Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!
Don’t forget Pick Pony’s Expert Picks, AI Picks, and Past Performance Sheets/Racing Forms!
The Pick Pony Handicapper's Report is published daily and provides analysis of all races on the card. A Pick Pony analyst prepares the report, so selections may differ from the Pick Pony Expert Picks, which are based on the consensus of all Pick Pony analysts.
Charles Town kicks off the weekend with an eight-race card that offers diverse wagering opportunities across claiming, allowance, and allowance optional claiming conditions. The evening program features competitive fields with trainer Anthony Farrior positioned strongly across multiple races alongside leading connections including Jeff Runco and Ronney Brown. According to the scratch report, several horses have been withdrawn from competition including Empire's Treat, Impetus Echo, Talbot Heirloom, Rainbowsnsunshine, Paymengold, Love and Kisses, Buddy Buddy, and In the Chase due to stewards and veterinarian actions.
Weather and Track Conditions
The forecast for Charles Town on January 9 shows temperatures ranging from approximately 49°F high to 39°F low. Current track conditions are reported as fast dirt, typical for this time of year at the West Virginia oval. The track has been handling well throughout the early January meet with no significant weather concerns anticipated for the evening card. Trainers have been working horses consistently on the surface, suggesting confidence in racing conditions.
Track Bias and Post Position Analysis
Charles Town's configuration features a tight six-furlong oval with three turns for longer distances. Historical data from the 2026 meet indicates that sprint races at 4.5 furlongs show a 58% wire-to-wire success rate, heavily favoring early speed. Inside posts at positions one and two produce win percentages of 15.8% and 15.9% respectively in sprint races. For routes at 6.5 furlongs and beyond, the bias shifts toward stalkers and closers, with outside posts showing improved performance as the track favors horses making sustained moves. When track conditions are fast, as expected tonight, frontrunners maintain significant advantages in sprints while routes remain more tactical.
Race 1 – Charles Town – Friday, January 9, 2026
Post Time: 7:00 PM EST
Distance: 1 1/16 Miles Dirt
Class: Claiming $5,000
Purse: $14,100
Pace Analysis
This route will feature moderate early fractions with several horses capable of contesting the lead. Pure Magic Girl and Amorica have shown early tactical speed in past performances while Queen of Soul also demonstrates forward tendencies. The pace scenario should be honest but not suicidal, setting up potential for closers and sustained runners to make an impact through the stretch.
Key Contenders
Pure Magic Girl draws the rail for trainer Pedro Nazario and jockey Paul Luna. The five-year-old mare drops into a claiming spot after competing at higher levels and possesses tactical speed to secure favorable position. Her ability to rate off the pace gives her multiple trip options.
Amorica represents trainer Jesus Rodriguez with regular pilot Shirley Esther Yancapallo Gomocio. This five-year-old mare has demonstrated consistency at Charles Town and fits the class level. Her mid-pack running style positions her well for the route distance.
Queen of Soul ships from the Scott Lane barn with Justin Lewis riding. This four-year-old filly shows recent positive form and the Lane/Lewis combination produces solid results at the meet.
Secondary Choices
Beaches and Pearls for trainer Kent Knudsen represents a player in this field based on recent workouts. The four-year-old filly draws post two with J.D. Acosta, a rider showing 13% wins and 36% in-the-money finishes to start 2026.
Slanderous from the Kevin Joy barn merits consideration as a pace presser who could benefit if the early tempo becomes contested.
Betting Strategy
This race presents value opportunities with multiple contenders at reasonable odds. Key Pure Magic Girl on top in exactas and trifectas while using Amorica, Queen of Soul, and Beaches and Pearls underneath. A straight exacta box of the top four provides solid coverage.
Selections
Win: Pure Magic Girl
Place: Amorica
Show: Queen of Soul
Race 2 – Charles Town – Friday, January 9, 2026
Post Time: 7:32 PM EST
Distance: 4 1/2 Furlongs Dirt
Class: Allowance
Purse: $31,700
Pace Analysis
The sprint distance combined with the allowance conditions creates a scenario where early speed will be paramount. Dixie Yodeler and Party Time For Me both demonstrate fast leader credentials. This should produce contested fractions that may set up late runners, though the historical 58% wire success rate at this distance favors those positioned forwardly.
Key Contenders
Howler represents new trainer Cathal Lynch making rare Charles Town appearances with Angel Cruz aboard. The four-year-old filly ships from Laurel where she recorded consecutive runner-up finishes in allowance company at 5.5 furlongs. Cruz leads all riders in percentage of purse earned and brings 21% wins with 49% in-the-money statistics. Howler's fastest closer running style gives her tactical advantages if the pace becomes contested.
Party Time For Me from the Anthony Grigsby barn with Joe Stokes riding represents the main danger. She won her most recent start at this distance and class level by open lengths. Grigsby connects at 13% with 48% in-the-money while the mare demonstrates fast leader credentials.
Allformenoneforyou trains with Cynthia McKee and draws Reshawn Latchman. This four-year-old filly won last out at the distance and possesses a 43% career win rate from seven starts. Latchman's 22% wins and 58% in-the-money statistics make this combination formidable.
Secondary Choices
Dixie Yodeler brings extensive experience with 40 career starts for trainer Russell Davis. Her recent Charles Town victory at the distance makes her competitive despite the 8% career win rate. The mare's fast leader style positions her prominently early.
Seven Natty Patty for trainer Ronney Brown with Moises Santaella represents a closer who could benefit from pace dynamics. Brown leads all trainers at the meet with strong statistics while Santaella won three of 12 mounts opening weekend.
Betting Strategy
Howler represents the value play as a shipper with Angel Cruz making rare Charles Town appearances. Use her on top in exactas over Party Time For Me, Allformenoneforyou, and Dixie Yodeler. A trifecta key with Howler on top and spreading the others provides solid coverage of the race dynamics.
Selections
Win: Howler
Place: Party Time For Me
Show: Allformenoneforyou
Race 3 – Charles Town – Friday, January 9, 2026
Post Time: 8:02 PM EST
Distance: 7 Furlongs Dirt
Class: Allowance
Purse: $31,700
Pace Analysis
The seven-furlong distance creates tactical opportunities for multiple running styles. Night Quest and Magic Moon Spell demonstrate early tactical speed while several closers including Avril and Mun Mun Can Run will be positioned to strike late. The pace should be moderate with honest fractions setting up for sustained moves through the stretch.
Key Contenders
Magic Moon Spell graduated impressively in maiden special weight company on December 11 for trainer Gary Williams Jr. with Arnaldo Bocachica aboard. The four-year-old Thousand Words filly scored by dominant margins in her debut and now steps into allowance conditions. Williams operates at 23% wins with Charles Town runners while Bocachica captured his eighth consecutive riding title with 196 wins in 2025. This combination represents the meet's most potent force.
Night Quest from the Cathal Lynch barn with Angel Cruz provides main opposition. The five-year-old mare finished second in her most recent outing and demonstrates tactical speed to secure favorable position. Lynch's limited Charles Town starts bring quality over quantity.
Cheese N Crackers trains with Kelly Deiter and draws Edgar Villasmil. This four-year-old filly carries topweight at 124 pounds, indicating connections' confidence in her ability. Deiter operates successfully at the meet and the filly's form suggests competitiveness at this level.
Secondary Choices
Last of My Kind for trainer Kelly Deiter with Jomar Torres merits consideration as a pace factor. The four-year-old filly fits the allowance conditions and Deiter's strong meet statistics support her chances.
Mamawasagogogirl from the Cynthia McKee barn with Reshawn Latchman represents a closer who benefits from contested pace scenarios. McKee's 18% wins and Latchman's 22% statistics make this pairing dangerous.
Betting Strategy
Magic Moon Spell figures as a short-priced favorite but the Bocachica/Williams combination justifies support. Key her on top in exactas and trifectas while using Night Quest, Cheese N Crackers, and the Deiter runners underneath. A straight win bet on Magic Moon Spell combines with exacta coverage.
Selections
Win: Magic Moon Spell
Place: Night Quest
Show: Cheese N Crackers
Race 4 – Charles Town – Friday, January 9, 2026
Post Time: 8:32 PM EST
Distance: 6 1/2 Furlongs Dirt
Class: Allowance Optional Claiming
Purse: $32,700
Pace Analysis
This West Virginia-bred allowance optional claiming sprint features experienced campaigners with varying running styles. Youthinkthatsfunny and Boss E Boogs should contest the early lead while closers position for late runs. The pace figures to be contested but manageable, allowing closers opportunities through the stretch.
Key Contenders
Youthinkthatsfunny represents the Anthony Farrior barn with Arnaldo Bocachica riding. This eight-year-old gelding brings proven Charles Town form and the Farrior/Bocachica combination operates at elite levels throughout the meet. Farrior led the track with the most wins in 2025 while maintaining placement precision. The gelding's experience at the distance and class level positions him favorably.
Social Chic from the Anthony Farrior barn provides a second entry with J.D. Acosta. The eight-year-old gelding has compiled extensive earnings and fits the optional claiming conditions. Having multiple Farrior runners indicates barn confidence in this spot.
Boss E Boogs trains with Tabitha Wilhelm and brings consistent form to the race. The eight-year-old gelding's recent performances suggest competitiveness at this claiming level.
Secondary Choices
Paymengold was scratched by stewards according to the official scratch report. This eliminates a potential contender from handicapping consideration.
Robbielikeshim for trainer Jeff Runco with Moises Santaella represents a longshot possibility. Runco's 32% wins at the meet and strong placement record make any of his runners worth including on tickets.
Betting Strategy
The Farrior barn dominating this race with two entries creates exacta opportunities. Key Youthinkthatsfunny on top with Social Chic, Boss E Boogs, and Robbielikeshim underneath. A trifecta using both Farrior horses in multiple positions maximizes coverage of the likely outcome.
Selections
Win: Youthinkthatsfunny
Place: Social Chic
Show: Boss E Boogs
Race 5 – Charles Town – Friday, January 9, 2026
Post Time: 9:02 PM EST
Distance: 6 1/2 Furlongs Dirt
Class: Claiming $10,000
Purse: $18,200
Pace Analysis
This claiming sprint features multiple speed horses including Slewing, Lucky Bop, and Climate Change. The contested early pace should create opportunities for closers while also testing the stamina of early leaders. The pace scenario favors horses with tactical speed who can rate behind the dueling frontrunners.
Key Contenders
Climate Change trains with Anthony Farrior and draws Arnaldo Bocachica. This four-year-old filly carries topweight at 126 pounds and represents the meet's leading connections. Farrior's precision placement and Bocachica's riding excellence make this pairing formidable despite the outside post nine.
Slewing from the Jamie Collyer barn with Alexis Rios-Conde Jr. brings veteran experience. The eight-year-old mare carries topweight and recent form suggests competitiveness at this claiming level.
Lucky Bop for trainer Lewis Craig with Julio Jorge represents a mare with tactical speed. The six-year-old fits the claiming conditions and should secure favorable position early.
Secondary Choices
Love and Kisses was scratched by stewards according to the official report, removing a potential contender from consideration.
Cicatriz from the Timothy Shanley barn with Justin Lewis offers value at longer odds. Shanley operates at 11% wins with Charles Town runners while Lewis brings familiarity with the track.
Look Ahead for trainer Timothy Shanley with Moises Santaella provides Shanley with two chances in the race. Santaella's 25% wins opening weekend and strong form throughout 2025 support this runner.
Betting Strategy
Climate Change represents the value despite short odds given the Farrior/Bocachica combination's dominance. Key her on top in exactas and trifectas while spreading Slewing, Lucky Bop, Cicatriz, and Look Ahead underneath. The contested pace creates exacta and trifecta value with multiple horses capable of hitting the board.
Selections
Win: Climate Change
Place: Slewing
Show: Lucky Bop
Race 6 – Charles Town – Friday, January 9, 2026
Post Time: 9:32 PM EST
Distance: 7 Furlongs Dirt
Class: Claiming $5,000
Purse: $14,600
Pace Analysis
This bottom-level claiming route features twelve horses with varying degrees of ability and consistency. Valore and Smooth Rico demonstrate early speed while several closers will position for late runs. The large field and low claiming price create chaotic pace scenarios that favor horses with tactical versatility and experienced riders.
Key Contenders
Little Bit Risky for trainer Tyler Shanley with Jomar Torres represents a four-year-old gelding with improving form. The connections show promise and the horse's recent performances suggest readiness for this claiming level.
Valore from the Charles DeMario barn with Inoel Beato brings tactical speed to the race. The five-year-old gelding carries topweight at 126 pounds and fits the class level based on recent efforts.
Solomons Gold trains with Anthony Farrior and draws J.D. Acosta. The six-year-old gelding represents the meet's leading trainer despite being entered at the lowest claiming level. Farrior's placement precision suggests this horse fits the conditions.
Secondary Choices
Buddy Buddy was scratched by stewards according to the official report. This removes a potential contender from handicapping analysis.
Feast for trainer Keith Brown with Reshawn Latchman offers value as a nine-year-old gelding with extensive experience. Latchman's 22% wins and strong riding statistics make him capable of guiding older horses to victories.
Strive for Stride from the Timothy Shanley barn with Justin Lewis brings Lewis/Shanley combination that operates consistently at the meet.
Betting Strategy
The large field and low claiming level create chaos that favors spreading tickets widely. Use Little Bit Risky, Valore, Solomons Gold, and Feast in various exacta and trifecta combinations. The race presents value opportunities if focusing on experienced riders capable of navigating the crowded field. A trifecta box of the top selections provides solid coverage.
Selections
Win: Little Bit Risky
Place: Valore
Show: Solomons Gold
Race 7 – Charles Town – Friday, January 9, 2026
Post Time: 10:02 PM EST
Distance: 6 1/2 Furlongs Dirt
Class: Allowance
Purse: $32,800
Pace Analysis
This allowance sprint features horses with tactical speed and closing ability. Dorado and Runaldo bring proven Charles Town form while several others demonstrate the ability to compete at this level. The pace should be contested but manageable with opportunities for sustained moves through the stretch.
Key Contenders
Runaldo represents the Jeff Runco barn with Arnaldo Bocachica. This six-year-old gelding captured the Sam Huff West Virginia Breeders Classic and the Randy Funkhouser Memorial Stakes in 2024, establishing himself as one of the state's premier runners. Named for the combination of trainer Runco and jockey Bocachica, this gelding embodies the partnership's success. Runco operates at 32% wins at Charles Town while Bocachica dominates the riding colony. The gelding carries topweight but possesses the class to overcome it.
Dorado from the Javier Contreras barn with Wesley Ho provides main opposition. The five-year-old horse won his most recent Charles Town start and demonstrates tactical speed to secure favorable position. Contreras operates successfully at the meet and Ho's riding abilities support this runner's chances.
In the Chase draws post six for trainer Michael Jones with J.D. Acosta. However, the official scratch report indicates this horse was scratched due to private veterinarian illness. This removes a potential contender from consideration.
Secondary Choices
Moonlit Notion for trainer Timothy Grams with Larry Reynolds represents an intriguing runner. The colt maintained an undefeated 5-for-5 record before his most recent start and competed in the Coin Collector Stakes. Grams operates at 20% wins while Reynolds brings 25% wins and 43% in-the-money statistics.
Wiffleball from the Timothy Kreiser barn with Angel Cruz offers value as a four-year-old gelding with improving form. Cruz's elite statistics throughout 2025 and early 2026 make him capable of guiding this runner to victory.
Betting Strategy
Runaldo represents the logical favorite given his proven stakes credentials and dominant connections. Key him on top in exactas and trifectas while using Dorado, Moonlit Notion, and Wiffleball underneath. The race presents value in exotic wagers while Runaldo merits win consideration despite potentially short odds.
Selections
Win: Runaldo
Place: Dorado
Show: Moonlit Notion
Race 8 – Charles Town – Friday, January 9, 2026
Post Time: 10:32 PM EST
Distance: 7 Furlongs Dirt
Class: Claiming $5,000
Purse: $14,600
Pace Analysis
The finale features thirteen horses competing at the bottom claiming level over seven furlongs. Multiple horses demonstrate early speed including Quebeck, Platinum Ghost, and Ray's Blue Wagon. The large field and low claiming price create unpredictable pace scenarios where experience and post position become critical factors. Closers positioning for late runs will need clear paths through the crowded field.
Key Contenders
Ray's Blue Wagon for trainer Bruce Kravets with Arnaldo Bocachica represents a four-year-old colt with improving form. Bocachica's ability to navigate large fields and secure favorable position makes him particularly valuable in chaotic claiming routes. The rail-skimming trips Bocachica engineers often produce victories in these circumstances.
Platinum Ghost trains with Kent Knudsen and draws Jomar Torres. The six-year-old gelding brings experience and recent form suggesting competitiveness at this claiming level. Torres demonstrates solid riding abilities throughout the meet.
Masterwork from the Javier Contreras barn with Juan Nunez represents the outside post one. The six-year-old gelding carries topweight and fits the claiming conditions based on recent performances.
Secondary Choices
Strasse for trainer Christopher Keller with Sunday Diaz Jr. offers value as a five-year-old gelding fitting the class level. Diaz operates at 21% wins with 33% in-the-money early in the meet.
Abuelo Paps from the James King barn with Justin Lewis brings veteran nine-year-old gelding experience. Lewis's familiarity with Charles Town and ability to ride tactical races support this runner.
Life Is Hard for trainer Julie Mathes with Gerald Almodovar represents an eight-year-old gelding with extensive racing experience. Almodovar scored an early-meet victory and demonstrates capable riding.
Betting Strategy
The thirteen-horse field creates chaos favoring experienced riders and inside posts. Key Ray's Blue Wagon on top given Bocachica's excellence in these scenarios. Spread Platinum Ghost, Masterwork, Strasse, and Abuelo Paps in exacta and trifecta positions underneath. Consider wider trifecta coverage given the field size and claiming level unpredictability. A straight win bet on Ray's Blue Wagon with exacta coverage provides solid approach.
Selections
Win: Ray's Blue Wagon
Place: Platinum Ghost
Show: Masterwork
Jockey Notes and Insights
Arnaldo Bocachica continues his dominance of the Charles Town riding colony, capturing his eighth consecutive title in 2025 with 196 wins from 598 mounts representing a 33% win rate. Opening the 2026 meet, Bocachica won twice from eight mounts during the first weekend. His partnership with trainer Anthony Farrior produces elite results with the combination winning at extraordinarily high rates. Bocachica excels at securing favorable position from any post and demonstrates tactical versatility across all distances. His rail-skimming ability in crowded fields makes him particularly effective in claiming routes.
Moises Santaella led all riders opening weekend with three wins from twelve mounts representing 25% strike rate. Santaella recorded 1.14 wins above expectations, indicating he outperformed the odds of his mounts. His apprentice allowance provides weight advantages while his riding maturity belies his experience level. Santaella excels on early speed horses and demonstrates patience when rating closers. His partnership with trainer Ronney Brown produces consistent results.
Angel Cruz makes limited Charles Town appearances but delivers elite results when riding at the West Virginia track. Cruz primarily rides in Maryland and brings 21% wins with 49% in-the-money statistics when competing at Charles Town. His tactical versatility and ability to adapt to different running styles make him particularly effective on shippers. Cruz leads all riders in percentage of purse earned during limited starts.
Justin Lewis operates at 9% wins with 35% in-the-money finishes early in the 2026 meet. His extensive Charles Town experience and familiarity with trainer combinations make him valuable on mid-level horses. Lewis demonstrates patience in routes and tactical awareness in sprints. His ability to secure position from inside posts creates advantages in competitive claiming races.
Reshawn Latchman recorded four wins from 26 mounts during the early 2024 season while operating 1.03 wins above expectations. His 22% wins and 58% in-the-money statistics through early 2026 demonstrate consistency. Latchman excels at rating horses off the pace and timing late moves. His partnership with trainer Cynthia McKee produces solid results across multiple racing levels.
Trainer Notes and Insights
Anthony Farrior dominated Charles Town racing in 2025, leading all trainers in wins while maintaining precision placement. Farrior operates at 31% wins with 52% second-place finishes and 62% in-the-money. His partnership with Arnaldo Bocachica represents the meet's most potent combination. Farrior excels at identifying proper class levels and timing horse readiness. His horses typically show sharp form and fitness. When Farrior enters horses at 2-1 or lower odds, victory rates exceed 70%, demonstrating public recognition of his barn's excellence.
Jeff Runco ranks among Charles Town's elite trainers with 32% wins and 48% second-place finishes representing 57% in-the-money. Runco captured his 5,000th career win during 2025 and operates with remarkable consistency across all class levels. His partnership with Bocachica produces exceptional results while his understanding of pace dynamics creates strategic advantages. Runco excels at developing young horses and maintaining older campaigners in competitive form.
Ronney Brown finished second to Farrior in wins during 2025 and opened the 2026 meet with four victories from nine starters during opening weekend. Brown operates at 37% wins with 58% second-place finishes representing 68% in-the-money. His partnership with Santaella creates value opportunities as the apprentice jockey provides weight advantages. Brown excels with fillies and mares while demonstrating tactical versatility across distances.
Timothy Shanley operates at 11% wins at Charles Town with 1,112 career starts at the track. His barn focuses on developing claiming-level horses and improving form through proper placement. Shanley's patience with horses creates longshot opportunities when conditions align favorably. His partnership with Justin Lewis produces consistent results in claiming races.
Cynthia McKee operates at 18% wins with 48% in-the-money finishes. Her barn specializes in West Virginia-bred horses and understanding state-bred conditions. McKee's partnership with Reshawn Latchman creates competitive combinations across multiple racing levels. She excels at improving claimed horses and identifying proper placement spots.
Best Wagering Strategies and Value Plays
The evening card presents multiple single opportunities in races where dominant connections align with favorable conditions. Race 3 features Magic Moon Spell for the Williams/Bocachica combination coming off an impressive maiden victory. While likely short-priced, this represents the card's most reliable single for horizontal wagers.
Race 7 showcases Runaldo for the Runco/Bocachica partnership with proven stakes credentials dropping into allowance company. His class advantage combined with elite connections creates bankable single opportunity despite potentially prohibitive odds.
The Pick 4 covering Races 5 through 8 offers value construction. Spread Race 5 using Climate Change, Slewing, Lucky Bop, and Cicatriz. Race 6 requires wide coverage given the twelve-horse field and low claiming level – use six horses including Little Bit Risky, Valore, Solomons Gold, Feast, Strive for Stride, and Smooth Rico. Single Race 7 with Runaldo given his class advantage. Spread Race 8 using Ray's Blue Wagon, Platinum Ghost, Masterwork, Strasse, and Abuelo Paps.
Race 2 presents the card's best value opportunity with Howler shipping from Laurel with Angel Cruz. The combination of quality shipper, elite rider making rare Charles Town appearance, and competitive odds creates overlay potential. Use Howler in exactas over Party Time For Me and Allformenoneforyou while including her in wider trifecta coverage.
Daily double opportunities connecting Races 2 and 3 provide value. Key Howler in Race 2 with Magic Moon Spell in Race 3 as a straight daily double while adding Party Time For Me and Allformenoneforyou in Race 2 with Night Quest and Cheese N Crackers in Race 3 for wider coverage.
The late Pick 3 covering Races 6, 7, and 8 requires aggressive spreading in Race 6, singling Runaldo in Race 7, and moderate spreading in Race 8. This structure maximizes value by concentrating investment on the reliable Race 7 single while covering chaos in the surrounding claiming routes.
Win betting should focus on overlays where morning line odds exceed realistic winning probability. Howler in Race 2, Little Bit Risky in Race 6, and Wiffleball in Race 7 represent potential overlay candidates if public betting concentrates heavily on favorites.
Exacta wagering produces optimal value in races featuring dominant favorites with competitive secondary horses. Race 3's Magic Moon Spell over Night Quest and Cheese N Crackers creates solid exacta structure. Race 7's Runaldo over Dorado and Moonlit Notion provides exacta value despite short win odds on the favorite.
Place and show betting becomes strategic on short-priced favorites in competitive fields. Magic Moon Spell to place in Race 3 and Runaldo to show in Race 7 provide reduced risk while maintaining reasonable return potential if favorites encounter traffic or pace issues.
