sequence beginning in this race is suggested, as analysts have high confidence in the top selections for Races 5 and 7. For Race 5 specifically, an Exacta Box with JES SEE ME (5) and WISE WORDS (1) is the preferred structure.
Race 6: This is the first race where analysts recommend a broader “spread” in exotic wagers. An Exacta Box using COALMINER’S KITTEN (2), SMART STRIKER (4), and JUST RELAX (5) is advised to capture the value in a race with divided opinions.
Race 7: With 100% consensus on RIDING A DREAM (6), analysts suggest this horse be used as a “lone” in all multi-race wagers (Pick 3, Pick 4, Pick 5). For single-race betting, a cold Trifecta RIDING A DREAM (6) / MORNING CUP (7) / ELUSIVE D’ORO (5) is the primary recommendation.
Race 8: Analysts see value in an Exacta Box with TAPRIXIE (2) and GO GO STAR (1). If the morning line favorite continues to drift in the betting, a win bet on the consensus top choice is also a sound strategic move.
Race 9: To close out the card, analysts recommend a Trifecta Wheel: COCKTAIL KISSES (9) over MIDWAY VOW (4) and PROMAJA (6) over the field. This protects against a longshot slipping into the third spot in what is traditionally a volatile turf finale.
Value Play Observations
The most significant value opportunity on the card appears in Race 9 with NASHVILLE SLEW (1). While COCKTAIL KISSES (9) is the heavy consensus favorite, one analyst has identified the 1 horse as a primary threat at 8-1 morning line odds. If NASHVILLE SLEW (1) maintains these odds, it represents a substantial overlay compared to the professional assessment of its winning probability.
Conversely, CHACARERA (5) in Race 1 is identified as a potential underlay. While appearing in several secondary analyst selections, its morning line odds are relatively low compared to the overwhelming consensus for JASSAI (6). Bettors may find better value by looking elsewhere for the minor placings in the early Daily Double.
In Race 6, JUST RELAX (5) is highlighted as a sleeper. Despite the split consensus between the 2 and 4 horses, several analysts believe the 5 horse is currently overlooked by the public. At 5-2 or better, this horse provides an excellent value alternative to the two favorites who are likely to be over-bet.
Overall Wagering Strategy
The racing program at Tampa Bay Downs for February 18, 2026, presents a card dominated by several high-confidence favorites, making it an ideal day for multi-race exotic construction rather than individual win betting. The strongest consensus races occur in the middle and late stages of the card, specifically Race 3 and Race 7. In Race 3, MEGAN’S HONOR (8) commands an 83% confidence rating, while RIDING A DREAM (6) in Race 7 achieves a rare 100% consensus among all surveyed analysts. These two runners should serve as the “anchors” for any Pick 4 or Pick 5 tickets, allowing bettors to spread their investments more broadly in the more competitive heats.
A notable split-opinion race occurs in Race 6, where analyst sentiment is divided between COALMINER’S KITTEN (2) and SMART STRIKER (4). This analytical tension suggests a race with significant pace volatility. Because opinion is so evenly divided, this is a prime opportunity for bettors to utilize “Dutching” strategies—betting on both top contenders to ensure a profit if either prevails—or using both horses on all multi-race tickets to avoid an early exit from a Pick sequence. The variance here is high enough that ignoring either of the top two choices could be a costly mistake for horizontal bettors.
Multi-race sequences are particularly attractive today, especially the Pick 4 starting in Race 6 and ending in Race 9. With a 100% consensus “single” available in Race 7 and a very strong 71% favorite in Race 9, the volatility of the sequence is localized to the first and third legs. By using multiple horses in Race 6 and Race 8 while “singling” the favorites in the other two legs, bettors can maintain high coverage while keeping the total ticket cost manageable. This structured approach leverages the analyst consensus to minimize risk in the most predictable segments of the afternoon.
Environmental factors at the track should be monitored closely, as the 72-degree weather and consistent dirt surface favor tactical speed in the shorter sprints. Analysts have repeatedly pointed toward horses with early “gate speed” in the 6-furlong events. Key takeaways for today include prioritizing the consensus favorites in the second half of the card and looking for value overlays in the turf finale, where the large field size typically creates pricing inefficiencies. Bettors should focus their capital on the Pick 3 and Pick 4 sequences that utilize the standout favorites in Races 3, 7, and 9.
