Pick Pony Picks – Consensus Expert Picks for Keeneland Race Course, April 17, 2026.


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Consensus Expert Picks

Consensus rankings based on 12 experts. Scoring: 1st pick = 4 pts, 2nd = 3 pts, 3rd = 2 pts, 4th = 1 pt. Agreement % = share of experts that included each horse.

Race 1

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Starwood (3)2-110/1283.3%33 pts
2Buckeye Bombshell (4)1-110/1283.3%29 pts
3Olympic Star (1)4-16/1250.0%15 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4She's Gotta Go (2)15-15/1241.7%16 pts
5Watershed Moment (6)8-11/128.3%2 pts
6Tiz Laws Hall (7)10-11/128.3%2 pts
7Howyoudosomething (5)6-10/120.0%0 pts

Race 2

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Horsing Around (2)2-110/1283.3%34 pts
2Sutura (5)4-19/1275.0%24 pts
3Starship Godiva (3)3-16/1250.0%15 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4Cat Island (1)8-14/1233.3%12 pts
5Smokin Hot Stuff (4)6-12/1216.7%6 pts
6Endless Glory (8)15-12/1216.7%6 pts
7Maxi Maxi (7)10-10/120.0%0 pts
8Naukarezza (6)20-10/120.0%0 pts

Race 3

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Yes It Tiz (5)3-19/1275.0%30 pts
2Senza Parole (3)1-19/1275.0%27 pts
3Queen Azteca (2)4-16/1250.0%18 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4Table Flirt (1)8-15/1241.7%12 pts
5Cat's Cave (6)4-14/1233.3%10 pts
6Peak Popularity (4)20-10/120.0%0 pts

Race 4

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Mighty Nora (1)2-110/1283.3%33 pts
2Noroomformischief (2)6-17/1258.3%20 pts
3Grace Of Monaco (6)4-15/1241.7%12 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4Lunar Loop (3)4-13/1225.0%12 pts
5Good Graces (5)8-13/1225.0%8 pts
6Weetamoo (7)6-12/1216.7%6 pts
7Debby's Gal (9)12-12/1216.7%5 pts
8Tiz A Princess (4)15-11/128.3%1 pts
9Donna Strada (8)30-10/120.0%0 pts

Race 5

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Murdock (3)3-19/1275.0%32 pts
2Longshoreman (9)6-16/1250.0%21 pts
3Ambitiously (2)8-15/1241.7%14 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4Innate (10)4-13/1225.0%7 pts
5Pivotal Moment (7)4-12/1216.7%6 pts
6Jimmy Rules (8)8-12/1216.7%6 pts
7Expressway (5)15-11/128.3%2 pts
8Military Cruiser (1)20-11/128.3%2 pts
9Utopian (6)20-10/120.0%0 pts
10Snare (4)12-10/120.0%0 pts

Race 6

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Bold Journey (2)2-110/1283.3%30 pts
2American Monarch (3)2-17/1258.3%18 pts
3Illuminare (6)8-15/1241.7%17 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4Durante (1)8-15/1241.7%16 pts
5Little Ni (4)3-13/1225.0%7 pts
6Normandy Coast (5)6-12/1216.7%6 pts

Race 7

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Next Up (1)1-112/12100.0%43 pts
2Dozen Diamonds (3)6-17/1258.3%20 pts
3Thatsalrightmama (2)4-14/1233.3%13 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4Cara Felce (7)15-13/1225.0%6 pts
5Latte Lizzie (4)10-12/1216.7%5 pts
6Scribble (5)12-12/1216.7%5 pts
7Surprenant Cocca (8)8-12/1216.7%4 pts
8Champagne Nights (9)20-11/128.3%1 pts
9Mint Driven (6)30-10/120.0%0 pts

Race 8

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Beer Run (3)2-111/1291.7%40 pts
2Double Talker (7)4-16/1250.0%21 pts
3Unitas (10)4-15/1241.7%13 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4Strate Cash (6)8-15/1241.7%11 pts
5Atlal (1)4-13/1225.0%6 pts
6Big Garry (8)30-11/128.3%2 pts
7Moon Sniper (5)20-11/128.3%2 pts
8Razorcat (2)12-11/128.3%2 pts
9Uncle Bucky (9)20-10/120.0%0 pts
10Frontier Justice (4)30-10/120.0%0 pts

Race 9

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1Alpine Princess (1)2-110/1283.3%31 pts
2Gin Gin (4)2-19/1275.0%29 pts
3Eunomia (3)4-17/1258.3%20 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4Running Away (6)4-12/1216.7%5 pts
5Aye Candy (2)20-12/1216.7%3 pts
6Ourdaydreaminggirl (5)20-11/128.3%4 pts
7Peignoir (7)10-11/128.3%2 pts
8Chilled (8)15-10/120.0%0 pts

Race 10

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
1She Wants War (3)2-110/1190.9%33 pts
2Amani's Music (5)4-18/1172.7%26 pts
3Twirling Claire (7)4-17/1163.6%19 pts

Alternatives

#HorseMLExpertsAgreementScore
4Fool's Adventure (2)3-16/1154.5%14 pts
5Loriebeth (1)30-11/119.1%1 pts
6Poverty With Aview (10)20-10/110.0%0 pts
7Sheer Jazz (12)30-10/110.0%0 pts
8Toast The Star (8)12-10/110.0%0 pts
9Heitzgirl (6)15-10/110.0%0 pts
10La Puma (13)30-10/110.0%0 pts
11Whiskey Serenade (11)30-10/110.0%0 pts
12Army Chic (4)20-10/110.0%0 pts
13Swirling Seas (9)15-10/110.0%0 pts
14New Rose (14)20-10/110.0%0 pts

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback