Posted inAnalysis

Pick Pony Picks – Consensus Expert Picks for Penn National, March 18, 2026.

No CommentsPosted inAnalysis


Get more in-depth analysis, expert picks, handicapper reports, AI picks, handicapping tools, in-article data tooltips, NO ADVERTISEMENTS, and other membership perks with a Pick Pony subscription!

Pick Pony takes pride in providing the most accurate expert picks available today. Pick Pony Expert Picks are carefully selected by our team of analysts based on analytics from our advanced Past Performance Sheets and Racing Forms. For potential longshot selections, check out Pick Pony's AI Picks.

Race 1 – Claiming – 8F 70Y – Dirt – Purse: n/a

Win: The Feisty One (1) – 40% confidence

Place: Shining Spirit (3) – 35% confidence

Show: Roman Goddess (5) – 15% confidence

Alternative: Wink Of An Eye (4) – 10% confidence

Race notes: Analysts generally expect The Feisty One (1) and Shining Spirit (3) to control the race flow, with Roman Goddess (5) and Wink Of An Eye (4) filling out exotics. Pace projects honest with multiple stalkers, which slightly upgrades The Feisty One (1) as a forward type.

Other runners include: Bugged Out (2), Hay Hay Paula (6).

Race 2 – Claiming – 1320Y – Dirt – Purse: n/a

Win: No No Joe (3) – 55% confidence

Place: Boss Holiday (1) – 30% confidence

Show: Lieutenant Stan (5) – 10% confidence

Alternative: Trophy Room (7) – 5% confidence

Race notes: No No Joe (3) is seen as the most likely winner, but Boss Holiday (1) retains plenty of respect and could make this a two-horse battle late. Lieutenant Stan (5) and Trophy Room (7) shape as typical underneath keys in exactas and trifectas for many analysts.

Other runners include: Big Beemster (2), Pentatonic (4), Eddiemush (6).

Race 3 – Starter Optional Claiming – 1320Y – Dirt – Purse: n/a

Win: Capos Sugar Kane (5) – 40% confidence

Place: Edge Of The Blade (3) – 25% confidence

Show: Music Clarifcation (7) – 20% confidence

Alternative: Java Tales (6) – 15% confidence

Race notes: Analysts cluster strongly around Capos Sugar Kane (5) but concede that Edge Of The Blade (3) has upside on the drop and could prove the main danger. Music Clarifcation (7) and Java Tales (6) are widely used as underneath pieces, suggesting a relatively formful trifecta profile.

Other runners include: Avril (1), Azami (2), Lady Ahava (4).

Race 4 – Claiming – 1210Y – Dirt – Purse: n/a

Win: Arrogante (2) – 40% confidence

Place: G's Fireball (3) – 25% confidence

Show: Warrior's Treasure (6) – 25% confidence

Alternative: Queen Wiggy (1) – 10% confidence

Race notes: Opinion in this race tilts mildly toward Arrogante (2), though G's Fireball (3) and Warrior's Treasure (6) both attract serious win and underneath support. Many analysts regard Queen Wiggy (1) as a price horse with back class and fitness questions, landing more often in wider exotics than on top.

Other runners include: Pretty Lily (4), Style To Follow (5).

Race 5 – Claiming – 8F – Dirt – Purse: n/a

Win: What Does It Take (6) – 55% confidence

Place: Gun Right (2) – 35% confidence

Show: Makabim (3) – 5% confidence

Alternative: Martini Martin (1) – 5% confidence

Race notes: Analysts overwhelmingly side with What Does It Take (6) or Gun Right (2) as the key outcome, framing this as a strong two-horse axis. Makabim (3) and Martini Martin (1) show up mostly on the bottom of vertical tickets, implying a fairly chalky projected structure unless pace collapses late.

Other runners include: Sir Cupid (4), Guns N' Rojas (5), Bullet Breeze (7).

Race 6 – Claiming – 8F – Dirt – Purse: n/a

Win: Waldrip (5) – 70% confidence

Place: Metalhead (3) – 20% confidence

Show: My Redemption (2) – 5% confidence

Alternative: Last Romance (1) – 5% confidence

Race notes: Waldrip (5) is one of the most trusted horses on the card, with analysts nearly unanimous about his superiority at this level and distance. Metalhead (3) and My Redemption (2) profile as logical chasers, while Last Romance (1) is viewed as a minor upset candidate who could sneak into multi-race tickets.

Other runners include: Sapphire Prince (4), Striking Sparks (6), Hope's Alive (7).

Race 7 – Claiming – 1320Y – Dirt – Purse: n/a

Win: I Once Stood Alone (6) – 40% confidence

Place: Inter Miami (3) – 25% confidence

Show: Mischief Warrior (1) – 20% confidence

Alternative: Joking Way (5) – 15% confidence

Race notes: Analysts are somewhat divided, but I Once Stood Alone (6) is the narrow top choice, with Inter Miami (3) a live alternative based on expected improvement. Mischief Warrior (1) and Joking Way (5) are widely used for vertical depth and could help inflate exotic payouts if either wins.

Other runners include: Book Marker (2), Swing Oil (4), Eclipticals Bear (7).

Race 8 – Maiden Claiming – 1320Y – Dirt – Purse: n/a

Win: Desperate Dreams (4) – 70% confidence

Place: Adamiscashingin (2) – 15% confidence

Show: Craving Carbs (3) – 10% confidence

Alternative: Lemonade Sprinkles (1) – 5% confidence

Race notes: This is another race where analysts exhibit strong conviction, with Desperate Dreams (4) widely viewed as the most likely winner on class and recency. Adamiscashingin (2), Craving Carbs (3), and Lemonade Sprinkles (1) rotate through underneath spots, making the race fertile ground for structured exacta and trifecta plays around a strong single.

Other runners include: Just A Click (5), Brockcasso (6), In The Biz (7), Spicy Bubba (8).

Recommended Exotic Plays by Race

Race 1 – Recommended Exotics

Analysts often build exactas around The Feisty One (1) and Shining Spirit (3), using Roman Goddess (5) and Wink Of An Eye (4) underneath in second and third. A common trifecta structure is The Feisty One (1), Shining Spirit (3) over The Feisty One (1), Shining Spirit (3), Roman Goddess (5), Wink of an Eye (4) over those four plus Bugged Out (2) at a price. Superfecta players may consider keying The Feisty One (1) and Shining Spirit (3) on top while spreading with Roman Goddess (5), Wink of an Eye (4), Bugged Out (2), and Hay Hay Paula (6) for fourth. Multi-race sequences can legitimately start with The Feisty One (1) and Shining Spirit (3) as A-level tickets, with Roman Goddess (5) as a B-type backup.

Race 2 – Recommended Exotics

Given the strong sentiment around No No Joe (3), many analysts recommend him as a key in exactas over Boss Holiday (1) and Lieutenant Stan (5). Trifectas frequently use No No Joe (3) in the win slot, with Boss Holiday (1) and Lieutenant Stan (5) in second and a spread including Trophy Room (7) and Pentatonic (4) in third. A value-oriented superfecta wheel might go No No Joe (3) over Boss Holiday (1), Lieutenant Stan (5), Trophy Room (7) over those three plus Pentatonic (4), Big Beemster (2), and Eddiemush (6). In daily doubles and pick 3s, No No Joe (3) is often treated as a near-single, with Boss Holiday (1) used lightly as coverage where budget allows.

Race 3 – Recommended Exotics

Capos Sugar Kane (5) is often keyed on top in exactas over Edge Of The Blade (3) and Music Clarifcation (7), reflecting the consensus that these three are most likely to dominate. Trifecta constructions such as Capos Sugar Kane (5) over Edge of the Blade (3), Music Clarifcation (7), Java Tales (6) over those three plus Java Tales (6) are common. For superfectas, many analysts add Azami (2) and Lady Ahava (4) to the third and fourth slots seeking a mild upset underneath. Multi-race players frequently lean on Capos Sugar Kane (5) as an A, with Edge of the Blade (3) as a backup and Music Clarifcation (7) used primarily underneath in verticals.

Race 4 – Recommended Exotics

Arrogante (2), G's Fireball (3), and Warrior's Treasure (6) are the core exotic horses for most analysts. Exactas like Arrogante (2) over G's Fireball (3), Warrior's Treasure (6) and reverse combinations are commonly proposed. Trifectas often key Arrogante (2) and G's Fireball (3) in first and second, using Warrior's Treasure (6) and Queen Wiggy (1) in third. For superfectas, including Queen Wiggy (1), Pretty Lily (4), and Style To Follow (5) beneath the main three may create payoff separation in what otherwise appears a compact field. Multi-race sequences usually treat Arrogante (2) as the primary win candidate, with G's Fireball (3) and Warrior's Treasure (6) as necessary backups.

Race 5 – Recommended Exotics

What Does It Take (6) and Gun Right (2) form a strong exacta and daily double anchor, with analysts frequently boxing that pair on top. Trifectas commonly use What Does It Take (6), Gun Right (2) over What Does It Take (6), Gun Right (2), Makabim (3) over those three plus Martini Martin (1). Some superfecta strategies expand further to include Guns N' Rojas (5) and Sir Cupid (4) in the bottom slot, anticipating a pace-induced collapse or trip chaos. In pick 3 and pick 4 sequences, What Does It Take (6) is often singled, with Gun Right (2) reserved for backup tickets or value-focused coverage.

Race 6 – Recommended Exotics

Many analysts treat Waldrip (5) as a strong single in multi-race bets, allowing more coverage elsewhere on the card. Vertical exotics often key Waldrip (5) on top of exactas over Metalhead (3) and My Redemption (2). Trifectas such as Waldrip (5) over Metalhead (3), My Redemption (2), Last Romance (1) over those three plus Sapphire Prince (4) and Striking Sparks (6) are frequently suggested. Superfecta approaches tend to be lean, using Waldrip (5) over two or three logicals in second and third and then spreading modestly for fourth, preserving bankroll for races with more chaos potential.

Race 7 – Recommended Exotics

Race 7 is considered a better spot for spreading, as the consensus is thinner and several runners can win. Exacta boxes involving I Once Stood Alone (6), Inter Miami (3), and Mischief Warrior (1) are common, with Joking Way (5) added for price leverage. Trifectas might go I Once Stood Alone (6), Inter Miami (3) over I Once Stood Alone (6), Inter Miami (3), Mischief Warrior (1), Joking Way (5) over those four plus Swing Oil (4). Some superfecta tickets key I Once Stood Alone (6) and Inter Miami (3) in first and second, but many analysts encourage using multiple combinations to capture the expected variance. Multi-race sequences through this race typically use at least three A/B-level horses rather than singling.

Race 8 – Recommended Exotics

Desperate Dreams (4) is the preferred single in late pick 3s and pick 4s, with many analysts comfortable leaning heavily on this runner. Exactas often key Desperate Dreams (4) over Adamiscashingin (2) and Craving Carbs (3), with some tickets including Lemonade Sprinkles (1) as a saver in second. Trifecta plays such as Desperate Dreams (4) over Adamiscashingin (2), Craving Carbs (3), Lemonade Sprinkles (1) over those three plus Just A Click (5) are popular. Superfecta structures broaden to include Brockcasso (6), In The Biz (7), and Spicy Bubba (8) for fourth, capturing a more chaotic outcome underneath a strong favorite.

Value Play Observations

Across Race 1, The Feisty One (1) appears likely to be well-found on the board, but the consensus still leaves room for Shining Spirit (3) to be an overlay if the market leans too heavily on last-out winning form. Roman Goddess (5) and Wink Of An Eye (4) profile as likely underlays if they are bet near co-favorite status given their typical positioning in analysts' exotics rather than on top.

Race 2 positions No No Joe (3) as a probable short-priced favorite, and any drift above a clear odds-on level would arguably be fair given the strength of support. Boss Holiday (1) may be slightly overbet off name familiarity and consistent placings, while Lieutenant Stan (5) could become a value play underneath if overlooked compared with Trophy Room (7).

In Race 3, Capos Sugar Kane (5) is treated as the most likely winner but not with the same unanimity seen in a horse like Waldrip (5), suggesting moderate favorite status is justified but a very short price might be an underlay. Edge Of The Blade (3) and Music Clarifcation (7) both offer potential overlay profiles if they float above mid-single digits, given their frequent mention as win or place candidates.

Race 4's spread between Arrogante (2), G's Fireball (3), and Warrior's Treasure (6) implies that any one of them could be an overlay depending on tote behavior; for example, if Warrior's Treasure (6) sticks near a mid-range price despite repeat mentions, it becomes interesting. Queen Wiggy (1) is more of a speculative longshot, and would only qualify as a value play if her price drifts far beyond the morning line while still representing a legitimate pace or class angle.

Race 5 shows one of the clearest two-horse setups, with What Does It Take (6) and Gun Right (2) likely to absorb most win money; here, Makabim (3) could be an overlay in verticals if left at a double-digit price given analysts' willingness to use this horse for third. Martini Martin (1) is similarly positioned as a fringe contender that may outrun odds in deeper exotics.

In Race 6, Waldrip (5) will probably be a heavy favorite and may even be an underlay if the market pushes the price below fair odds implied by a roughly 70% consensus win view. Metalhead (3) and My Redemption (2) look like classic value keys in exactas and trifectas if bettors overly fixate on Waldrip (5) while ignoring the likely second and third choices.

Race 7's divided opinion suggests that any runner—especially I Once Stood Alone (6), Inter Miami (3), Mischief Warrior (1), or Joking Way (5)—could represent value if the board heavily favors just one. This is the sort of race where a disciplined bettor can gain edge by leaning into price sensitivity and backing the best-value among the top four rather than the most-touted single horse.

Race 8 is structured around Desperate Dreams (4) as a probable solid favorite, but overlay opportunities may emerge with Adamiscashingin (2) and Craving Carbs (3) if they drift to generous prices while still being widely cited as logical underneath horses. Lemonade Sprinkles (1) may become attractive for deeper trifectas and superfectas if allowed to go off at a long price despite having a consistent place-focused profile.

Overall Wagering Strategy

Strongest consensus races on this card appear to be Race 6 with Waldrip (5) and Race 8 with Desperate Dreams (4), followed closely by Race 5 where What Does It Take (6) and Gun Right (2) dominate analyst opinion. In these spots, the most efficient approach for experienced bettors is often to accept the short price in multi-race bets, treating Waldrip (5) and Desperate Dreams (4) as primary singles while using the Race 5 pair as a small two-deep anchor leg. This allows bankroll to be conserved for more contentious races where real value is more likely to surface.

Split-opinion races include Race 3, Race 4, and especially Race 7, where several horses share similar support bands in analysts' rankings. In these events, the analytical tension lies between trusting the slight consensus (for example, Capos Sugar Kane (5) in Race 3 and Arrogante (2) in Race 4) versus leaning into price-driven decisions on co-favored types like Edge Of The Blade (3) or Warrior's Treasure (6). A prudent wagering approach emphasizes spreading in these races using value-based line-making, rather than locking into a single narrative.

Multi-race sequences such as early pick 3s and pick 4s can be framed around the higher-confidence legs in Races 2, 5, 6, and 8. Race 2 offers No No Joe (3) as a near-A single, Race 5 and Race 6 provide strong backbone positions, and Race 8 features a likely key in Desperate Dreams (4). By structuring tickets with narrow coverage in these legs and broader coverage in Races 1, 3, 4, and 7, bettors can exploit carryover potential and reduce exposure to volatility while still embracing the card's most uncertain spots where overlays are more likely.

Exotic value opportunities are most pronounced in the mid-card claiming events where field depth and pace dynamics create genuine upset possibilities, notably Race 3 and Race 7. In these races, superfecta wheels and four- or five-horse trifecta combinations centered on one or two mild preferences can be constructed at relatively modest cost while still capturing sizeable payouts if a secondary analyst choice or lightly regarded closer hits the frame. Exacta and trifecta strategies should generally be tighter in high-consensus races, focusing on maximizing return from logical outcomes rather than chasing big scores.

Environmental and track factors, including cool temperatures and a dirt surface expected to play fairly, suggest that recent local form and tactical speed should remain reliable guides rather than extreme bias-driven angles. Pace projections in several events indicate honest to slightly pressured setups rather than meltdown scenarios, which supports the emphasis analysts place on forwardly placed runners like The Feisty One (1), Gun Right (2), and Waldrip (5). Still, bettors should monitor early races for any emergent inside or outside bias and adjust later multi-race bets accordingly.

Key takeaways are that bettors should be willing to lean heavily on Waldrip (5) and Desperate Dreams (4) as structural pillars, allowing more aggressive spreading in contentious races where consensus is weaker. At the same time, races such as Race 3 and Race 7 invite creative exotic constructions that can leverage modest opinions into outsized returns without excessive risk. Finally, staying flexible with in-running tote assessment—especially where analyst consensus and market pricing diverge—will be critical to maximizing edge across the card.

Tags:

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Talkback